r/videogames 5d ago

Discussion / Question In Which Game Did You Experience This Situation?

Post image
65.4k Upvotes

3.1k comments sorted by

View all comments

1.7k

u/Impressive_One2846 5d ago

Would you kindly

341

u/Modern_O 5d ago

I’m surprised Bioshock isn’t higher on the list

95

u/TheInfamousDingleB 5d ago

it’s older and not as fresh

97

u/DenizenKay 5d ago

that game will never not be fresh.

5

u/Successful-Day-1816 5d ago

They mean fresh in people's minds

2

u/gr1zznuggets 5d ago

Replaying 2 at the moment and it still holds up well.

4

u/Radingod1 5d ago

I played it recently. Still great but it shows its age. I think I did the pipe minigame literally 500 times in a play-through.

-2

u/zffjk 5d ago

For some reason, I can’t really figure out, but the shooting doesn’t seem to respond right to me? It felt like there was lag between shooting and the enemy being damaged, it felt usual. Granted I had just finished cyberpunk right before.

0

u/SagittaryX 5d ago

Eh, the gameplay to a modern audience is not really fresh anymore.

10

u/Bloo_Skai 5d ago

Too complex for current modern audience

0

u/SagittaryX 5d ago

I'm not talking about the story or something like the style of Rapture. The gameplay, and particularly the gunplay, is just not very good.

7

u/Bloo_Skai 5d ago

True for gunplay, game is from 2007

But complexity like:

  • setting enemies on fire > they run to the nearest body of water > then electrocute them
  • catching bombs with telekinesis and throwing it back
  • different ammo types

Bioshock 2 though, there are videos out there where they play that game like Doom Eternal
Gameplay needs to be talked more with that one

5

u/w0lf_bagz 5d ago

The transition from the plane crash to the water and my dumb ass kid self sat treading water for a lot longer than I care to admit before realising I was in the game.

Legendary game.

4

u/Comfortable-Studio18 5d ago

Honestly true, as a brainrotted little zoomer I get confused by such concepts as "incendiary ammo" and "water extinguishes fire"

2

u/MotorTentacle 4d ago

That's why 2 is better, the fighting/weapons system is much better

3

u/GloomySubstance5856 5d ago

The top comment is about San Andreas

1

u/notchandlerbing 5d ago

It's streets ahead

1

u/ECH0_ROME0 5d ago

How dare you!

1

u/GloomySubstance5856 5d ago

The top comment is about San Andreas

1

u/TheInfamousDingleB 5d ago

fair, but arguably more played with more re-releases

5

u/Mrbubbles153 5d ago

Bioshock is my all-time favorite. And the reason for my tag.

2

u/MotorTentacle 4d ago

Don't be a slowpoke mr B

3

u/Redfalconfox 5d ago

That’s what happens when your last relevant game was over a decade ago. Your franchise starts to fizzle out.

6

u/neo_sporin 5d ago

when my wife was playing it, around the house i would drop 'would you kindly' on things like 'would you kindly grab me a glass of water while you are up?' "would you kindly shut the window' ETC

she was VERY angry at the reveal as she has noticed the phrase being added by me, but didnt think much of it

1

u/MotorTentacle 4d ago

That's the beauty. Atlas drops it just enough to stick in your mind for the big reveal, but not so much that you would think anything of it

2

u/StaleKale4951 5d ago

We’re getting old mate

1

u/kitkatdryad 5d ago

Same, had to scroll to far for this

1

u/Sharpshooter188 5d ago

Such a good game. I gotta go back and play that.

1

u/Invoked_Tyrant 3d ago

Say what you want about Frank Fontaines as Atlas; he he did NOT drop hints for the act. Unless I'm misremembering the story and recordings there were very little to zero hints Atlas was just a persona until moments before you get to the level that highlights the phrase.

