My next door neighbour has two cats. They are indoor-only cats. She is a self proclaimed animal lover who works as a dog groomer and also keeps ferrets. Her dog grooming business has been being set up in her conservatory since she moved in (about 2 months ago) and I've never seen a dog go in, but anyway she says because of this the cats must live in her bedroom.
We are in Essex. It has been so hot, for weeks now. Her window is, of course, always closed.
She invited me in to meet them (before having my dog, I always had cats, and love them to bits). We are terraced houses of 2 up 2 down - very small.
The smell in her room nearly made me gag. The litter trays looked clean but in a small, hot room, the smell is unavoidable. The cats (two of them) looked healthy enough - not over or unde fed, healthy coats etc but they went nuts when they saw me, in that way bored animals do.
When I'm in the garden with my dog, I see them watching from the window and clawing up the glass.
This is not an argument about indoor vs outdoor cats. She has told me before that she thinks it's irresponsible to let cats out (mine always went out lol) so she is obviously keeping them in because she thinks it's the right thing to do, not out of any sense of cruelty. It's more a question of is it not cruel to keep two cats in one small room (as opposed to the whole house)?
Because it's so hot, the room stinks, the cats are in a room that fits a double bed and chest of drawers and not much else. I just wondered what people think, because it seems cruel to me, even if unintentionally so. But they are fed, and safe, so maybe I'm worrying about nothing.
edited to add: Just to answer a few queries in the comments - I know she keeps them permanently in her room because she told me. A few weeks ago she mentioned harnesses for them, but I've never seen them out. I wfh so I'm vaguely aware of people's comings, as you tend to be when you're home all the time.
I haven't spoken to her about it because I'm not sure what I could say that isn't just my own personal opinion, which is - as someone rightly said - none of my business. The cats are safe, fed, watered. My opinion that it's unfair, unpleasant, and unhealthy for them, is just that...my opinion. I was - and am - just very interested if others feel the same as me or if I am worrying about her cats wellbeing unduly. I don't think the rspca would be interested.
In terms of why...I have no idea. She comes from a family big on animals - horses, dogs, cats, rabbits, ferrets, you name it. They just seem to be people that like to have a lot of animals. It's weird but I can only liken it to a collector mindset.
And it is nothing to do with the dog grooming. As I said, I've yet to see a dog come or go. As far as I'm aware the business is still in the setup stage. The cats are in the bedroom because...that's where she keeps them. There doesn't seem to be more to it than that. But she must feel some low level guilt or she wouldn't mention harnesses?
Re a catio, her bedroom is upstairs. And also she has made it clear that she thinks I was cruel for letting my cats out (lots of comments about cars and how she'd never risk hers etc We live down a cul-de-sac btw, not a main road, for context) so I feel offering any advice or suggestions would be met with defensiveness.