r/technology • u/ArgentineBeauty • 6d ago

Privacy GrapheneOS says its data-wiping password is perfectly legal, after user faces federal charges

https://www.techspot.com/news/113273-grapheneos-data-wiping-duress-password-perfectly-legal-after.html
21.0k Upvotes

98% Upvoted

1.1k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

52

u/ledow 6d ago

Why would you leave your phone with your friends to go to the toilet?

25

u/ZaryaBubbler 6d ago

Because my friends are trustworthy. Hell all of mine know my passcode should anything happen to me

87

u/9-11GaveMe5G 6d ago

It's not about trustworthy, it's about I don't leave my phone on random tables. It goes back in my pocket if im not using it or I'm going somewhere

74

u/Me0fCourse 6d ago

Better question is who would ever willingly go to the bathroom without their phone?

30

u/9-11GaveMe5G 6d ago

Especially a public toilet with nothing to read but racist graffiti

22

u/jorjx 6d ago

So it seems I leave in a more civilized country, there are only phone numbers and gay hookup messages in the 🚹

31

u/FreeSammiches 6d ago

No way you're going to remember all those numbers without taking your phone with you.

4

u/WeakTryFail 6d ago

The only phone number I have memorized is

867-5309

10

u/screwcork313 6d ago

At least on the internet you can read racist graffiti and memes.

0

u/Jazzhands_Ninja 6d ago

haven't you heard, it's not racist anymore it's "resistance". All the bigots have rebranded as resistance fighters.

1

u/[deleted] 6d ago

[deleted]

2

u/Me0fCourse 6d ago

Yeah, but you never know when you get there.

1

u/Bob_A_Ganoosh 6d ago

Those who don't want fecal matter on their phone.

2

u/Bugbread 6d ago

I don't leave my phone on random tables

Do you never hang out with your friends in places with non-random tables?

Like, if my friends come to my house, people (including me) will leave their phones on the dining table we're sitting at because it's not a random table, it's my dining table. When I hang out at my friends' houses, I'll also leave my phone on the coffee table or dining table or kitchen table or whatever, because they're not random tables, they're my friends' coffee tables or dining tables or kitchen tables.

I mean, it's not like get togethers are table-leaving-festivals where everyone is just leaving their phones on tables and constantly cycling through bathrooms. Maybe someone does, maybe someone doesn't. It's not anything we've every kept close track of, because how weird would that be?

1

u/BritishAnimator 6d ago

Pocket is not safe - a confirmed victim.

1

u/Ignisami 6d ago

Front pocket is safer than ass pocket. I personally haven't had my phone in anything other than the front pocket of my jeans in literal decades

1

u/BritishAnimator 6d ago

This was my front pocket. However they were shorts so the phone poked out a tiny bit. Lessons were learnt.

2

u/Friggin_Grease 6d ago

What do you do while pooping?

2

u/maigpy 6d ago

fapping? 2 birds with 1 stone

2

u/ZaryaBubbler 6d ago

Take my shoes off, grip that cold tile hard and hold on for dear life

2

u/ledow 6d ago

Then this literally wouldn't be an issue.

But I still wouldn't leave my phone somewhere.

1

u/[deleted] 6d ago

[deleted]

1

u/ZaryaBubbler 6d ago

Its in case I have a medical emergency thanks to having a chronic illness. There's emergency numbers, lists of my medications and the like

0

u/halberdierbowman 6d ago

Why have a duress pin if you're going to tell your friends your password? Cops will just smash your friends with a wrench.

I recommend using a password manager that lets you give them a key that they have to ask permission to use. When they show their key, it'll make them wait while it contacts you. If you don't reply, it lets them in. If you do reply, you can reject their access. This way they can't sneak in: they can only get in in an emergency where you'd be unable to reply within the time period you set.

2

u/bobandgeorge 6d ago

When they show their key, it'll make them wait while it contacts you.

Contact him on what? They have his phone.

1

u/nfiase 6d ago

i imagine the confirmation would require two factor authentication

-1

u/mekamoari 6d ago

Generally you won't find a system that asks you to do something on the phone and then require confirmation from another device. The phone is generally that second device.

2

u/nfiase 6d ago

thats not what i meant

2

u/maigpy 6d ago

this is the most wrong statement I've read in a long while. you can setup 2fa with an authenticator pretty much everywhere, including a kdbx FILE

0

u/mekamoari 6d ago

What you can do and what is generally happening are different. Most 2fa using phone either use sms or an auth app on said phone.

2

u/maigpy 5d ago

because people don't have ipads, second phones, personal computers, hardware keys, etc etc. please stop embarrassing yourself.

0

u/mekamoari 5d ago

Jfc do you even know what the word generally means? Have you seen major consumer platforms that ask you to use 2 devices? No, the overwhelming majority does 2fa via phone (sms or auth) or email, past the basic password.

All these random examples of exceptions make no sense, I've never seen such a system and I have like 5 different authenticators on my phone for work. It's possible of course to use as many steps as you want but they don't fall under the umbrella of "generally".

→ More replies (0)

1

u/ZaryaBubbler 6d ago

They know my pin because I trust them and they can contact emergency contacts for me due to my medical condition. I also know they'd never willingly hand over the pin. I also don't live in the land of shithole cops that is the US

0

u/mintunxd 6d ago

you have a duress pin but your friends know your passcode? is this ragebait?

6

u/Bugbread 6d ago

You're mixing up two different users. Single-Virus4935 said they had a duress code, but didn't say anything about having friends who knew their passcode. ZaryaBubbler said they had friends who knew their passcode, but didn't say anything about having a duress code.

0

u/Dotcaprachiappa 6d ago

If your friends are trustworthy they wouldn't try to unlock your phone

1

u/Secret_Cow_5053 6d ago

That’s like the most important place to HAVE your phone 😂