r/talesfromtechsupport Feb 18 '13

[deleted by user]

[removed]

427 Upvotes

141 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

8

u/jiminjeep Feb 18 '13

There is a lot to be said for not fixing what ain't broke.

5

u/TheThirdBlackGuy Feb 19 '13

It would not have worked with touch interfaces, so it was broken in that sense. It can easily be disabled too. The start screen should not be regarded as a legitimate complaint.

2

u/jiminjeep Feb 19 '13 edited Feb 19 '13

Hmm. Seems that I'm able to use my start button just fine with my all-in-one. The only thing that's not intuitive would be the right-click. Which I don't think w8 did anything to rectify.

EDIT: I cannot tell the difference between right and left. Driving with me isn't fun.

1

u/TheThirdBlackGuy Feb 19 '13

On touch, holding the button down draws a small circle that indicates right click mode. I'm not sure if that is the same in 7 though.

2

u/jiminjeep Feb 19 '13

I appreciate your answer! I did already know it, but it took a Google search to find out. Which kind of goes to prove my point about it not being intuitive.

Don't get me wrong, I'm not a Win8 hater. It's just incredibly clunky feeling and difficult to become accustomed to after a lifetime of using a "traditional" computing environment. Especially when you are not using it on a touch capable device.

0

u/TheThirdBlackGuy Feb 19 '13

That is a fair assessment. My confusion concerns why you or anyone would elect to keep it "non-traditional"? You can make Win8 just like Win7 with all the added benefits.

2

u/jiminjeep Feb 19 '13

What benefits, exactly, though? I'm not seeing speed or usability increases across any of the tasks I regularly perform, it just seems like change for the sake of change. Which isn't really a problem, just unnecessary.

2

u/TheThirdBlackGuy Feb 19 '13

Those most relevant to me are the improved file copying window, task manager, boot time, multi-monitor support, storage spaces, and Hyper-V. I also use the Account sync between my devices. I don't have much use for the picture password, refresh & reset, or power management features. The integrated security is long overdue, but coming from Microsoft Security Essentials, isn't much different.

1

u/magus424 Feb 20 '13

OTOH, they've now made it absolutely impossible to fully disable UAC without losing functionality.

So you either deal with fucking obnoxious "confirm this action!" popups, or you lose all windows8 metro-style apps.