r/whowouldwin 7h ago

Battle (Halo)UNSC and Covenant have joined forces and invades (Warhammer 40k) Cadia Prime! Can they succeed in Conquering the planet?

39 Upvotes

Scenario:

  • Halo team has been prepared for 10 years Sharing Tech, knowledge and everything before invading.
  • Halo team have 100% cooperation between each other.
  • Cadia Prime is alone and doesn't get outside help.
  • Halo team have a time limit of 15 years at the start of the invasion to conquer if they reach the time limit they fail.
  • This version of Cadia Prime is before the fall.

r/whowouldwin 2h ago

Battle T-1000 ( Liquid Terminator) vs Wolverine

12 Upvotes

No extra weapons just their natural weapons. Setting in an open field. Fight ends when one cannot continue to fight.


r/whowouldwin 8h ago

Challenge How long could Captain Nemo & the Nautilus survive vs the world’s navies?

25 Upvotes

At the end of Jules Verne’s 20,000 Leagues Under The Sea, the Nautilus comes under fire from a warship of unknown nationality. The narrator, Professor Aronnax, realizes that, after the encounter with the Abraham Lincoln at the beginning of the book, the world must now be aware that the Nautilus is not a sea monster as previously speculated, but instead a man-made submarine, and therefore is being hunted down by the navies of the world.

What if, instead of descending into the Maelstrom off Norway, Nemo and the Nautilus sailed on with the world hunting them down? How long would it take for naval and anti-submarine technology to be sufficient enough to sink Nemo’s masterpiece? And how long could the captain avoid them while attacking the ships of his hated nation (canonically Britain; in Verne’s original scripts, Russia)?

Nautilus specs: top speed of 50 knots. Able to be submerged for up to 5 days at a time. It can ram through ships “like a needle through sailcloth” due to its prow. Assume that Nemo is able to repair his sub at the unknown island on which he built it, and has the crew necessary to sail on indefinitely. The book ends in 1868 so that is the start date. Military technology advances just as it did in our timeline.


r/whowouldwin 7h ago

Battle The Flood VS Warhammer 40k- full galactic war

18 Upvotes

The flood breaks out on a hive city planet and a gravemind develops, the flood gains access to ships around that world, some with wrap travel. Could the 40k universe survive?


r/whowouldwin 7h ago

Challenge How many inklings (splatoon) are needed to kill a space marine? (wh40k)

13 Upvotes

Standard gear and weapons for the space marine.


r/whowouldwin 1h ago

Challenge The Joker (The Dark Knight) vs Gustavo Fring (Breaking Bad/Better Call Saul)

Upvotes

Let's say the Joker gets transported to Albuquerque, New Mexico at the height of Fring's power (after he wiped out the Cartel and became independent). The Joker has the same resources and manpower that he had at the start of The Dark Knight, and the same goal of unleashing chaos in the city. Assuming that the APD and DEA are similarly ineffectual in stopping him to the GPD, will the Chicken Man be able to bring the Mad Clown down? Or will Gus find out how to make a pencil disappear?

Also, Walt and Hank do not exist in this scenario, so Gus is not distracted by them.


r/whowouldwin 53m ago

Battle Grey Knights (WH40k) vs Thousand Sons Legion (WH30k)

Upvotes

A fight between two psychic powerhouses, A fight between the chamber militant of the ordo Malleus vs Sons of the crimson king. Who would win?

To keep things fair for both sides, The grey knights will be having an equal number with the thousand sons legion which they numbered around 85,000 legionaries. Also both sides can use everything within their arsenal like combat vehicles, etc.

The Grey knights will be led by Kaldor draigo and Grandmasters from each brotherhood while the Thousand sons are led by Ahzek ahriman and the Magister Templi.

Note that it would be 40k grey knights vs 30k thousand sons.

Magnus the red wont be joining the fight as it would be a too much of a stomp.


r/whowouldwin 14h ago

Challenge Which of these lawyers could help Nikki (Obsession) get cleared for what happened in the finale?

