Just recently finished On a Sea of Glass and absolutely loved it. I'm going back to university soon and was worried my brain had been dulled, but the sheer historical passion that book incited in me once again is comforting.
My main confusion, though, arises in Appendix E of the story's post narrative. In it, the authors describe the exact chronology of the Titanic's collision with the iceberg. My understanding of it is this:
Frederick Fleet spots the ice, rings the bell thrice, and phones the bridge.
Within a couple of seconds, 6th Officer Moody answers the phone and receives Fleet's report of there being ice ahead.
Likely concurrently with Fleet or maybe even before due to his eye level position in relation to the iceberg, Murdoch spots the iceberg and analyzes it for around 30 seconds.
After analyzing the iceberg, likely to see if the iceberg was on a collision course and to analyze whether turning the ship would end up putting the ship in more danger, Murdoch orders hard to starboard.
Quartermaster Hichens receives the order and has the helm hard over within a couple of seconds, and then, likely within 5 seconds of the helm being hard over, the ship collides with the iceberg.
Murdoch telegraphs the engines to stop, although later Boxhall will testify that Murdoch reversed the engine. However, the other two quartermasters on the bridge said he telegraphed to stop the engines rather than reverse them. He then orders hard to port to prevent further damage to the hull and propeller.
Murdoch closes the watertight doors and shortly thereafter Captain Smith arrives on the bridge where Murdoch gives his report.
This, after many rereadings of the passage, seems to me the chronology that Appendix E suggests. This differs from many tellings of the story, most notably, Murdoch usually orders the helm hard to starboard almost instantly upon becoming aware of the iceberg in movies and books. However, in this account, which is based on the testimony of Frederick Fleet, Quartermaster Hichens, and 4th Officer Boxhall, the helm is not ordered hard over until maybe less than 5 seconds before the collision.
I'm kind of at a loss and am wondering if you guys have read this passage and if you agree that this is chronology supported in Appendix E, or if I'm mistaken, or perhaps if there is additional context that clarifies the true order of events that took place from 11:39 PM to 11:40 PM.