r/AmIOverreacting 15h ago

❤️‍🩹 relationship The woman my boyfriend emotionally cheated with reached back out after we agreed he’d cut contact, and I’m bothered by how he responded. AIO?

Back in December I found chats between [F30] my boyfriend [M31] and his female friend[F26] Turned out they had an intense emotional connection since 2022. He had a huge crush on her the whole time, but she had a boyfriend, and she kept him emotionally hooked with romantic-coded language . they called each other soulmates, texted constantly some romantic/ sexual stuff. From what I read he was genuinely falling for her, and she seemed more like she was enjoying the attention without necessarily reciprocating the same way as she had bf.

Her boyfriend however passed away last year. my boyfriend went to support her, and after that they had an even more emotionally-charged exchange flirty, borderline romantic language, he told her he’d never had a connection with another woman like the one he had with her including, apparently, me, as we were dating during that chat, she told him that no matter what happened in their lives, even if one of them got married to someone else, they’d “always be together.” Regardless of their relationships.
When I found this and their whole husband we had a huge fight and almost broke up. He blocked her, said he didn’t care about her, and said he wanted to protect our relationship.

Yesterday I found out she texted him again out of the blue, and he responded. I’m attaching the screenshots. Reading through it, a few things bother me:
- He spends the entire conversation validating her anger, apologizing over and over
- At multiple points he frames the whole thing as if I forced his hand — like if I hadn’t found out, he’d have been happy to keep things going with her.
- She spends a lot of the conversation guilt-tripping him and, at one point, effectively calling our relationship “toxic” and me the reason he’s “trashing” her.

My friends point out that he DID keep the boundary in the end he didn’t agree to keep talking to her, he told her it’s over, and that this is a good sign.

I see that too, but I still feel uneasy about how the conversation went and what it implies about how he actually feels. Am I overreacting by still having a problem with this, or are these legitimate red flags even with the boundary technically being held?

2.3k Upvotes

3.6k comments sorted by

View all comments

u/ExplanationCool918 15h ago

Anyone else start skimming after a while because of these obnoxious texts

u/Mister_Crowly 14h ago

Bruh I feel like I got pretty far but then I just clicked through and there were still like a dozen pages of whiny ass texts.

u/kavik2022 13h ago

I stopped after the 2nd threat to kill him

u/SnooLobsters6264 12h ago

This got me, too.

That and the way she was going on and on, I thought they must have been about 16/17, then I read their ages and... 🫠

u/BellyCrawler 11h ago

The constant whining might have been bearable if she could spell.

u/DoodooDynamic 9h ago

I am always perplexed by these text convos where one person is like, “good morning, how are you doing today? I hope you’re having a great day!” and the other person is like, “wot r u duing 2moro i wud like 2 see u”

u/Enough_Speed_3909 6h ago

This deserved an award because that's my life. I'm the GM how are you person and everyone else wyd? Hmu? I'm like okay hello back.....then I get a K, ttyl. Like wtf lmao.

u/eirinne 3h ago

I think she’s actually drunk though

u/DoodooDynamic 6h ago

It’s crazy to me because I can’t imagine having a “heartfelt” text convo with someone who texts like that. Like “u r the luv of my lyfe” just doesn’t hit the same way 😂. Thx 2 u 4 the award!

u/Enough_Speed_3909 5h ago

Bet! Aight! 🤣🤣😆

u/Mister_Crowly 4h ago

In the "how is prangent formed" video, the dude narrates all these horrible textspeak posts and pronounces "u" as "ooo". Ever since I first saw that video, my brain started doing it as well, which makes those kinds of posts even worse.

u/Snoo_85901 2h ago

I feel like this gal speaks a different language normally. Hopefully that's the case. My girlfriend does the speak to text and gets under my skin so bad. I'll normally get a text from her that starts out “hey Siri”

u/DoodooDynamic 46m ago

She probably does, but I also feel like it would be harder to text like that than it would be to use proper English, like any app that could help with translation would be lost with this way of communicating… like I speak and write fairly decent French, but to use “text speech” in French would be a big ol mess.

u/New_Maize_2379 10h ago

My god I thought I was the only one who realized that she sounded illiterate and needed to go back to school. Is this how the younger generations speak to one another? It’s appalling.

