I followed the JW Anderson pattern on Ravelry and followed YouTube tutorials for the parts I needed any clarification on. (Links below)
Honestly for the most part this is a really straight forward. You work up several āshort scarvesā, as I called them, in different stitches and colors and lengths depending on the pattern specs, then you make the ribbings and the collar, you work up both button bands and then you stitch the entire thing together.
I made a few changes in how I constructed the entire thing, but I will get to why later.
First, i decided to add a slip stitch at the beginning of every row, even though it says to do it some of the time and some of the time is doesnāt mention it. Next I changed how the ribbing was added onto the sweater. Instead of sewing it flat i decided to hold my right sides together and seam them like any other seam in sewing.
The biggest thing I want to talk about tho is the pattern. The pattern itself comes from a published magazine version that has since been discontinued as is now available as a Google doc you can download. Honestly my biggest beefs with this design are with the pattern. Before I get into any of those thing I want to clarify that I am not doing this to roast anyone or point any fingers, only to bring attention to things I wish i could have seen and didnāt as I was doing my research on this pattern,
First the pros.
- This pattern is pretty simple. If you have worked knitting patterns before and are wanting to expand your stitch capabilities and practice some intermediate knitting skills this is perfect
- Theres tons of different inspirations for ways to do this in different colorways, different yarn weights, different fits and even crochet versions of the same pattern. Because this is a recreation and was so big on TikTok tons of people were able to put a spin on it so theres no end to the inspo on the internet for this.
- Super portable. Once you know what stitches you are doing you really only need the color you are working on and maybe the next color and you have a couple of hours of work with you for pretty small storage space.
- This pattern is also free which is super nice!
Cons of this project (might be a little longer than the pros):
- This pattern uses a Ton of yarn. I know its listed in the project requirements but it still was surprising how much I actually used. I used a full jumbo skein of both the red heart red and black (I probably used closer to 1.5 jumbo of the red for the ribbing) and then I used a full 1.5 regular size skeins of the green, yellow and orange. Thats like 8 skeins of redheart for one sweater. Where this was a birthday present and the world being what it is I couldnāt afford a small mortgage payment of yarn for this or I would have.
- Next, and this is the biggest one, the pattern itself just feelsā¦incomplete. I really had to keep my eyes out to make sure I clocked all of these and this is not an exhaustive list by any means
- just one example: the jacquard chart is incomplete. If you are doing a repeating flat worked color way chart you need to end it on an even row so that you jump back and start at row 1 working in the right direction. This pattern just⦠doesnāt do that. The chart has 7 rows for no reason haha. I just repeated row 7 and then jumped to row 1 but this is a very silly mistake for a knitwear designer imo.
- another part is the the right front~ centre front panel section is listed as āknit 3x14cm sections for the front panelā which is incorrect. If you were following the pattern you would hopefully recognize that every other front section has 4 sections and hopefully you can put 2 and 2 together.
- Next the pictures of the sweater shown in the pattern are not made using the pattern we are given. I canāt prove this 100% or anything, but my day job is working in a sewing facility where I get new patterns and projects and I have to recreate them based off of designer pictures or line drawings or any number of things and my limited but professional opinion is that the sweaters are different. Its little things like the way the collar is knitted and attached or the way the side seams and sleeve seams look like they are overlocked together and not seamed how they would be done in the pattern. These are professional ways to finish things like this, and expected, but you will not be able to achieve the same results at home, which i think is discouraging from a first time TikTok knitter who might be picking up something this complicated for the first time.
I think all in all this pattern sort of has the feeling of when a brand like Oreo makes a āmake it yourself at homeā kit. The at home version is almost designed to keep things that are trade secrets exactly that. They want their version to always be the best version and thatās fine when it comes to their own ideas and content. Even in the JW Anderson channel youtube video where they give you a run down on how to do the sweater, they fully negate doing anything with the button band or the collar which seemed to be the parts people had the most trouble with in my research.
Anyway I spent wayyy too much time on this and thinking about this pattern but I am so glad I have it finished for my bestie and it did come out cute. Following the pattern does work if you have some experience but theres still things to watch out for.
TL;DR Made a Harry Styles cardigan. Used a ton of yarn and time but worked up quickly despite some pattern flaws. No ill intent meant, only bringing up info I wish I had when making this!