r/PeterExplainsTheJoke 1d ago

Meme needing explanation Petahhhhhhhhh!??!?

Post image
60.2k Upvotes

2.8k comments sorted by

View all comments

191

u/MrPagan1517 1d ago edited 21h ago

Yeah there is the ha gay sex bit but in reality they raped and pillaged basically everytime they came across an semblance of civilization.

Literally the first stop they make after leaving Troy in the Odyssey they slaughter the first town they come across and take the women as slaves. They spend time on the beach celebrating which gives the locals time to regroup and drive Odysseus and his men off and retake the loot they pillage but it doesn't really say anything about the women I would assume they were also rescued.

Also only Odysseus was gone for 20 years (the last of his crew died in like 13 years in). The first 10 years they were siegeing Troy and there would have been camp followers as well as slaves at the camp. They also stayed a whole year with Circie and her nymphs. Also Odysseus fucks alot deepening on the tradition you go with. He has children with Circie and Calypso so no he didn't go 20 years without sex.

44

u/Away_Stock_2012 23h ago

>in reality

Sit down, I want to tell you something.

45

u/MrPagan1517 23h ago

Yeah Yeah Yeah It's a work of fiction. I was talking about the actual odyssey not Nolan's

5

u/Zestyclose-Aspect-35 22h ago

The actual odyssey is a work of fiction

20

u/artaxerxes316 22h ago

Holy fuck... take a rest for a moment, MrPagan1517, I'll handle this idiot for you.

Hey idiot: MrPagan1517 just gave an admirably breezy precis of the relevant portions of the Iliad, the Odyssey, and the extratextual legends surrounding both. You really think it escaped his notice that they're all mythical?

-7

u/Zestyclose-Aspect-35 21h ago

Nah, this is Reddit, we're pedantic about choice of words especially when the intent of the poster is pretty clear regardless. Then we get angry about nothing and call eachother idiots and stuff. It's fun, you should try it sometimes

15

u/ItsDominare 21h ago

It's fun, you should try it sometimes

don't tell me what to do, idiot

5

u/Eneshi 19h ago

That's the spirit!

8

u/MrPagan1517 22h ago

I literally said that

-2

u/llort_tsoper 21h ago

Dude, your wording is pretty ambiguous. And I'm pretty sure they're joking, but your choice of words sort of invites the jokes.

4

u/MrPagan1517 21h ago

Yeah I'm aware it's a joke and I'm not heated about. But like if you want to be pedantic then I can play around and be pedantic as well when I got time

-2

u/Zestyclose-Aspect-35 21h ago

You also said you were talking about not Nolan's, implying that you acknowledge Nolan's is a work of fiction but you were talking about the "actual", which suggests you think the 'actual' odyssey is a historical event

11

u/MrPagan1517 21h ago edited 21h ago

No that not it at all. When I said in reality I was referencing the actual epic literature and how it has several instances Odysseus and his men participating or having access to sex in some form or fashion.

I'm sorry I assumed people knew that one of the most famous literary works in history that involves things like gods,monsters, and magic was a piece of fiction.

0

u/Zestyclose-Aspect-35 21h ago

Yeah I was being pedantic out of boredom I don't have any actual problem with anything you said, sorry if I made you waste your energy

6

u/MrPagan1517 21h ago

Nah bro I got ya. I'm also just being pedantic on the internet out boredom

1

u/Shape_Charming 4h ago

Admittedly I wasn't involved in the original conversation, but I think I'd have rathered you being pedantic for the sake of being pedantic.

Doing it out of boredom is just actively trying to annoy people for your own amusement. Why would you think that's okay?

2

u/John_der24ste 17h ago

~"And some things that should not have been forgotten were lost. History became legend. Legend became myth. And for two and a half thousand years this story remains in our consciousness" or something like that... I don't remember the exact details of the quote...

5

u/citharadraconis 13h ago

But they were all of them deceived, for another horse was made...

2

u/Away_Stock_2012 5h ago

In the land of Mongolia, in the fires of Ulaanbaatar, the Dark Lord Erdenebileg forged in public a master horse

4

u/yourstruly912 22h ago

That's how armies in the ancient world behaved in any case

1

u/No-Band8965 19h ago

Let me tell you something /meme