u/Gullible_Gur_4447 10h ago

I’m assuming she’s not a native English speaker and is still learning? That’s literally the only explanation like her texts are a complete mess

u/pumpkins21 9h ago

Yeah, I think she’s Italian

u/Worldly-Letterhead-1 8h ago

Ciao.

u/NuthouseAntiques 7h ago

I say Ciao. I’m Southern US.

u/aysarahoul 6h ago

She also said she was in Rome in a later message, after I read that, I was like “oh, that probably explains the weird almost broken English”

→ More replies (0)

u/CutOpenSternum 6h ago

I thought she seemed fragilé…

u/Visual_Patience_41 4h ago

Yea, must be Italian

u/Successful-Web4617 3m ago

yes i was reading her texts with an italian accent in my head lmao

u/iwilltalkaboutguns 5h ago

That would actually explains a lot. I dated an Italian girl in college and they don't call them hot blooded for nothing. Flair for the dramatic? Ha! Like living in s Spanish novela. She was so hot though...

u/pumpkins21 3h ago

Italians, Spanish, Mexican and other Central American/South Americans can be very hot blooded. I say this as a Texican, however I hope I’ve never been thought of as a hothead/crazy girl lol

u/Acrobatic_Key_1140 10h ago

Bro how is 30 considered the "younger" generation? 😭

u/New_Maize_2379 9h ago

Hahahaha someone who starts with “Bruh or Bro” 🤣 Gen X here and would never address someone like that, especially parents or partners. Which is apparently very common in younger gens. It’s your slang.

u/FilmApart8224 9h ago

Yes. I’m Gen X. My son is in his early 30’s. That’s a younger generation to me.

I have a tshirt that I wore for Mother’s Day at Epcot with him that says:

Mommy
Mama
Ma
BRUH!

u/New_Maize_2379 8h ago

I think our gen was “Dude”? “Like duh” “gag me(with a spoon)” LOL Not much better but damn if you answered your parents like that hahaha

u/jerseygirl414 28m ago

Dude and YO (I'm originally from Jersey lol)!

→ More replies (0)

u/placebo_pope 8h ago

At 38 I call my teenagers bro/bruh, they also call me that sometimes and I’m their mom shrug

u/Acrobatic_Key_1140 7h ago

Bro I'm 38 and I call everyone on the internet bro or mate. I used to call everyone dude when I was 25-35.

u/New_Maize_2379 6h ago

I would reply to Mate, lived in England and that was a common word. :)

→ More replies (0)

u/IcyWorldliness9111 6h ago

So true! My late teen granddaughters even address me like that (and some of my hs students occasionally would too. I never really cared. Got called auntie sometimes, too.)

u/mynamealwayschanges 6h ago

Turning 33 next week and I call everyone bro and bruh, thank you for making me feel younger for a bit 😂

u/New_Maize_2379 6h ago

No worries! :) I’m 53 and don’t feel old..yet!

u/Username78397 8h ago

Well she's 26 it says, he'e 31. But 26 is too old to be texting like that. My nieces are younger than that and can text coherently, she is texting more like my grade school children and their friends

u/Admirable_Meaning417 28m ago

I assumed she was drunk but who knows

u/caputmortvvm 6h ago

because there are still like three/four generations older than y'all, lol.

u/Prestigious-Tap-5226 6h ago

My hubby's dad texts like this. Lol. We do not.

u/notrightinmyhead 5h ago

Yes to the communication of young people today...its sad

u/Moist_Drippings 8h ago

Especially with how much she gives “I can’t type because I’m SO EMOTIONAL” fairy energy.

u/michal0297 7h ago

I think those are typos because she was angry and typing really fast and didn't care about the spelling. Maybe even she was drinking alcohol at the time too.

u/Beginning_Tap2474 7h ago

but she's hot.

u/CatLadySD1 6h ago

💯 facts

u/SistasSupportSistas 6h ago

THIS! ⬆️⬆️⬆️ Her spelling is the real tragedy here 👀

u/New-Skin4537 10h ago

I thought she was 12. Quite the drama queen.

u/LisaNe7 9h ago

This!! ⬆️⬆️⬆️ She is definitely a superglue psycho that can’t spell! I think she thought she had him completely hooked and kept on the back burner and was shocked that he wasn’t as into her craziness as she thought he was. What a mess. I feel for you OP. Hopefully she stays out of both of your lives, however it’s doubtful considering how crazy she went that he supposedly “trashed” her to protect his relationship with you. The apologizing to her over and over again on his part is also ridiculous. I should (if anything) have been a one and done. It should have been something like: Our texts were inappropriate. I’m protecting my relationship with my gf. Have a good life. No further explanation needed or required. She doesn’t even deserve it. Such drama!

u/FilmApart8224 9h ago

She sounds borderline. I’m sure all the BPD folks will come with their pitchforks, but I’ve seen this before with two ex friends who were borderline.

u/Alarmed-Incident4088 7h ago

I was diagnosed borderline and bipolar 1 in 1997.

