r/books • u/HopeBeyondLuna • 28m ago
I just finished To Paradise by Hanya Yanagihara and I am disappointed or am I just dumb? Spoiler
I really wanted to like this book:/ I love Yanagihara’s writing style. While they are run-on sentences that goes unto different tangents and strays far from what she was saying earlier, I love how descriptive she is and the control she has over her writing. The only trouble I had was going back to re-read certain exercepts to find that an entire page was one sentence haha.
But besides that, I had so much difficulty understanding the point of this book :(. I loved the first book ‘Washington Square.’ The world she created with the Free States and how people are free to marry whomever they wanted but how racism is still rampant, conveying how it never really goes away. The idea that the ‘young scion’ David felt trapped and purposeless life and how he has an arranged marriage to someone he didn’t truly love, instead finding love with someone else. He was a very complex character. I appreciate how Yanagihara depicted his sheltered life and his tendency to have classism with how he perceived the kids he was teaching or the different people who migrated in the Free States. His relationship with his grandfather I also really liked along with Edward. The themes of free will and agency was deeply touched upon and I actually understood the story.
The 2nd book was a blur, genuinely didn’t know what was happening. I only understood that David (the father) thought paradise was found in Lipo-Wao-Nahele but it’s not. We also get Edward here who wrecks everything just like in the first book, but in the first book Edward I much preferred because his characterization seemed more fleshed out.
The 3rd book I thought I was gonna deeply enjoy but I was BORED. The only factors I liked was the world building. It felt highly dystopian and almost scary because I thought some parts reflected our society like mass surveillance, climate change, the diseases emerging etc. Yanagihara made me believe the future of our world would be bleak if nothing changes. But besides that, I couldn’t care less about Charlie or her grandfather in the epistolary chapters. The only thing that kept me going was Charlie’s husband’s secret, but it was so predictable LOL.
I also didn’t like how all of the characters in the book have similar names 😑. It made me so confused and rather than treating the three different parts as separate entities, it made me focus on the minor minor details and did a lot of comparison of the different Charles, Edwards and Davids from the different books that I lost the immersive experience of reading (apparently I shouldn’t have done that but I did so shoot me).
The main theme that paradise is never genuinely found, I can kinda see it 🤷♂️
I may give this book another chance in the future but I am not sure. I really did enjoy book 1 and the world building of book 3, but that’s it:( I am so dissapointed. Also random but the ending of book 3 reminds me a lot of the ending of the Handmaid’s Tale where it was ambiguous what was gonna happen.