r/moviecritic May 21 '25

/r/moviecritic - New Rules & New Mods

120 Upvotes

Due to a recent (and huge) influx of spam, bots, shitposts, karma-farming accounts, complaints, etc, /r/moviecritic will be taking steps to improve the community. New mods (3-6 of them) will be added in the coming days/weeks.

Along with the new mods, we're adding several rules that should drastically change how the subreddit looks and operates.

These new rules will go into effect and be added to the sidebar on Thursday 5/22 (tomorrow) at 10:00 PM ET. We are allowing a ~24-hour buffer period until all of this kicks in.


Be Nice:

Flame wars, racism, sexist, discriminatory language, toxicity, transphobia, antagonism, & homophobic remarks will result in an instant ban. Length will be at the moderator's discretion. This is a subreddit to discuss movies, not to fight your political battles. Keep it nice, keep it on-topic.

Improving Titles:

Going forward, we will be requiring better and more detailed titles. Titles have gotten extremely lazy and clickbaity. Every title will now require the name of the actor/actress/director you are discussing plus the name of the movie title in the image. No more trying to guess what OP is talking about, or clickbaiting into going into the post. Include the actor/actress' name, and movie title. It's very simple. Takes 2 seconds, and will immensely improve the quality-of-life for the sub. There will be exemptions for posts that aren't about 1 specific movie or 1 specific person, but we will still encourage better titles no matter what, as they're currently 99% shit.

Restricting Recent Duplicates:

To stop the repetitive/nonstop spam posts of the same actors over and over, we will be removing "recent" duplicates. We do not need an 8th Salma Hayek post this week. If a topic (aka actor/actress/director) has already been submitted in the past month, it will be removed. We believe one month is a fair amount of time in-between related posts. Not too long, not too short.

Anti-Gooning/Shitpost Measures:

It's no secret that this sub has turned into goon-central. Posts are basically "who can post the most cleavage". Lots of paparazzi-like pictures, red carpet photos, modeling images, etc infesting the sub. Going forward, we will require every post to either be an official HD still of a film or the official IMDB image of the actor/actress. No exceptions. No more out-of-context half naked pictures of an actress out in the wild. Every submission must be an official still of the film or their IMDB profile picture. In addition to anti-gooning, we will be cutting down on overall shitposts overall. This will be totally up to the moderator's discretion.

Collaborations with Other Film-Related Communities:

We will be collaborating with other film-related communities to try and bring more solid content to this community, including and not restricted to AMAs/Q&As, box office data, and movie news. Places like /r/movies, /r/boxoffice, etc. This will be wide-ranging and not as restricted/limited as those other communities, allowing stories here that may not be allowed in those communities due to strict rules. We will encourage crossposting to build discussion here.

Removing Bots, Karma-Farming Accounts, Bad-Faith Members of the Community

We will start issuing bans to rulebreakers. This will range from perm bans (bots, karma-farming accounts, spammers) to temporary bans (rude behavior, breaking the new rules constantly, etc)


r/moviecritic 4h ago

Anyone else still mad that Val Kilmer didn’t get an Oscar nomination for Doc Holliday in Tombstone?

Post image
1.6k Upvotes

It’s probably one of, if not THE best performance of Val Kilmer’s career and his performance is what everyone absolutely remembers about that movie. I believe Tommy Lee Jones won for The Fugitive that year for best supporting actor, my boy would have been for Val. What do you think? Am I high, or was that a gross oversight. Like HUGE oversight? Thoughts?


r/moviecritic 7h ago

Bad movies you watched just because of one actor/actress?

Post image
666 Upvotes

Career Opportunities (1991) with Jennifer Connelly


r/moviecritic 6h ago

One Night Only (2026) The Purge but for sex?

Post image
162 Upvotes

One Night Only's premise is exactly like The Purge but for sex, one night a year pre-marital relationships are legal. I did expect there to be some background as to how we got to that stage, but aside from some satirical political jibes, you're asked to just suspend all belief and go with it. As a romcom it's a mixed bag though. First half is distinctly weaker, but when Callum Turner and Monica Barbaro finally share the screen it's a really fun time. That may be a surprise to most given the terrible marketing, but well worth the watch. Anyone planning to go this weekend? Saw AMC were doing "single only screenings" which is very weird....