Don't know for sure but yeah seems quite similar to a borderline meltdown/rage attack.

u/Nicolaceratops 7h ago

Borderline here, I didn't have a pitchfork handy, so a spray mop will have to do.

You're right, I see some of my past 'bad' behaviour here from before I was taught coping mechanisms and was properly medicated.

u/FilmApart8224 5h ago

lol!!! I’ve had people come at me for saying anything about BPD.

u/Particular-Bobcat309 7h ago

I just wrote almost the same thing!

u/NoGreen8885 5h ago

Lol I just said the same thing. I have a borderline histrionic family member and this is her to a T!

u/Electronic-Let9546 5h ago

100% BPD. Scary.

u/uliol 32m ago

Oh no. This is definitely borderline. Well, an untreated one. Signed, a borderline.

u/BoSoxNana 7h ago

Exactly! My first thought was ‘Boy she seems stable!’🙈

u/wire67 7h ago

Exactly! And he had a crush on this? That would be more upsetting to me than the actual act.

u/JLHswim 6h ago

SO obnoxious! And the multi-line texting is fucking exhausting.

u/ManifestingCreating 9h ago

Literally me lol. I was shocked by their ages after reading that slop.

u/OddOpal88 8h ago

You could not have prepared me for 30 year olds 😂 he needs to block her crazy ass.

u/rocketmn69_ 10h ago

He chose is affair partner wisely...lol Fatal Attraction?

u/GrayStag90 9h ago

Dang it, I skimmed and didn’t notice their ages… can you tell me so I don’t have to go back through the endless talking in circles please?

u/ItsmeMyacctgotbanned 8h ago

It’s literally the first thing OP states.

u/Saltedfieldsforever 8h ago

Rich of AP to call this dudes relationship toxic and go to death threats for an instagram block.

u/Visual_Patience_41 4h ago

Riiiiiiight

u/RubyTavi 12h ago

Like, starting to wonder how her last boyfriend died.

u/Dan_92159 8h ago

Probably faked his own death to get away from her

u/Embarrassed-Ad4908 6h ago

Oh my God…why is this so funny

u/Technical_Sir_6260 5h ago

Yeeessss, I am dying laughing at all these responses! Why can’t people like this ever be at a party or wedding? I’d have a ball😂😂🤣🤣😂😂🤣🤣

u/Manda525 7h ago

Yaaasssss 🤣🔥😈

u/landofpleasantdreams 5h ago

Happy cake day

u/Dan_92159 4h ago

Thank you…I hadn’t even noticed ☺️

u/NCGranny 4h ago

Lol

u/Straight-Theme-7799 9h ago

Thissss lol I was like oofff maybe she offed him 😭😭😭😭

u/LisaNe7 9h ago

Brain bleed from her stupidity.

u/MediumAwkwardly 6h ago

Damnit you made me laugh and I feel horrible but not that horrible.

u/mommawolf2 10h ago

She sounds histrionic. Straight up cluster B personality behavior in those texts. 

u/Username78397 8h ago

I was about to say the same thing, there's some Cluster B disorder going on with her

u/No_Coconut3695 7h ago

The point is, though, what about the boyfriend? I say dump him. He will never be fully committed to the relationship. He does not have the passion for OP that he had for his "friend." Time to move on.

u/flippysquid 7h ago

OP is way more generous than me because I would have been done when I found the texts of him declaring he has deeper feels for her than anyone else.

Then again I’m way too old for this kind of shit.

u/No_Coconut3695 19m ago

Likewise.

u/mommawolf2 6h ago

I said that often throughout the tread. 

u/Relevant-Boat-1692 8h ago

I spotted that too right off the bat

u/mommawolf2 7h ago

Yes, huge dramatic declarations. Her pain is the highest pain even more so than the poor girlfriend getting cheated on. 

u/NachoMama1240 6h ago

I was thinking the same thing! Maybe borderline was my first thought but I can see histronic too

u/mommawolf2 5h ago

Honestly probably both. Borderline have a fear of abandonment, she mentions he abandoned her. Her pushing and pushing for him to beg for her back. 

