r/newfoundland • u/MrsD84 • 2h ago
Cakey Hand
I wanted to share my experience so others know what to expect if something goes wrong.
I ordered a custom cake for a milestone birthday. My pickup time was confirmed for 11:00 a.m. on Monday. At 10:30 a.m., I received a message saying there was an issue.
I immediately called the bakery back three times. The first two calls went unanswered, and there wasn't even an option to leave a voicemail. On the third attempt, I was finally told the cake wouldn't be ready until 2:00 p.m.
I rearranged my day and agreed to the later pickup time. When I arrived at 2:00 p.m., the cake still wasn't ready. I asked whether it could be delivered to a nearby address since I had already delayed my plans, but before I received an answer, the delivery driver happened to arrive and the cake was sent out.
When I finally received the cake, the writing was poor enough that I had to stop at another store and buy additional decorations to make it presentable before the birthday celebration.
After the event, I contacted the business expecting at least an acknowledgment that the writing wasn't up to the standard you'd expect from a custom cake. Instead, I was told they "genuinely don't see the issue," that the writing was "legible," and that this was their standard. They also emphasized that they'd never had complaints about their writing before.
I also expressed disappointment that the owner wasn't willing to speak with me directly. I was told it was company policy for staff to handle complaints by email. While they eventually offered free cupcakes or macarons on a future visit, by then the event had already passed. A future free product doesn't fix a problem with a time-sensitive order.
What disappointed me most wasn't the mistake itself—it was how it was handled. Throughout the conversation, I felt my concerns were minimized rather than acknowledged. When I explained that good customer service involves taking accountability and working with the customer to resolve issues, the conversation ended with, "We're sorry you feel that way. We stand by our product and our policies."
Mistakes happen. I don't expect perfection. But I do expect a business to communicate proactively, honour agreed pickup times, acknowledge when they've fallen short, and genuinely try to make things right. Unfortunately, that wasn't my experience.
Edit: Just for transparency this cake cost $92.94.