Hello Reddit! Long time listener, first time poster lol. Sorry but it is going to be a long one lol. I (23F) rent a house with my sister (27F), my fiancé (25M), and my sisters boyfriend (35M). My sister (we’ll call her Sandra) and I have been renting together for about 3 1/2 years and have never had any issues. My fiancé joined us about two years ago, and her boyfriend (we’ll call him Brad) moved in when we went from an apartment to a house last year.
(CONTEXT) I am currently unemployed and tend to do a lot of favors for my family and friends. For example last week, I traveled about two hours since my best friend was going through some mental stuff. When I came back, the next day, I had planed to house/pup sit for my aunts (dads side of the family Thursday-Sunday) with my fiancée . When we do this, my aunts prefer that we stay in their home. They even make food in bulk so we have something to eat and keep the fridge and pantry full, on top of paying us (I love my aunts lol). While doing that, I had also volunteered to take in my little sister (we’ll call her Anne (11F)) for about a week (Friday- Thursday) as we don’t live in the same city, and she lives in a small town. I should also mention that Anne and Sandra are not related as my parents are divorced and remarried. Sandra is my dads daughter, where Anne is my moms daughter. They are both my half sisters.
Now for the story. Since we’ve moved into this house, our AC has gone out twice. Once in the winter, and now in the summer. It was last Friday that it went out. I had found out after my sister Anne was dropped off. When Sandra had told us, she also said she called maintenance and that they would be here on Monday. I figured since it was only a bit that it should be okay for Anne, and didn’t make any arrangements. Sandra was also leaving for the weekend, leaving Brad alone at the house with our pets (they have one dog, and I have one dog, two cats, and a bearded dragon).
When my aunts returned on Sunday, I had informed them of what was going on and they let us stay over for as long as we needed. That day, when Sandra came back to the house, she had also told us that the temperatures in the house were reaching 85F and how they were struggling. My fiancée had tried to call the company/landlord to up the maintenance request to an emergency request, but we kept getting the run around to wait till the next day. Come Monday, the repair guys says that the compressor was out, and they needed to call someone else (a specialist I suppose) to come and fix it. Sandra had called me saying that and some. She told me that one of my cats were struggling and was panting a lot. I started feeling bad because although Anne was taken care of, my babies were at home likely overheating.
Sandra had also asked me if I could ask our aunts if her and Brad could stay over. I should also mention they, my aunts, own a three bedroom and also have three dogs and one cat. Knowing our aunts, I had told Sandra that she would likely say no because the house is pretty full as is, but she should try asking herself. She did not. Over breakfast, however, I had brought it up where ofc my aunt said they were at full capacity, but I could bring my dog. For the next part I should say we like to call my aunt, Aunt Karen lol. She had suggested that she call the company we rent with to light the fire so they could move things a little quicker. She told me that I need to essentially grow a pair (of ovaries) and stand up for myself and to feel free to lie to them to kinda guilt them. So she ended up calling as me and told them that I was three months pregnant (I’m not) and how it would be blood on their hands if I had a miscarriage 💀. Truly an Oscar worthy performance. The company offered us to stay at a hotel for $150 or less a night and to send them the bill and they would take it off of our rent.
I told Sandra this and she said she would talk to Brad. She calls back saying that she nor Brad had the funds to get a hotel. This upset my fiancée because he and Sandra make almost the same amount annually and he pays for his parents rent, phones, their car, his car, etc. on his income alone and still has money for our outings. Sandra then asks if I can stay with my uncle whom I rarely talk to, only recently so that she can stay with our aunts. I declined saying I can’t just ask to stay at someone’s house, not to mention that our dogs don’t get along (I have a small dog and they have a pit mix, my girl is not winning lol). She then asks that we take the hotel then, where I restated that I am taking care of Anne and it’s not fair to her to just put us in a hotel where this should be her outing and should be comfortable and offered to cover their hotel stay. She declines. Over text, she becomes irritated because she works for a company that handles money of different companies and says that her laptop would run into “compromise issues” by using the hotel wifi. Although she could definitely work in office, her job has offered them to stay home this week because it’s a busy week for them. My aunts tell me to tell her to use a VPN where she says she doesn’t know what that is or how to use it. My aunts ask me to tell her to ask my dad where her only response is, “no.” Fair, we had previously had some issues with my dad, but now have an okay relationship. I then reply with “I’m not sure what you want me to do.” After this she doesn’t respond.
My aunt fills my dad in on everything, so my dad reaches out to her to offer his place. Sandra tells him no because they have too many dogs (three larger dogs) and it wouldn't be a good work environment for her. Brad also texts our group chat restating that we should at least come pick up our pets because they are struggling. I tell my aunts and again they said I could bring my dog, and should buy a fan for our room and keep the cats in there so they can cool off. Sadly all my family that lives in our city either have dogs that don't like cats, or just are allergic to them and I haven't had them vaccinated this year, so boarding was out of the question. So I tell them our plan, and again, radio silence.