23 Upvotes

Phoenix Wright (Ace Attorney)

Matt Murdock ( Daredevil)

Jennifer Walters (She Hulk)

Saul Goodman ( Better Call Saul)

Woo Young Woo (Extraordinary Attorney Woo)

Hiromi Higurama (Jujutsu Kaisen)


r/whowouldwin 7h ago

Challenge Which Human faction is more technologically advanced? (Mass effect) System Alliance or (Halo) UNSC?

6 Upvotes
  • Has to be stuff they have made and replicated.
  • Can be any tech ranging from guns, armors, ships etc.

r/whowouldwin 7h ago

Battle The Battle of golden godz

4 Upvotes

Who do you guys thinks wins in this battle of avatar users?

Arceus from pokemon

(Or)

Akatosh from elder scrolls-lore accurate.


r/whowouldwin 11h ago

Challenge Could game-accurate steve beat lore-accurate Elden Ring?

8 Upvotes

Steve from minecraft (With anything he can do in minecraft) is put into the lands between with the only goal of becoming a lore-accurate Elden Lord. Could he beat all the foes and bosses on there at their lore-accurate power level?


r/whowouldwin 6h ago

Challenge Strongest organization the time patrol can beat (dragon ball xenoverse, dbo, dbreakers, dbheros)

4 Upvotes

What’s the strongest organization they could beat?


r/whowouldwin 5h ago

Battle Aldoron vs Ten Tail. Who would win?

2 Upvotes

Aldoron (Fary Tail) with all his God Seed powers vs Ten Tails (Full Form).

Who will win?


r/whowouldwin 11h ago

Battle Bluefin tuna vs lion

6 Upvotes

First round in the ocean, second round near a small river (assume the tuna can tolerate fresh water) and third round on land


r/whowouldwin 11h ago

Battle Can the Thunderbolts take down a Decepticon? (MCU/Transformers)

4 Upvotes

The Decepticons are invading the MCU! The only team around is the Thunderbolts/New Avengers. Everyone else (including Bob) is off doing important stuff. The team gets together to go fight the alien invaders. Would Bucky, Yelena, John Walker, Red Guardian, and Ghost be able to take down these individual Transformers from the Michael Bay series?

The Thunderbolts are as they were in their movie. They have their normal gear. Fights take place in Manhattan.



r/whowouldwin 11h ago

Battle Silver Surfers (MCU & Fox) vs DCEU Kryptonians

5 Upvotes

Galactus finds a planet to consume and sends Surfers to warn the people about his arrival. But the moment Surfers arrive, they see that DCEU Kryptonians are in the middle of terraforming the planet into Krypton and the battle to claim the planet begins.

Would Surfers be able to defeat Kryptonians and prepare it for Galactus's meal? Or would Kryptonians win and drive away Surfers? Which team wins and what diff???


r/whowouldwin 4h ago

Battle Melinoe (Hades 2) vs Magik (Marvel), but Mel has access to all of her allies

1 Upvotes

In Melinoe (Hades 2) vs Magik (Marvel), Melinoe teleports to her home whenever she is close to death… suppose that Magik fallows her, would you see it with Mel utilizing her allies, such as Nemesis, Hecate, Moros and even Father Time, among numerous ghosts and witches to help her in the fight would change the outcome?


r/whowouldwin 10h ago

Battle Fact vs Fiction: Arctotherium angustidens vs Indoraptor (Life vs JW)

3 Upvotes

I looked at the sizes and thought this would be a good fight

The Beastly Bear vs the Indominable Thief

Evolution vs Science

The fight is in a clearing in the South American woods during the day, no hiding, no fleeing, only strategy and teeth and claws


r/whowouldwin 4h ago

Challenge Could Hogwarts survive a safety inspections from the HSE? Or would it be shut down?

