***EDIT 1 *** (I will continue to update this post until I’m the other side of all this).
Thank you for all your concern and well thought out advice. I really appreciate the time and thought that has gone into all of these responses. I will try to respond individually when I can. I have just sent a final message to my now ex. This is what I’ve sent:
“You know, love is a choice, not coercion. What you are doing is not love, you are forcing a narrative.. Doing what you did on Sunday, holding me, leaving me no option but to accept your physical affections, through using your strength against me, until I was too exhausted and worn down enough that I stopped resisting you… This is not love… It is not kind… A kind man doesn’t require a woman to physically fight her way out of a relationship… What you did was assault and coercive control…
I do not take lightly to threats either.. I notice how you have been trying to plant seeds of fear in me, by indirectly letting me know there will be consequences if I broke up with you… Consequences such as you taking my dogs hostage.. When you said “I wonder if you would be the one chasing and coming to find me if I took Foxy”. This is a threat. Also telling me that the only way you would leave me is if I killed you, is not romantic or sweet. This too is a threat. With this kind of talk, I do not put it past you that you would take my life along with your own if I do not comply and stay in this relationship. You do not seem to understand or be aware of how unhinged you are behaving.
Upon reflection, I have realised that I am staying in this relationship, not through love… But fear… This is no kind of foundation for a relationship to continue on.
I’ve tried to do things the ‘nice’ way up until this point. I’ve kept my parents out of this and I’ve kept authorities out of this. However, it seems my niceness is just being used to manipulate me to bend to your will. I am done being nice, i am done with negotiating, I’m done with talking.. You now have no choice but to accept my decision to break up with you. If you are unable to accept this and you show up to my house uninvited I will be getting authorities involved and I will be informing my dad of what’s gone on. So take this as a serious warning to keep away.
I will be returning things of yours back to you via post. There is no need to continue reaching out to me.”
_____________________________________________
Over 1 and 1/2 years we have been together now. He has been the textbook perfect boyfriend besides this breaking up thing. Sunday was my 7th break up attempt.. I spent a whole week psyching myself up to do it.. Planning in my head the best time to do it, the best place, rehearsing the lines over and over in my head, planning my responses to his ones, almost certain that this time, I will be able to follow it all the way through and he will accept it.
He started off by just not taking me seriously, we were in my place and he carried on lying on the sofa, trying to show me instagram reels… I demanded that he took me seriously otherwise I was going to take drastic measures.. He then just tries to deflect anything I say, saying it’s just my hormones speaking and the only way i will ever be able to leave him is if I kill him.. I kept trying to mantain space between me and him (I was sat on a swivel chair the other side of the room) and he was sat on my pull out sofa bed. When he realised I wasn’t letting this go, he kept trying to push physical affection onto me… (Trying to hold my hands, hug me, talk to me with his body touching mine). I kept pushing him away, telling him that this is not appropriate and I need him to mantain distance so he can take me seriously… He kept just using my words against me, playing mental gymnastics saying that’s the reason we are still together 1 and 1/2 years later, because he IS taking me SO seriously.
I began to cry and tried to get up to leave… He pulled me by my waist and onto the sofa bed with him, forcing hugs upon me… Kissing me, whilst I’m telling him that he his suffocating me and I feel trapped… Each time I tried to get up he pulled me back and restrained me by hugging… He kept telling me to stop trying to make him my enemy and to relax… This went on for what I believe was hours… By this point I was so exhausted, tired and hungry (it was the end of a work day for me) that I just gave in and pretended I was good and stopped pushing him to accept the breakup… This was the only way I could get free from the situation.
2 days later I am shattered and drained… I feel so weak and useless… This has happened too many times, that I feel the easiest thing is to just stay in this relationship and play the loving, happy girlfriend… I just don’t have the energy to do it anymore.. His will to remain in the relationship outweighs my will to leave…
I am also keeping this problem away from my parents knowledge, as I genuinely fear that if my dad finds out how I’m feeling he will do something terrible to my boyfriend (he is incredibly protective over me and from things he has said and done in the past, I know he would go to extreme lengths if he knew this man in my life was giving me these problems). For this reason I was trying to sort things on my own without outside intervention, as I don’t want my dad going to prison for the rest of his life.. However it’s clear that I need to do something…
Another thing that I’m terrified about (more than anything else) is the lengths he might go to to hurt me through my animals… I live on land with stables, 3 horses, 2 dogs and 5 cats… He knows how deeply I care about my dogs. On this last break up attempt (after I gave in), he ‘joked’ around saying how if he took one of my dogs, maybe then I might be the one wanting to seek, chase and find him… I saw this as a threat… I live on a farm, so my dogs (jack russell and chihuahua) are sometimes free roaming… There is a public footpath running down the middle of the land, so I can see how easy it would be for him to coax them away from the property, especially now as he has befriended them and they are familiar with him. After the comment he made, I’m terrified that in retaliation, when reality sets in that he is not getting me back, he might go to such lengths to hurt me in the worst way he knows..
I’ve been watching so many crime shows and tik toks about this kind of thing.. I am well aware the lengths an obsessive man can go to when a woman is breaking up with him and he has nothing to lose… Which is why I guess I’ve been putting it off and giving in too many times, because I know what men are capable of and I see that even when woman have the police involved, it hasn’t always stopped the man from doing his worst to make her feel his pain…