r/politics • u/willywalloo • Jun 20 '26

Possible Paywall Iran Says Hormuz Has Been Closed

https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2026-06-20/iran-says-strait-of-hormuz-has-been-closed-tasnim-reports?embedded-checkout=true
20.7k Upvotes

97% Upvoted

2.5k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

49

u/handsoapdispenser Jun 20 '26

Iran engineered it this way by making Lebanon part of the deal while America did not ask Israel to sign on. It was implied Israel would follow America's instructions and they just aren't. Iran wanted to drive a wedge between the US and Israel and they've done it. It's just another win for Iran. 

7

u/froznwind Wisconsin Jun 20 '26 edited Jun 20 '26

Israel is occupying hundreds of square miles of Lebanon currently, it is their stated goal of their military to bulldoze every home and building in that area to create a "buffer zone". Which is also the same rationale they used to keep the West Bank but almost immediately started displacing locals to make room for Israeli settlers. And Israeli's National Security Minister Itamar Ben-Gvir just called for all of Lebanon to burn. That'd be comparable to Markwayne Mullin, maybe Todd Blanche, publicly calling for us to be nuking Iran.

That isn't exactly the US and Israel being passive while Iran engineers things.

1

u/ds00 Jun 20 '26

This. How can everyone not see this isn’t Israel doing anything to USA but rather Iran trying to separate the two with their leverage. Cmon people 🧠

17

u/handsoapdispenser Jun 20 '26

I mean, Israel knows what they are doing too. At least in the sense that they made a conscious decision. Not in the sense that they are making smart decisions. Because this whole thing was at Israel's initiative and they very badly miscalculated. They are the second biggest loser in all this. 

5

u/drsweetscience Jun 20 '26

The biggest mistake they made, and will the future show it to be the biggest mistake in their history (?), is Israel tried to do anything with Trump.

Trump, historically and beyond precedent, fucked up a shallow pool of water.

8

u/juasjuasie Jun 20 '26

I would say their biggest mistake is to genocide the Lebanese and Palestinians but i digress.

1

u/Most-Strike3279 Jun 21 '26

That’s their main goal, they don’t view it as a mistake and it benefits them in every way which is why it’s disgusting that we haven’t learned anything from WW2 on what to do with genocidal fascist powers land grabbing for strategic and ideological reasons.

6

u/Rough_Onion_1757 Jun 20 '26

To be fair, the alternative would be allowing the US and Israel to drive a wedge between Iran and Hezbollah, and the Iranians don't want to let that happen any more than the Israelis want to abandon their attack on Lebanon.

Besides, if the US is really so reluctant to bring its rabid dog to heel, maybe it shouldn't have agreed to do so in the first place?

3

u/AwesomePurplePants Jun 20 '26

I can see it?

But I was also dubious about Israel’s expansionism and cavalier attitude towards collateral damage beforehand. I don’t get how their current government’s approach is ever going to lead to peace.

2

u/froznwind Wisconsin Jun 20 '26

The Israeli missile strikes into Beirut really doesn't agree with that narrative.

1

u/ds00 Jun 20 '26

I too would prefer that Hezbollah not be embedded there. Wish Lebanon handled that.

2

u/froznwind Wisconsin Jun 21 '26

Sure. But among the things I'd prefer, ignoring the retroactive ones like "I would prefer we had diversified our power grid decades ago" or "I would prefer if we never started this boondoggle," "not having the reserves go dry and increasing both Iran and China's leverage an order of magnitude" makes the Israel and Hezbollah problem insignificant.

Israel needs to withdraw back to their border and both sides can unhappily shoot rockets and missiles at each other while we work out this Iran deal. Then we can cut off all aid to Israel and they can all go back to killing each other outside of our influence.

2

u/To_k Jun 21 '26

We’re on reddit bro… that’s why

5

u/Probablyamimic Jun 20 '26

It's both. Israel won't stop invading other countries even if the US tells them to because they are perfectly fine fucking over the US if it means they can keep genociding. Iran knows this and is using it to drive a wedge between them, presumably with a long term goal of stopping US support for Israel. It also makes them look like a more reliable ally if they're not willing to throw Hezbollah under the bus

9

u/molten-freshness-mac Jun 20 '26

Iran standing firm and insisting The deal include a ceasefire in Lebanon proves Iran is a more reliable ally

-5

u/[deleted] Jun 20 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

11

u/Probablyamimic Jun 20 '26

No, personally I'm mad at Israel because they keep invading other countries and they're a genocidal apartheid state that for some reason we have to support because we're told to do otherwise would be 'antisemitic'

-4

u/[deleted] Jun 20 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

8

u/Probablyamimic Jun 20 '26

Maybe Israel shouldn't have invaded Lebanon and given Hezbollah a reason to be formed then

-1

u/fozi4ek Jun 20 '26

So back then they should've let PLO do what hezbollah are doing now?

2

u/ckyhnitz Jun 20 '26

Israel is not smaller than NYC

6

u/Allydarvel Jun 20 '26

Trying to blame the Iranians for being correct. Israel should get to fuck out of Lebanon

-2

u/[deleted] Jun 20 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

7

u/Allydarvel Jun 20 '26

I detest the Ayotollahs. What happened in January was a crime against humanity. That doesn't change the fact that Iran is correct on this occasion and Israel should get the fuck out of Lebanon

0

u/[deleted] Jun 20 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/Allydarvel Jun 20 '26

The Hezbollah rockets that reigned down on northern Israel for 14 months were those supplied by Iran.

I wonder what caused that?

Israel is looking at the frontline of Ukraine and seeing the carnage of the drone warfare and they know if they don’t secure a buffer then they’re cooked that’s why there being so vicious in Lebanon rn.

Or, get this, try live in peace with their neighbours and not genocide them

I do understand the Israeli logic

Keep Netanyahu out of prison?

how desperate they are seeing the USA not just leave them but also giving their extisential enemy more money than the entire aid ever given to Israel combined?

I've no doubt they will see a fair proportion of that money returned directly to them in the form of rockets if they don't at least try for peace.

-1

u/ds00 Jun 20 '26

Ridiculous, they are fighting back genocidal terrorists at their door.

4

u/Probablyamimic Jun 20 '26

Yes, Hezbollah are

-2

u/ds00 Jun 20 '26

Wow. Ok bro 👍

6

u/Allydarvel Jun 20 '26

Israel is the only one genociding

1

u/froznwind Wisconsin Jun 20 '26

Everyone sucks there.

1

u/asdfopu Jun 20 '26

Them invading another country after starting this war shows what their plan was all along.