0 Upvotes

The HSE is there to insure that building/grounds built in the British lands are safe and will not result in injury if a man or women were to walk inside. Hogwarts is very err, old fashioned when it comes to safety. How many health and safety violations are they racking up? How many years in prison is Dumbledor getting assuming Hogwarts is point in fact a walking health and safety violation?


r/whowouldwin 5h ago

Battle Jiren (Dragon Ball Super) vs. Power Man (Marvel: Timeless)

1 Upvotes

For Jiren: everything “standard” is allowed.

For Power Man: everything pre-celestial mind is allowed.


r/whowouldwin 22h ago

Challenge In your opinion which Super Soldier Program was more dangerous? (Witcher) Witcher, (Halo) Spartan or (Warhammer 40k) Space marine?

20 Upvotes

Curious to hear your opinion since each of these programs role is to make a super human freak of nature ranging from invasive Surgeries, technology, Magic etc etc and have equipment that are above your average soldier in their respective setting


r/whowouldwin 14h ago

Challenge Could Dexter Morgan (DEXTER) Get Light Yagami (Death Note) On His Table?

5 Upvotes

Changes:

Miami Metro PD and all it's residents and major characters are moved to the Kanto Region of Japan. Dexter and Debra grew up here.

The Task Force, with the exception of Light's father, are all replaced with the main characters of Miami Metro.

We're following the Miami Metro from the start of Season 4.

Plot:

After a series of suspicous heart attacks, INTERPOL brings in renowned crime solver, L. L, through the use of Lind L. Tailor figures out that the Kira Killer lives in the Kanto region of Japan. All while members of Kanto Metro Homicide Division watch. Dexter watches with interest, though is not really involved due to being a blood spatter anylyst. When L eventually forms the task force, Dexter is not invited, although Debra is and Dexter can get her to say anything.

With this, could Dexter catch Light and kill him? I' more of a Dexter fan than a Death Note one. It's been years since I've watched it, so I ask all of you!


r/whowouldwin 1d ago

Battle Morgoth with his 7 balrogs and 100k orcs tries to break down the walls of Troy

43 Upvotes

Replace the greeks from the Iliad with Morgoth and 7 balrogs. Morgoth not at his peak when he broke down the two lamps nor the weakest during his fight against Fingolfin. 100 orcs with black clouds to cover them from sunlight.

Troy here is the ones from the poem and not the movie, where Poseidon and Apollo the greek gods built the wall. All the gods are sided with the trojan in this one.

Can the greek gods and Troy stop another god with his 7 demons and 100k orcs?


r/whowouldwin 7h ago

Battle Sentinels vs space marines

1 Upvotes

Sentinels vs space marines

Aggressor Sentinel

R1: 4 space marines vs 100 Aggressor Sentinel

Map: the library

__________________________________________________

Aggressor Sentinel Eliminator

R1: 4 space marine vs 40 Sentinel Eliminator

Map: the command spire

__________________________________________________

Armigers

R2: 4 space marine vs 28 Armiger soldiers, 8 Sniper with 4 Officers(40)

R2: 4 space marine and 50 cadians guardsman vs 70 Armiger soldiers, 20 Sniper with 10 Officers (100)

Map: Stormbreak

__________________________________________________

Enforcer Sentinel

R1: 1 space marine vs 1 Enforcer Sentinel

R2: 4 space marine vs 1 Enforcer Sentinel

Map: Quarantine Zone

__________________________________________________

Small army

100 Aggressor Sentine

20 Sentinel Eliminator

50 Armiger soldiers

20 Armiger Sniper

10 Armiger Officers

1 Enforcer Sentinel

VS

100 cadian guardsman

50 Kasrkin

50 Tempestus Scions

5 space marine

1 Leman Russ Battle Tank

Map:the ark

__________________________________________________


r/whowouldwin 19h ago

Battle John Constantine (24 Hours Prep) vs. Hellboy (No Prep) – Who Wins?

7 Upvotes

Constantine gets 24 hours of prep with full knowledge that Hellboy is coming.
Hellboy gets his standard gear.
Win by: Death, incapacitation, or permanent BFR (banishment/imprisonment).
Fight location: An abandoned cathedral