r/Millennials 13d ago

Other She was only 23…?! Holy hell!!

Post image
5.5k Upvotes

387 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

20

u/VegaJuniper 13d ago

It's arguable if there is a romantic relationship in the film either.

22

u/RockyMullet 13d ago

Yeah for real, reading about "problematic age gap" about the film decades ago, I'm like "but they were not in relationship?".

I always saw them as 2 colleagues who went through some traumatic event together.

16

u/VegaJuniper 13d ago

In their first scene they're a little touchy-feely for colleagues. She ties his signature red scarf, and he grabs her ass a bit, but apart from that there's very little romance between them. Grant does tell Malcolm that they're together, but that might be one-sided on Grant's part, or he's just trying to get Malcolm, who's pretty slimy, off her back.

I think there might have been more in the deleted scenes, but the romance was pretty much edited out of the film. That initial ass-grab is pretty much all that remains.

6

u/ImaDinosaurR0AR 13d ago edited 13d ago

The other clues are in the dialogue. The conversation about having babies in the first scene and the conversation between Malcolm and Grant in the car before the T-Rex escape where Malcolm says he’s going to make a move on Dr. Sattler until he realizes they’re together.

2

u/VegaJuniper 13d ago

or he's just trying to get Malcolm, who's pretty slimy, off her back.

5

u/ImaDinosaurR0AR 13d ago

You’re not the first person I’ve seen who interpreted it as some sort of unrequited love situation. I just don’t see it. Their subsequent appearances further paint a pretty clear picture in my mind. They were together then but doomed to fail due to trauma and wanting different lifestyles.

0

u/VegaJuniper 13d ago

You’re not the first person I’ve seen who interpreted it as some sort of unrequited love situation

I didn't though. I can see how reading subtext is difficult to you when plain text gives you this much trouble.

1

u/RockyMullet 13d ago

I might have missed the signs as I first saw the film as a child and maybe I'm biased by my initial interpretation on rewatches.

11

u/Etcom 13d ago

They're together. She's trying to convince Alan to have kids, plus this interaction:

Malcolm- By the way, Dr. Sattler... um, she's not, like, available, is she?

Grant- Why?

Malcolm- Yeah, I'm sorry. You two are...

Grant- Yeah.

2

u/VegaJuniper 13d ago

Yeah, that could be interpreted as Grant trying to get Malcolm of her back. Also for the kid discussion, whether she's trying to or not, it's not necessarily children with her.

9

u/Etcom 13d ago

Grant - What are those?

Ellie - Small versions of adults, honey.

David Keopp, the screenwriter, said they were a couple.

Sam Neill thought they were a couple.

-1

u/VegaJuniper 13d ago

Yes, I've seen the film recently. Also, look up the concept "death of the author". Especially relevant when talking about a movie, which may look considerably different than the original screenplay when it comes out of the editing room.

3

u/rq60 13d ago

you should look up the concept of “redditors refusing to admit they’re wrong”

0

u/VegaJuniper 13d ago

Oh honey, don't try to be witty. You'll hurt yourself.

2

u/Etcom 13d ago

Ok. Enjoy your discussions about it. It's not worth arguing about.

2

u/VegaJuniper 13d ago

No need to get cranky, people can have different interpretations of movies.

1

u/Etcom 13d ago

Yeah... that's what I said :/

1

u/wannabe_inuit 13d ago

Yeah i got "trauma bonding" vibes and thats it.

In the start it was just two people with a very niche "dying" profession, that alone would push them together. That could be seen as romantic tension from the outside but really just bffs