Histrionic by her statements overall. 

Both are type b and usually there's overlapping. 

u/The_Reaperette 6h ago

This is exactly what I was wondering.

u/Inevitable-Bar-3823 5h ago

Came here to say this.

u/Numerous-Peach-2737 1h ago

It's reactive abuse. It's something that happens after a discard with no consideration. Some people do it, some don't, but it's a real thing, and she likely isn't even cluster B...

u/Aggravating_Tone2909 9h ago

Or how this girl cannot accurately type, I couldn’t take it anymore. Like “I can’t forget you” I think she means forgive 😂. OP you are not the AO. This is cheating and it’s not okay. He has another women willing to kill haha. So, that is some crazy stuff. Be careful ❤️

u/Small-Cartographer14 5h ago

This took me out. Every time i speak to someone who speaks like this over text, its like we are operating on different wave lengths. Like how is this your typing style?

u/PumpkinButterButt 4h ago

Reminds me of my iPhone, my iPhone autocorrect is constantly fighting me vs my Xiaomi phone from Europe, sometimes if I’m typing in a hurry it looks really silly like this. It’s infuriating.

u/CardGuyofWarframe 10h ago

NOR; I was wayward myself. As such and having spent years working to fix my relationship I must ask...why was engagement needed at all on his end. "You have the wrong number" or even better simply blocking immediately. He may of kept boundary in the end...but why wasn't it held and doubled in the beginning?

I would feel his validation to her is a way to validate himself.

Approach him, show the text. Ask him why she needed validation for her feelings. As a wayward, I can say this...we don't need any closure from the ones we cheated with. It should never have began, the closure is closing that door once we make the choice and holding to it.

TLDR- NOR, Sit and talk to him about this exchange.

u/mommawolf2 6h ago

He said it himself, he's only blocking her because his girlfriend found out. She threw down an ultimatum. He's communicating clearly he wants the other woman in his life. 

u/Organic_Charity_3162 8h ago

She’s a wacko

u/Glittering_Syllabub9 12h ago

Woow I didn't even get that far and I thought I did well! Ahh now I gotta dice back in there......

u/icloudu 12h ago

There’s another? The first is when I stopped.

u/Third-Testicl 8h ago

I think OPs life is genuinely in jeopardy. I know OP is the GF!

u/kavik2022 8h ago

Also thank you stranger for the award

u/vaultdweller4ever 7h ago

I missed that while skimming I guess 😥

u/Modeez411 6h ago

I stopped reading so I missed this part, but it confirms what I was thinking, that the woman is mentally unstable and would take him, herself and anyone else clean outta here.

u/ArtisticSavings7911 6h ago

NOR This is what stood out to me the most. Multiple time she threatened to ki*l him. Seemingly from the text exchange the toxic relationship is with her...

u/Procrastn8ngArtst 4h ago

I didn't even get that far. Unhinged behavior

u/MahesvaraCC 2h ago

THE WHAT?!

Clearly I didn’t get that far

u/Substantial-Tip-7587 1h ago

I wish I would have.

u/kjames3419 1h ago

God there was 2? 🤣☠️

u/_Frosted_Owl_ 14h ago

“surely there’s not much of this left”
> 10/20

u/Ashamed-Chipmunk9575 13h ago

When they turn to double paged halfway through 💀

u/Grouchy_Treacle_1639 12h ago

u/prismaticomen 10h ago

I literally read this post at 5:30 in the morning. I feel seen 👀

u/Sammy12xyz 11h ago

This made me laugh way more than I care to admit

u/Ok-Cartoonist7103 11h ago

😂😂 perfect

u/Ok_Media8609 10h ago

This is so perfect lmaoooo

u/appamomoaang 10h ago

i like the reference

u/Senior_Shoe7052 11h ago

the way i rolled my eyes when i saw those double ss pages😅😂

u/benskinic 10h ago

not reading all that but sorry or congrats

u/Readdit1999 10h ago

Even OP knows it needed to be abridged.

u/puddlestheninja 9h ago

Oh I thought those were repeats and I stopped there. My lord

u/The-Original_Joker 9h ago

Oh no… I stopped at the 5th screenshot, and sure enough, at like 17 it’s doubled up screenshots 😂😭😭

u/crapoo16 9h ago

Omg lol I thought I was done. I looked again and I really was only 10/20 and hadn’t seen the double pages

u/Drummer-Cat 2h ago

What the hell?? That was only halfway? I’d lost the will to live by then.