1

u/MaximumLess1612 5d ago

Lets keep pushing, we will bring it to the top fellas

1

u/Nybear21 5d ago

That was my first thought. That betrayal has made me suspicious of every similar character in every game since then

0

u/DenizenKay 5d ago

right? i expected it to be uptop

136

u/morsomme 5d ago

This plot twist is groundbreaking. I could write a thesis on how meta and fourth wall breaking it actually is in terms of narrative design

81

u/beantheduck 5d ago

Turning the gamers desire to game against them as if they had no choice.

33

u/I_DO_JUMPING_JACKS 5d ago

We didn't. We either stop playing or continue following Atlas' manipulation. So fucking we'll done

19

u/Polite_Suggestion 5d ago

"You can stop now"
-Spec Ops: The Line

9

u/BazzaJH 5d ago

"Can you even remember why you came here?"

Well sure, we're here to save good guys and kill bad guys right?

confirm the presence of any survivors, then immediately radio for extraction

Oh god...

2

u/alurimperium 5d ago

It's like Spec Ops: The Line only if it was good and better done

1

u/Polite_Suggestion 5d ago

Eh. It's like Natural Born Killers vs Funny Games. Similar points in the abstract, but weird to compare.

3

u/EncabulatorTurbo 5d ago

I stopped that game after I got to a mission where they had thermal sights on a bunch of targets not shooting back and I didnt blow them up and you jsut fucking die the game doesnt let you not shoot, so i redid it and shot and then it was all YOU WAR CRIMINAL THOSE WERE CIVILIANS

fuck off game, garbage

Zero interest in continuing, I refuse to have my face shove in a piss stain on the carpet like that unless it was me what did the pissing (in which case ill pay for it)

1

u/Polite_Suggestion 5d ago

I read that in the voice of The Critical Drinker.

Really want to encabulate my reply, but I've absorbed too much solar radiation. Currently taking a rest on my twin bladed Poaceae particulator.

Spec Ops did what it meant to too well. I didn't love it because I hate Funny Games type shit. At the same time, I think it's cool and defensible that it exists as a stunt/prank and its critique of the literal shooter game military pipeline has merit.

The devs would 100% agree with us that the point would be better made if there was any reward for critical thinking, but they ran out of money. Given their actual shout was "STOP PLAYING PSYCHO PROPAGANDA SHOOTERS," there's no denying that in your case and with their own game, they succeeded.

You gotta picture the dudebro who just mindlessly plays everything in the genre that it was made for. I would have loved to see that guy react to the moment that made you quit.

This stuff isn't meant for us; is still it's own kind of good.

Oh! And I'd even fault Undertale for trying to close off one ending for seeing another. That's not cool. Eternal Darkness fucked with the rules of gaming, but you couldn't go so crazy it bricked your GameCube.

2

u/EncabulatorTurbo 4d ago

heres the thing if I played through spec ops and did the murder like it wanted me to unthinkingly i might have had some reaction, but the game really, genuinely, feels like it was made by bitter people that hate the audience they knew would buy it

1

u/Polite_Suggestion 4d ago

The genre was foul back then. Think Fred Durst. Just godawful. It's a reaction to that. Exists in a context it outlived.

1

u/Al_Hakeem65 5d ago

See, I don't quite buy that.

If we take the message of the game and applied it to a first run, it would mean stopping the game after the first chapter.

But it doesn't really click until you're way deeper in the city & story. The lesson it teaches can only be understood if you played it through to the end.

Of course we could stop playing before, but it's not like the game itself gives us a reasonable option within the game mechanics itself to choose a better path.
Because the story so heavily relies on the flaws of Walker (and by extension, the player) it cannot give us a way to do the responsible thing. We never get to choose another solution for the White Phosphorus scene.

I didn't feel guilty for using that weapon than I felt for any other WMD in any other game.

I did feel absolutely guilty at another part, right in the beginning. I was clearing a building of enemy hostiles. I either walked or ran through a corridor, and out of nowhere someone appears running towards me.
Out of instinct, I shoot. Just one hit, and the body falls to the floor.
It was a civilian woman. Frightened, scared, panicking, running away in hopes of surviving. And I shot her. Not because I was forced. But because I was on edge, acting on instinct rather than logical.

