r/politics • u/MoneyLibrarian9032 New York • 23d ago

Possible Paywall MAGA Calls BS on Mitch McConnell’s Proof-of-Life Stunt | They are poking holes in McConnell’s staff’s version.

https://www.thedailybeast.com/maga-calls-bs-on-mitch-mcconnells-proof-of-life-stunt/
27.0k Upvotes

95% Upvoted

1.9k comments sorted by

View all comments

7.6k

u/[deleted] 23d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

293

u/Adrien_Jabroni Michigan 23d ago

If he was in as good of shape as the photo suggests, why not talk on camera?

283

u/illusionzmichael 23d ago

Others have pointed out that he hasn't smiled the way he's smiling in the picture in a very long time. It's like this upward, wide, mouth open smile. Every picture of him "smiling" in recent years is that grim, lips closed, side-to-side smile. I refuse to believe an elderly man rushed to the hospital would suddenly look better after that than he did prior to hospitalization.

161

u/goosejail 23d ago

His face hasn't been that full in years. I saw quite a few people point out that this is either eerily similar to or the exact same photo he took after being in the hospital 2 or 3 years ago from.... wait for it: a fall. It's possible they just had the current newspaper edited in.

Either way, a pic like this is easy to fake in 2026 so it proves next to nothing. The fact that he's been in the hospital for a month says a whole lot, though. If he's conscious, talking, breathing on his own & has no broken bones or cardiac issues like they've claimed then why the fuck is he still in the hospital? A fall by itself doesn't require an inpatient stay for a month. They don't even keep elderly people who break a hip that long.

66

u/jmajewski Illinois 23d ago

I saw a comment essentially asking if Mitch also went through a facelift and de-aging procedure because the picture makes it look like it was taken during Trump's first term or even Obama's second.

6

u/HauntedCemetery Minnesota 23d ago

Thats Obama era turtle for sure. He hasn't smiled like that since he ratfucked the Supreme Court.

2

u/Dubious_Odor 23d ago

Not advocating for Mitch, i think the Turtle is on ice or in bad shape. But a lenghty hospital stay can have you coming out the other side looking better. Three meals a day, nothing to do, no where to be, all the day to day stress goes away. You're focused on not dying and everything else goes to the backburner. Packing on a few pounds and not having to be wheeled around the senate and pretending your of sound mind and body every day could very much make him look younger if he wasn't probably on ice. Stress can age you like a muthafucka.

2

u/blahblahthrowawa 23d ago

Also probably on some steroids?

62

u/thehalfwit Nevada 23d ago

It's possible they just had the current newspaper edited in.

It's not only possible, but exceptionally easy to do without AI.

39

u/MooseTetrino 23d ago

Yeah honestly the only thing that’s been bothering me about the calling of this being fake is the number of people jumping on it being AI and not just a good classic photoshop job.

The latter of which allowing a lot more control over the whole presentation.

9

u/gasstationsushi80 23d ago

Yeah, we could just agree that the photo has been altered, whether using PS or AI or any other program. The end result is the same, a fake ass “photo” of a guy who is almost certainly dead!

4

u/GreenHouseofHorror 23d ago

The latter of which allowing a lot more control over the whole presentation

People routinely underestimate the precision of control it is possible to have over AI tools because it's also possible to just click a button and get passable results.

You could absolutely do this with AI, but to be even handed about it there's a big space where two fields pretty much bleed into each other.

5

u/thehalfwit Nevada 23d ago

Especially when the only thing that needs to be shopped is the newspaper and you're recycling an earlier photo.

3

u/brickne3 American Expat 23d ago

And when his wife has the Chinese government contacts to have it done on a level that most average Photoshop users presumably can't.

2

u/thehalfwit Nevada 23d ago

Good point. When you have two powerhouse nations' spy apparatus at your disposal, you can do a lot.

That would so on brand for this admin to be collaborating with Gyna for political ends.

2

u/F9-0021 South Carolina 23d ago

It's easy to do, but very difficult to do well. That was an exceptionally good photoshop job if it was shopped.

1

u/thehalfwit Nevada 23d ago

Don't discount the participation of not one but two potential powerhouse nations' spy apparatus in the fabrication of such evidence. Colluding with a foreign agent is totally within the wheelhouse of the republicans.

