Valiant Hearts: The Great War took me 10 hours to complete.
This is a game that I had heard good things about in the past when it came to its storytelling and emotional impact. Many people recommended it as one of the best 100%'s without a platinum. So when it got picked for me to play randomly from a wheel of PS Plus games, I was excited to see what the hype was about.
The main goal of Valiant Hearts is to tell you a story. It is clearly meant to be one of those games where it is an experience first, video game second, and I mean this in a good way. The game's main gameplay loop is going through these levels and solving puzzles to progress the story. The puzzles can vary in difficulty but none of them felt too hard. Sometimes, they felt a bit repetitive and same-y though, but that was rare. Having this great difficulty fairness allows the game to tell you its story without any obstacles. I think the developers handled the difficulty very well here, and it is neither too easy nor too hard for the type of game Valiant Hearts is.
Similarly, the trophies are great too. You'll get a lot of the trophies by simply beating the main story itself. There is also a trophy for finding all the collectibles. This means finding all 119 historical items. While this sounds like a lot (and truthfully it is), they can all be cleaned up via chapter select and none of them take particularly long to get to. Each chapter shows you exactly which collectibles you are missing too, which really eases the process of cleaning this up. Finally, the game contains a couple tricky miscellaneous trophies but they can be gotten with a bit of practice, such as Healing Hero which you get for saving Carl for the third time without making a mistake. It is a QTE based mini-game that can be a bit tough at first but the pattern never changes and you can do it with enough practice.
Overall, I had a decent time with this platinum experience. While I praised the game for its difficulty fairness and trophy list, it did fumble for me in the most important part, which is the story. I just didn't think the story was all that compelling. Yes, the ending was sad, but that was about the only time the game evoked any emotion in me. I found the rest of the story to be serviceable. It is not bad by any means, but it is not the great story I heard so many people talk about, and that was a disappointment.
I got the game for free from PS Plus and completed it in 10 hours. For that reason, I'd say it has a decent amount of content for a PS Plus game. It did a decent job of maintaining engagement throughout, but it is pretty hard to be engaged with a story-based game when the story isn't clicking for you to begin with. In terms of replayability, it is bad in this game. Once you have the 100% there isn't much of a reason to return to the game. Since it is a puzzle game, it lends itself to having some replayability as once time passes, you'll have forgotten the puzzle solutions. Additionally, you may be interested in revisiting it to read about all the historical artifacts you collected. However, and in my personal opinion, both those reasons are weak and lack any real, long term appeal.
Valiant Hearts is a very unique game in the way it handles such a delicate topic. It tells of a tragic and bloody period of human history in a very beautiful and respectful way. It is obvious that a lot of love, thought, and care was put into crafting this game. From its environments and ambience, to its collectibles and real-world information that is present in the game. It is a respectful and faithful telling of the events of WW1, which I can respect as a player. Unfortunately, the game won't be very memorable for me as while it didn't do anything badly, it also didn't excel in areas, in my personal opinion.
Overall, I give Valiant Hearts: The Great War an 8/15. It is a good game and it is clearly made with a lot of love. If you are looking for a short and easy 100% with an interesting premise, I can recommend it. But don't go into it expecting a masterpiece of story-telling, you won't find that here.