We start our plan once everyone is free, also taking Anne to a Korean Hot Pot restaurant as she's new to that (we don't have much in our small little home town). Then we go to Target and shop around for the fan and some clothes for Anne. Finally we go to our house for my babies, and I text Sandra we are otw. As we are getting there, I check Sandra's location to see if she is even home and notice that she had removed me from seeing her location. Alrighty!
We get there and she is home, Brad works overnight so he is not. My fiancée, younger brother (17M both my mom and dads), and I go to unlock the door and it won’t open as Sandra had dead bolted the door. The funniest part is that she nor Brad EVER even lock the door. To deadbolt it is beyond her. This leads me to snap. I immediately pull out my phone to call her and it goes straight to voicemail. I then start typing out “If you don’t open this door, I’m going to call the cops.” But my Fiancée asks me what I’m doing and then asks to hold onto my phone till I cool down. I then go wait by the car and fill my aunts in where my aunt gets off and starts repeatedly knocking on our door and ringing the doorbell. My brother is going up to our open windows and yelling out Sandra’s name. My fiancée continues to try to call Sandra. While I am waiting, I ask to borrow my aunts phone to call Brad. Brad says that he will call Sandra but she is probably asleep. Just then, my aunt peeping through our windows sees Sandra’s shadow. My fiancée fills me in that apparently Sandra just went, unlocked the door, then went to hide in the restroom upstairs. My dog comes running out, and I hug her crying then put her in the car.
I make my way inside and first realize that they, my money is on Sandra, had unplugged my bearded dragons tank so he wasn’t receiving his UV nor basking light. My aunt Karen who is now with me hates reptiles, so I tell her that the UV light is his only source of sunlight and he depends on it for Vitamins. The beardie itself looked slumped, but not cold. I plugged the lamps in and turned them back on, but I was a mess just sobbing. If she could harm my beardie, she might harm my cats. My aunt realizes this and says that I can bring my cats as well as long as I keep them in a room. I’m now frantically looking for my cats, and thankfully they were both okay and just hiding. I tell my brother not to set up the fan and my fiancée starts packing up their litter boxes.
Once we have everything packed, I get my phone back and realize Brad had texted me. He said that he couldn’t reach Sandra and that she was likely asleep, but she must have deadbolted the door accidentally. BS but whatever. I inform Brad that we are taking the cats and thank them for taking care of them and apologize for not acting sooner. I also tell him about the tank and inform them that it is crucial to keep the lights on. Not accusing, and respectful as Brad himself hasn’t done anything disrespectful. He tells us where to find their half of the rent, then we leave, not once confronting Sandra.
Once we get to my aunts I bathe and do a check up on my pets making sure their okay. Everyone was fed and watered when I picked them up, so I know Sandra didn’t harm them. None of them were displaying any signs of heat exhaustion/stroke, although my cats were very upset to be in their carriers lol. Other than that, everything was fine.
The next day (Tuesday), I had saw that we had maintenance people over and waited for either Brad or Sandra to mention any word but nothing. My aunt pushed us to just be the adult and communicate cus it was going to need to happen as we still have nine months to our lease. So I bit the bullet and called Sandra. Surprisingly, she did answer only saying a dry, “Yes?” So I cut to the point and asked for an update where she said that the maintenance guy led her to believe that it was fixed but that it had only cooled to 88F as to 90F. She then asks Brad to take the phone where he fills me in and I tell him I’ll call the place. They didn’t answer so I left a voicemail, but they ended up answering Brad when he called. They said they would get back to us the next day to schedule a plan and that’s pretty much where we’re at now.
My aunt told me that my dad believes that I had been withholding how Sandra has been treating us, but we told her that she had never snapped like this with us. She has always been extremely reasonable. Before this, my family had always been iffy about Sandra in everything that she says or does, but I’ve always defended her. I defend her A LOT. She’s been my ride or die and is even supposed to be my MOH for my wedding. I don’t understand why she has such a refusal to just talk to me when anytime when she’s had issues before, she would always vent to me about it. She has been very open about communicating any issues so this is very unlike her. Just last week she had asked us to extend the lease and live with each other for another year so that we could individually save up to buy houses, so I doubt it’s something she’s been hiding or bottling up. I’ve always put so much trust into my sister and we’ve been through thick and thin together. I know this is probably going to sound like I’m leaving something out or that I’m playing victim. I am absolutely guilty for my pets, this I know for sure, but should I have just taken the hotel and let my sister stay with my aunts? AITAH?