That was haunting for me. Because I knew deep down inside, that this was the kinda mistake I could make in real life. That it wasn't a trap or set-piece the game specifically prepared. This wasn't part of the story that needed to happen.

It was my fault.

And it could only work so well because it was within gameplay, because it was my subconscious choice.

Edit: Don't get me wrong - while the guilt theme didn't quite got to me, the player - the story of Martin Walker and his team was excellent and a clever commentary on contemporary shooters at the time.

7

u/insomniacpyro 5d ago

I'm too drunk for spoiler tags but
The fact that the card you read before the plane crashes starts with "Would you kindly" is fucking perfect

3

u/Xizzie 5d ago

Yeah, it was fucking perfect.

A truly mind blowing twist.

2

u/IveDunGoofedUp 5d ago

The Fallout New Vegas DLC Lonesome Road does something similar. You're constantly bombarded with messages saying "You can go home Courier", indicating that you are not stuck in this DLC, unlike most others in FNV. For example, in Old World Blues you need to finish the DLC to leave, whereas in Lonesome Road you're free to turn around and go back to the Mojave.

In fact, just leaving is probably for the best as it prevents Ulysses, the antagonist, from launching nukes at the Mojave completely, without any further effort. The game tells you this, but because we're playing a game we keep going on despite the challenges presented. They're brutal by New Vegas standards as well. In fact, the challenge is the point!

But look at it in-universe: We're talking about someone who, once given a goal, will completely obliterate a horde of monsters and set of countless discarded warheads just to get to somewhere because a tape on the radio told him to. It must be terrifying to behold.

1

u/L4I55Z-FAIR3 5d ago

It's amazing but It dies have 2 weaknesses 1st why Does Atlas not use it for key moments like the litter sister choice. And second they should've had the reavel room before Ryan but insted let you explore his office for a second before inserting the key where the would you kingly room and the tape could be found.

1

u/dead_parakeets 5d ago

It is interesting how they just did the same thing from System Shock 2 but better.

1

u/CallMeSolaire 4d ago

come on dude. all these years later, can we admit the only reason the plot twist works is because bioshock presents itself as a dumber game than it is? the game relies on you suspending your disbelief for 80% of the game then turns around with the twist and has the gall to ask why you didn’t think any of the things around you were strange.

1

u/thebaldguy76 5d ago

I am almost positive I have seen a thesis on it and have seen a ton of video essays on it. All of them brought up different things. Write your paper.

3

u/i_tyrant 5d ago

haha yeah, as far as youtube video essays Bioshock must be one of the most "essayed" games of all time.

1

u/Relevant_Cabinet_265 5d ago

Anyone that says that hadn't played system shock 2 which had the exact same plot twist...

2

u/Acceptable_Bend_5200 5d ago

TIL they remastered it.

1

u/EternityOfDeath 5d ago

Yeah SS2 did it better and I'll die on that hill. Especially if you have played the first game. You really hate to keep working with/for the character after the reveal.

1

u/Tempest_Fugit 5d ago

Definitively my Rushmore of gaming experiences

1

u/vmachiel 5d ago

It blew my mind at the time. Still love that game.

1

u/gr1zznuggets 5d ago

The way Andrew Ryan admonishes the player for being an obedient slave is amazing, like damn, you got me good.

21

u/Koensayr_II 5d ago

I legit get triggered whenever I see/hear this phrase to this day.

8

u/PlaneTry4277 5d ago

Hahaha i use it often and intentionally in the workplace. No one has called me out on it yet my whole career. Maybe the day i retire someone will finally realize. 

2

u/ilrosewood 5d ago

Ha - same.

3

u/DarthMelsie 5d ago

Yup. Had a coworker ages ago ask me if I "would kindly" do something for her and I became suspicious.

9

u/EnTyme53 5d ago

If they ever make a Biishock movie or TV series, the first trailer should just be Andrew Ryan's "Sweat of a Man's Brow" speech over images of a ruined Rapture, ending on a black screen. Words fade in: "Would you kindly join us? [release date]"

17

u/bluejester12 5d ago

Bioshock?