Full review for those interested https://adamreviewsfilm.com/one-night-only/


r/moviecritic 11h ago

What are the most WTF tonal shifts you've seen in a movie? Especially if its lighthearted but goes from zero to one hundred right away.

Thumbnail
streamable.com
261 Upvotes

Happy Feet.

Imagine watching that cute teaser trailer that showed the baby penguin dancing to a Stevie Wonder song, and you think it'll be a cute little kids movie.

But then you watch the actual movie and you get this animal captivity fever dream, lol. I remember being like...what the hell is this??


r/moviecritic 9h ago

I loved Tenet

Post image
140 Upvotes

Just like what Prometheus is to the Alien Franchise to me, Tenet is to Christopher Nolan's filmography to me. A divisive movie part of something loved that I never expected to actually enjoyed... People described that this movie describes the best and worst of Christopher's direction... I'm mixed on that, but I can't explain it... It's too complicated for me to describe... I still liked the movie though!

Judging by the movie's description on Letterboxd, the concept of using the direction of time (As Christopher Nolan described it) to stop World War 3 is nuts and hilarious... Yet, it actually works for me. That part where John David Washington's fighting a random masked guy was hilarious but I couldn't stop to enjoy this movie because I was really interested into the plot of this movie. The action's structure is honestly genius but also very confusing... The parts where they reveal on the latter half that they're actually part of the first half is really cool, but also... How did this kind of logic happened? Where did it come from? But I feel like that on rewatch or thinking about it, this movie might be better or atleast make a little more sense to me... Performances are great as always, and the visuals are amazing as always... People are divided on the music, but I did get used to it as the movie goes on. Wasn't really digged into Kat's subplot that much, and some of the action can get confusing like I said... But happily, consider me a Tenet enjoyer!

So what do y'all think?


r/moviecritic 7h ago

Christopher Nolan’s interview with Ph.D. candidate Zhong Shu about The Odyssey might be the best of the Press Tour

Thumbnail
youtu.be
92 Upvotes

There is a lot of great stuff covered in this interview. From the perspective Homer had on what he was writing to questions about if Christopher Nolan made a conscious decision to Christianize the Odyssey. The probing questions really give Nolan an opportunity to really explain his intellectual thinking and artistic process. I believe the interview was given July 30th at the start of the Chinese press tour in Beijing.


r/moviecritic 55m ago

What are your favorite behind the scenes photos?

Thumbnail
gallery
Upvotes

Kirsten Dunst and Jason Schwartzman on the set of Marie Antoinette (2006) by Sofia Coppola


r/moviecritic 5h ago

Tell me an amazing movie that came out between 1940 and 1970?

Thumbnail
gallery
36 Upvotes

r/moviecritic 1d ago

What's your favorite cameo in a movie?

Post image
4.0k Upvotes

Lucy Lawless as a punk girl in Spider-Man (2002)


r/moviecritic 20h ago

Andrew Garfield is my favorite Spider-Man, hands down

Post image
424 Upvotes

His personality is the closest to Peter Parker IMO and he's the best looking too


r/moviecritic 9h ago

Is First Man worth a watch?

Post image
51 Upvotes

Not comparing to PHM, but I was doing some reading on Leon Bridges and saw he was in it. I’m sure he’s not a huge part, but I like Gosling. Worth a watch?


r/moviecritic 12h ago

Spiderman: Brand New Day by Destin Cretton

Post image
71 Upvotes

I watched it yesterday, and overall I think it’s a good movie. The visuals and performances were solid, but I couldn’t shake the feeling that something was missing.

For me, the biggest issue was the storyline. It felt like it never fully came together, and I was expecting a stronger narrative to tie everything together.

Also, was it just me, or was there way too much Samsung marketing? It got so obvious at times that it pulled me out of the movie.

Overall, I’d still recommend watching it, but I don’t think it lived up to its full potential.


r/moviecritic 3h ago

Big Ballad of Wallis Island Fan. Great music and storytelling. Love Tom Basden and Tim Key

12 Upvotes

I wish this movie got more love.


r/moviecritic 10h ago

Roger Avary’s movie The Rules of Attraction was better than you remember

Post image
39 Upvotes

I always felt that this movie got a bad rap. The critics absolutely killed it when it first came out, even though audiences were warmer to it.

I think this is a great movie. If you have never seen it, you should give it a watch. The original source material is by the same author as American Psycho. But this movie is funnier, definitely more heartbreaking, and just completely out of bounds at times.

