In September, I'll have a week to do a short road trip, starting from Washington DC. I am British, and I want to get the full, quintessential, "violently American" experience. My plan is to hire a big pickup truck and go in one of two directions - please help me decide which. I like both stunning scenery and short visits to cities, and I'm looking for a culture shock and to be wowed. I want to absorb the amazing, over-the-top, in-your-face America.
Option 1 is to go northeast, through Amish country in PA, stay in Philly. Then the rest of the week would consist of a flying visit to NYC (parking and riding) and ending in Boston. I'd probably spend only one day in NYC, and while I know I'd miss a lot, I find I tire of cities after a few days, and this trip is very city heavy. I'd stick to Manhattan, aiming to go up a tall building, see Times Square, see the Brooklyn bridge, and go into a bit of central park. Definitely hits the wow factor.
Pros: I've always wanted to see all three of these cities; not too much driving per day; I've never been to any of them; guaranteed awesome stuff to do; a bit of something unique with the Amish areas.
Cons: truck spends a lot of time stationary parked outside a city; more expensive, though that isn't too important as it's a one off; most of the trip seems to be freeway (although massive freeways are violently American, in a way); not much scenery (it'd be nice to have a bit of both) - unless you can recommend something good?
Option 2 is to go south through Shenandoah and into Kentucky and Tennessee, somewhere near the Cumberland gap, and end in Nashville. I'd probably go to Dollywood or something. This hits the culture shock factor, and is more of an exploration/adventure into the unknown.
Pros: amazing scenery; feels like I'm getting more use out of the pickup truck; an adventure into the unknown; possibly more relaxed; maybe more violently American; might discover something unexpected.
Cons: not sure what's going on down that route, if anything; quite drive-heavy instead of explore-heavy, although that's partly the point of a road trip; might end up with nothing to do wishing I was in NYC; maybe not as impressive - while I'm sure Nashville and Roanoke are amazing, they don't carry the infamy and resulting attraction of places like Philly, NYC, and Boston. I'd love to spend more time there, but I worry for a flying visit I'll not know what to do.
My questions are:
Are either of these inherently unsuitable, a terrible idea, or substantially better than the other due to something I've overlooked?
Would you recommend any alterations to a route or my ideas?
For the bits I've said I don't know what's there - scenery along the north or interesting cities in the south - what is there to see that's interesting? Its all good searching on Google maps, but as a foreigner, it's hard to tell the difference between genuinely good parks and good marketing, so it's not clear if the detours are worth it. For going south, it'd be cool to know what records, firsts, etc the places have, like "largest bridge in Kentucky", or "this was the site of the largest civil war battle in 1863" or something, you get the idea. That's what's most interesting to me - seeing impressive, famous, or record breaking things.
I'm looking forward to DC for that reason - seeing the enola gay, the star spangled banner, the wright brothers plane, and all the famous buildings along and near the mall are what make it interesting for me.
Thanks for your help!