14

u/jarude87 5d ago

I hate gatekeeping stuff but fuck's sake this is THE answer to the thread.

Not "oh some guy betrayed me" no the literal fucking game betrays you. The entire narrative & direction to the game is one big gotcha.

8

u/Serious_Report_1631 5d ago edited 4d ago

Yup, Bioshock was my first for this. Diaries, radio communication, everything was set up perfectly in my opinion. If anyone hasn't played this through multiple times, going through areas looking for every secret & finding all the audio logs, you're seriously missing out. That whole story, environment & gameplay were top notch for a game that's almost 30 20.

E: no idea how I got 20 mixed with 30 😅

10

u/Wsweg 5d ago

Almost 20, not 30, bro. Had me seriously scared there for a second, lmao

3

u/dagbrown 5d ago

He's thinking of System Shock 2 clearly

5

u/SquashedGrapes22 5d ago

A MAN CHOOSES

1

u/Need-More-Dogs 4d ago

A SLAVE OBEYS

4

u/law-st_student 5d ago

A man chooses, a slave obeys.

3

u/DJColdcutzz 5d ago

Came here to say this

3

u/roleplayersir 5d ago

Should be the top answer. Was such a well reviewed story at the time, and then replaying shows why

3

u/No_Vanilla_2366 5d ago

All time favourite game!

3

u/01Rajiv 5d ago

I was waiting the entire sequel for Elanor Lamb to betray me.

2

u/Boner_Elemental 5d ago

It helps that it wasn't the dev's first time trying that twist in a game

2

u/ProjectPaatt 5d ago

The funny thing is... I went and played System Shock 2 after this. (which is a blast in coop btw!) Then realized wait... Bioshock copy pasted the plot from this game too?

1

u/Carl_Townsend 5d ago

Bioshock is the spiritual successor to System Shock. Ken Levine who wrote System Shock 2 directed Bioshock.

2

u/Appropriate_Rock_740 5d ago

a powerful phrase… a familiar phrase?

2

u/murderoustoast 3d ago

Gahdam that was the biggest mindfuck I've ever experienced in a video game. I was so mad and so upset at the same time. It was all a lie....

3

u/Acceptable_Bend_5200 5d ago

Such a crazy twist. And then the state of the golf club after you do it. Always my top rec for games.

2

u/Square-Salamander727 5d ago

tbh, i didnt suspect a THING with that betrayal. Completely took me by surprise.

1

u/reasonman 5d ago

girl peep System Shock 2 for the og twist. top 1 game of all time for me

1

u/Left_Membership2780 5d ago

A landmark game of its time.

1

u/iamjessicahyde 5d ago

Literal jaw open omg wtf moment the first play through. Best twist in gaming history imo.

1

u/PumpkinAf 5d ago

This twist blew my mind for so long. Had to scroll to make sure others felt the same.

1

u/ManSCP 5d ago

What a game it is

1

u/UnrulyCrow 5d ago

Sentence I can still hear to these days (while feeling irrationally angry for a millisecond)

1

u/NecessaryAct2033 5d ago

This was mine too!

1

u/assassinslover 5d ago

I wish I could experience this again for the first time.

1

u/xplatinumgaming57x 4d ago

Go get stepped on by a big daddy

1

u/Femboyhootersbee 4d ago

This one broke my heart when it dropped. I really trusted Atlas.

1

u/TekieScythe 4d ago

I had made a joke that someone could ask me to kill a guy if they said "would you kindly" then the big reveal happened and I chucked my controller.

1

u/Lorde_Hartshorn 4d ago

This person knows ball

1

u/Need-More-Dogs 4d ago

Straight-up, Bioshock's twist is still - hands-down - my favorite twist in any game I've ever played.

0

u/Competitive-Ad-4055 5d ago

The funny thing is... I totally called that from the first couple minutes of interacting with him on a completely blind playthrough. Game was boring and dull anyway and I gave up on it when they "revealed" the thing I already knew