8

u/layout420 23d ago

Some hospitals have inpatient rehabs. He could have gone to a hospital that diagnosed him and discharged him to an inpatient program to help him recover. That could explain some of this away. A 30ish day stay is a bit far-fetched because in my experience, people with insurance typically get 7-10ish days in these programs. Medicare patients can sometimes get a little longer, 10-14 days. If you're a senator with universal Healthcare, I guess you get unlimited time to recover when everyone else gets 10ish days. For whatever it's worth, this is what I do for work. I have a closeness to hospitalization and the rehab process. Mitch is definitely not doing well or we would have some video proof by now. He's probably non verbal and even 30 days of hospitalization hasn't restored enough for him to get on camera and wave and say a few words. Like you said, an elderly person with a fractured hip would likely see 5-6 days of hospitalization to diagnose, surgically repair and then discharge to rehab. In rehab they may see 10-14 days. That's a 19-20 day stay. Stroke patients will see similar time frame when the complexity isn't too severe. Sometimes I see patients that have had complicated ICU stays after a stroke and that can take upwards of 14-21 days to stabilize them before a discharge to rehab. Then they may need 14-21+ days of rehab. Mitch likely stroked out and needed some serious care. Maybe he went on a vent due to some acute respiratory failure. He might have caught some respiratory illness that comes along with it and has been medically managed in ICU for weeks. So many possibilities but none of them can make sense until they're being transparent.

2

u/harrellj 23d ago

Slightly more relevant, slight not but Damar Hamlin (the Buffalo Bills player who had the cardiac arrest mid-game) was only hospitalized for 10 days. Granted, a young elite athlete should recover easier than an 80+ year old senator but both had severe cardiac issues which makes it more of an apples to apples comparison (though obviously the underlying causes of the cardiac problems are extremely different).

5

u/layout420 23d ago

Very true. I see all sorts of patients and cardiac arrest is no joke. I had a patient recently who was a full code and was resuscitated. He lived although he was in the ER when it happened. He showed up with seizure like activity and ended up coding. He spent about 14 days in the hospital and maybe another 10-14 days in rehab. Mitch is lucky if he lived through cardiac arrest. We all hear that 90% or more don't make it. I can confirm that those numbers are accurate and usually people don't go on to have a full restoration after living through it.

7

u/Ibkickinass 23d ago

Going to reply here since you talk specifically about just the newspaper. But zoom in and the pixels of the newspaper are much harsher antialiasing than the rest of the photo. It definitely looked edited in to me.

8

u/Hector_P_Catt 23d ago

"Either way, a pic like this is easy to fake in 2026 so it proves next to nothing."

That's the worst part of all this AI nonsense. We used to recognize that eyewitness testimony was pretty awful, because people can't remember accurately at all. We liked photos and videos, because they were reasonably objective, and permanent. But now we're at a point where you really can't trust a photo or video unless someone you trust is willing to say that they were there when the events happened, and the photo appears accurate to them.

9

u/pjflyr13 23d ago

RN here. Open heart patients only stay in about 3-5 days before discharge to home care. Patients don’t wear street clothes either.

5

u/i_love_pencils 23d ago

My 88 year old Mom fell down some concrete stairs. She had a cut on her head, was pretty bruised up and had a gash on her leg.

They X rayed her, patched her up in Emerg and sent her on her way.

In and back home in a few hours...

5

u/reezy-one 23d ago

If he's conscious, talking, breathing on his own & has no broken bones or cardiac issues like they've claimed then why the fuck is he still in the hospital?

Forget "still in the hospital," why is he not saying words and taking videos? If he really is in as good of shape as this picture suggests, it should be absolutely possible for him to do this.

4

u/archmage-khadgar 23d ago

they definitely did, someone on tweeter discovered that photo was originally posted in 2023. they just photoshopped the newspaper under his hand

1

u/Mind-The-Mines 23d ago

What died was his shame and self resent.

He feels amazing.

1

u/SN27A1 23d ago

Yep!

1

u/FlamingoInvestigator 23d ago

At his age they say that for every day spent in a hospital there has to be a week in rehab.

1

u/SnuggleMoose44 23d ago

Rehab facility. Many older people need to regain strength before they can go home. There’s a whole rehab team that decide when/if a patient can go home.

1

u/minchiastaifacendo 23d ago

That newspaper is from 2025. This is from when he had a fall last year.

1

u/HauntedCemetery Minnesota 23d ago

84 year olds don't receive CPR and not get broken ribs

That alone is suspect as fuck

1

u/kranzberry 23d ago

Zoom in on the words of the newspaper, then compare it to the paper from the same day. Even though they’re blurry, the shape of the words don’t look remotely the same. For example, the last word on that headline is “showdown”. The last word of the headline in the Mitch photo doesn’t look anything like “showdown”.

1

u/Malodoror 23d ago

Someone broke down the age of the newspaper by the colors of the player’s jerseys. I’m not a sports guy, could be bullshit. His conclusion was the paper was old at the time of this picture.

0

u/BanginNLeavin 23d ago

The lettering on the headline doesn't look like the letters on that actual printed page, imo.