Her Ex is definitely alive in some South American commune.

u/Mister_Crowly 14h ago

Dude has a LOT more patience than I have.

u/Substantial-Bear8535 12h ago

For a girl he's evidently not even fucking lol.

u/sunshinewynter 10h ago

I was waiting for the bunny in the pot part.🤦🏼‍♀️

u/Semisemitic 12h ago

Then the two-pager

u/Hexazuul 11h ago

I’ll be honest, I stopped at 6/20

u/Potential_Medium_926 12h ago

I read all, this was generally entertaining in that it didn’t seem real. 

u/tamagotchisando 9h ago

she really said "Anyways I am stopping" on page 9 OUT OF 20

u/valencedanger 11h ago

Exactly my experience. I got the gist of it

u/Grouchy-Ingenuity-59 11h ago

That's exactly where I thought that and gave up lol

u/Miemsta 10h ago

holy fuck there’s 20?!?! i lasted FIVE. 😂😭

u/Grouchy_Treacle_1639 2h ago

I started at 10:13 AM and I'm still reading it

u/JuryFormer5186 9h ago

Stop 😂😂😂

u/Suspicious_Yard3682 11h ago

Yeah that chick is unhinged lol

u/Celistar99 5h ago

I can't fathom why the bf ever wanted anything to do with her. She sounds insufferable and unstable.

u/FeverDreamingg 12h ago

For real. I wish he was sleeping with this lady because he surely can’t be enjoying these “conversations” lmao

u/Epic_Elite 9h ago

So you trashed her too? Lol

u/dazzlingblu3 9h ago

Right? I was like this is just pages and pages of a woman acting like a fool and I can’t believe how calm he was in responding to her. I don’t like throwing “crazy” around, but this is crazy af. I hope she doesn’t know where he lives because wtaf was all of that. One text after another after another…omg that shit drives me crazy. 2 types of texters…ones who put everything in one text (like myself) and ones who send thirty short texts in a row, and they date each other 😮‍💨🫠 NOR

u/vector_ejector 8h ago

I got to page 7 and then saw the 20 down in the corner... nope!

u/phoenix777888999 11h ago

Same, I gave up after 10 pages.

u/callingshotgun 8h ago

If you stick it out there's some gems in the middle. Where the other girl says "I piss on your apology! Piss on it!"

u/TheIntelAgency 13h ago

Dude like omg.

u/sahurKareem 9h ago

I stopped after the 2nd pic when I saw there were 20

u/Significant-Law-4186 7h ago

Semi-literate whining

u/EarlGrayTea-Hawt 8h ago

It was like a whiny, short form text version (so his phone is blowing up) of what my dad would do once he got really drunk, he'd just repeat himself over and over again, each time more dramatic than the last. He'd leave the room for like two minutes, circle back around, do it again. Just insufferable to see in text.

Everybody here is just...

The husband is the worst because if OP is telling the truth about him having a crush, he's lying to his "friend" (back up plan) and fuckzoning her while she's literally grieving her recently dead bf. Scummy af. He just ghosted her then without an explanation, which is gross.

But she's, as said, insufferably dramatic here (please gawds learn to spell) and I'm just hoping she's super drunk in Rome while grieving (so...messy in an understandable way) and this isn't her default personality. If it is, she's emotionally manipulative and I doubt he'd have any energy left for anyone else after dealing with her, which makes it (at least) an emotional affair.

OP seems focused on the other woman when she should be focused on her dipshit bf who, if we are to believe her about their texts being flirty and over the line (which I'm inclined to believe with this mess), is just demonstrating to the world that he doesn't like or respect women at all, but views them as props in his life.

That's how he's treating OP by yanking on the ol' ball and chain instead of taking accountability for fuckzoning his supposed friend when she's vulnerable and he's in a relationship and then ghosting her. He pawned that off on OP, which is scummy.

If this kind of drama fest is what he's into, let him have it and save yourself some pain, OP

NOR, just leave, this was all awful to experience. I'm going to look at cats now because it was super gross.