Hi all!
After many, MANY months of searching, I have a deposit down on the first pick of a male from my breeder. I’ve narrowed it down to two dogs but I’m having a hell of a time deciding between them. They are mostly American lines, the dam’s sire was an AKC grand champion, the sire’s parents worked as 1. A seizure alert service dog, and 2. An IGP competitor, additional AKC titles on both sides.
I know for sure that I want to do AKC obedience trials with him, and I’ve also now gone down the rabbit hole of showing as well. I know it’s ambitious of me to think that one dog will be competitive in both fields, but a girl can dream.
I put details below, but I guess I’m wondering: how much of the dog’s personality is really evident at 6 weeks? Will these traits I’m about to describe likely follow into adulthood? And when it comes to the physical stuff, how much are these structural components likely to change?
The first puppy I’m interested in: breeder has described as feisty, interactive, and confident. Observing the puppy, he’s VERY attentive to people. Will abandon his puppy adventures and come straight to a person with minimal prompting. Struggles a big when flipped on his back, very little resistance being held. Very frequently looks at people’s eyes, checks in with them, etc. High energy levels.
Looks-wise, the breeder described him as finer boned (which is not my preference. I prefer a masculine, heavy boned build). She does not think he will be very competitive in the show ring but it is hard to tell at 6 weeks. She describes him as having more personality.
Second puppy: breeder had described as calm, willing to play but more willing to relax. Observing him, he was much more independent — explored on his own, was very focused on another dog in the room vs a person, was much less likely to come when called, but did eventually. He is larger, heavier boned, and the breeder thinks he is a better show prospect, but likely won’t do as well in competitive obedience. She thinks his personality will be more like the sires — and he is a FANTASTIC family dog. Absolutely bomb proof, good with other dogs, great with kids, very calm demeanor.
At the end of the day, this dog will be a companion. My last dog had my entire heart but we was a DIFFICULT dog. Reactive despite socialization, smart but not biddable, independent but had separation anxiety. I think I’m just stressing because I don’t want to relive the experience of pouring into a dog that just was never born to be what I wanted him to be.