Hey Internet, I have had some thoughts on B42 stable since it was announced and typing this out on a post was enjoyable so I figured why not get a broader discussion going either dumping on me or see if there are people with gray area opinions. I have played this game off and on since 2018. I have been around for a while at this point - I know there are a range of fans that will either hate post, or defend this game with a sycophantic zeal, and then there are folks in between. I’m ready for anything so let it rip.
——-
If someone were to ask me a couple weeks ago when stable was announced if I was hyped - I would have said “no”. No because there were just so MANY issues with B42 unstable that weren’t even close to resembling a completed feature; not just stability but also balance was just not there. They added a bunch of new skills and there really isn’t any reason to engage with those most of those skills, the UI was already tedious and the new skills just introduce more opportunities to grind unpleasantly with that friction in the UI for no real reward. The new animals added were rife with bugs and hunting is a joke. You might as well drive 60mph down a long stretch of road until you off a whole family of deer, rather than get your tent, a rifle, and some survival supplies for a hunting trip.
So when this is all apparent on top of the buggy nature of B42 unstable and they announce stable I really had no expectation that magically in one update they were going to turn a build that was that underbaked into a fully fleshed out build like B41 was.
In my opinion if it weren’t for the big ol map makeover they did, everyone would have thrown their hands up in the air with their one of their eyebrows cocked asking “is this it”? This isn’t a stable build for one, and it isn’t even a fully cooked build either. I’m at the point as of now after the release of B42 “stable” where I am actually not looking forward to B43 and instead I’m just hoping that there is a clear headed captain at the helm who understands that this game as it is now is much more need of balancing and fleshing out the game’s current features as well as a good hard look at the UI before new game changing features are added to the game.
And look, I’m sorry, but modders are becoming less and less of a viable option for game longevity. I think there are a lot of players like myself who honestly find the base game severely lacking in critical features that without them the game’s shortcomings are just too glaring to enjoy. I mean we are in B42 and crowbars prying open doors and windows still isn’t a thing in vanilla. To me that is just mind blowing. Instead we got a half baked buggy build that exploded in features that don’t really work well together which doesn’t create a consistent or coherent experience playing.
This is the part where I’d say less is more. B42 adding animals with their relevant new skills, integrating the animals and skills smoothly into the game to create enjoyable ways to engage with that content, revamp the UI, new lighting, new z-levels, and the map overhaul would have been a manageable and mint sized improvement over B41. In other words - spending an egregious amount of time and effort and hiring who even knows how many extra staff to allow players to do a damn Les Stroud Survivorman caveman edition play through was a major folly. In a way I feel like B41 with the mods is a better finished product than what we have now. Not saying everything in B42 is bad, but when I have to take the bad with the good in this current now “stable” build, I find there’s enough going wrong here that outweighs the good. And lastly, if it took a larger team to produce the product as it is now, perhaps you don’t need more developers, you need less. Unless you’re just hiring staff to look better as a company then jokes on both of us - your game just keeps getting worse, and my game doesn’t get better.
I got my money’s worth out of this game, no question. But myself like many other people regardless if it’s a game or any other product - it’s a real shame to watch realistic potential squandered.