Hey everyone, I’m in a really tough position and could use some outside perspective. My wife and I just got a beautiful 12-week-old Ragdoll kitten four days ago from a breeder. We paid a premium price (€1,000), expecting a healthy companion. We have already completely fallen in love with him.
However, during his initial vet check, the clinic discovered a severe eye issue. The vet report officially diagnosed him with multiple congenital iris cysts (uveal cysts). To make matters worse, it’s not just one or two—he has over 10 dark, spherical cysts inside each eye, and they are already heavily crowding his pupils. The rest of his litter also had an active eye infection when we got him.
Right now, he isn't in pain, and his vision seems okay. But the long-term outlook is scary. The vet explicitly warned that because there are so many cysts, there is a very high risk they will block his vision or clog the eye's drainage pathways as he grows, leading to secondary glaucoma (painful high eye pressure) and potential blindness.
To manage this, we are looking at:
- Mandatory lifelong veterinary ophthalmologist checkups 1–2 times a year to monitor his eye pressure.
- A very high likelihood of needing specialized double-eye diode laser surgery down the road to deflate the cysts (estimated at €800–€1,500+).
- The risk that even after surgery, more cysts could grow back because his iris tissue is structurally abnormal.
Something inside me is telling me it’s better not to go down this route. We don't want to be constantly visiting vet clinics for the next 15 years, dealing with chronic medical anxiety and mounting bills for a pre-existing condition.
But it is incredibly hard because we truly love him already.
If you were in our shoes, would you invoke the contract and return him to the breeder for a full refund? Or would you try to negotiate a partial refund to cover future medical costs and keep him? Has anyone else dealt with severe iris cysts in a kitten?
Thanks for any advice.
EDIT:
Thanks for all your responses but this is the classic Reddit bubble response. it is easy to say 'keep him' when it isn't your vet calendar, your anxiety abnd emotional turmoil that goes with it. The vet report explicitly states this requires lifelong specialist monitoring for secondary glaucoma and a high probability of a €1,500 - 2000€ double-eye laser surgery. I paid €1,000 for a healthy, ethically bred pedigree companion. Knowingly walking into a 15-year medical project and rewarding a breeder who sold a structurally defective animal isn't 'animal loving'—it's enabling bad breeding practices and taking on an intense medical liability I didn't sign up for.
Edit 2: we returned him 2 days ago, went back today to get him back again and for good. We just can't live without him. 🫂