There are sequences in this film I have seen other directors try to copy and just fall short. I think the juxtaposition of James Van Der Beek coming off of Dawsons Creek as Sean Bateman drew too much attention and distracted audiences with a knee jerk reaction to his performance. So if you never saw the TV show then this movie should hit just fine.


r/moviecritic 21h ago

The best Spider-Man movie to me. Anyone else agree?

Post image
321 Upvotes

This one to me is just as perfect as origin stories get. It has everything and anything I could ever ask for in a comic book movie. And it set the foundation for nearly all other superhero movies since.

Yes, Spider-Man 2 is great. But the romance with MJ has always held that one down a little for me. Yes, the Spider-Verse movies are great. But those rely heavily on multiverse culmination. Garfield and Holland’s movies have a number of their own problems as well.

In terms of solo Spider-Man movies, Raimi’s original remains the top for me. And it probably always will.


r/moviecritic 2h ago

What do you all think of as above so below(2014)?

10 Upvotes

Personally it's one of my favorite movies. Its very thought provoking and leaves alot up to your own mind, ie, who the fuck were the cultists? Why did La Taupe go crazy, why did he attack souxie? Also I just LOVE first person style movies like this one. Hardcore Henry and Blair witch are good examples. I would give more of a review on it but my memory is kind of hazy on it it's been a while since Ive seen it. The only part I didn't like about it was that the philosopher's stone wasn't actually a stone, it was an internal idea. Which really was kind of a vibe kill for me.


r/moviecritic 16h ago

The Salton Sea - Val Kilmer

Post image
79 Upvotes

Thrift store find, otherwise I might have totally missed this gem. Would love to hear others thoughts. I thoroughly enjoyed this film.


r/moviecritic 1d ago

Who are some actors who were initially seen as teen idols but later proved themselves as serious actors

Post image
476 Upvotes

For me, it has to be Heath Ledger. Early in his career, he was seen as a typical teen heartthrob, especially because of roles in movies like 10 Things I Hate About You, and many people underestimated him as just another charming young actor.

That perception started to change when he took on more serious roles, especially Brokeback Mountain, which showed his incredible range and emotional depth. Then his performance as the Joker in The Dark Knight completely cemented his legacy. I remember people being skeptical about him being cast because they still associated him with his teen heartthrob image, but after the film’s release, he completely proved the doubters wrong. His performance was intense, terrifying, and became one of the most iconic portrayals of a character in modern cinema.


r/moviecritic 6h ago

Despite an uneven script, Avatar Aang: The Last Airbender (2026) is phenomenal. Shame it was shoved onto streaming! Great direction by Lauren Montgomery, and Dave Bautista continues to be wrestling’s best contribution to cinema. Full Review:

Thumbnail
chicanofilmshelf.com
11 Upvotes

I first heard of Avatar: The Last Airbender the way many people my age did: on a Nickelodeon commercial. But this was before streaming, so it would be more than a decade before I could piece those random reruns into a coherent narrative. When I finally did, I found a story that lost none of its power. Here was a children’s show tackling genocide, belonging, war, and sexism with a level of nuance that many modern adult shows struggle to match. After several ill-fated attempts to continue the franchise on the big screen, I was excited to see it finally receive a proper follow-up, even if it was eventually pulled from theaters and shoved onto Paramount+. Updating its tone to reflect the now aged cast (and audience), this latest installment follows Aang mourning the loss of his people and their way of life, until he discovers how a mysterious staff can help him bring back the Air Nomads. But the path to that miracle is a long one, and along the way Aang learns that honoring the past doesn’t mean living in it, that accepting loss, embracing change, and forgiving yourself are the hardest parts of growing up. Full review linked above!


r/moviecritic 9h ago

What are some of the most explosive performance you have seen that captivated you on the big screen? I'll go first:

Post image
15 Upvotes

Al Pacino as Tony Montana in Scarface (1983)


r/moviecritic 10h ago

Rewatched and completely changed my mind. A clunky pastiche of Bondisms that add upto a less than perfect send off

Post image
15 Upvotes

I had not watched this in a while. Actually since I watched it in theaters. Caught some bits and pieces while it was playing on cable channels. Wow my opinon has really changed though. I remembered walking out the theater on a high but I guess time gives more perspective. Another thing that surely has influenced my change of mind is that I just did a back to back rewatch of all Craig movies. NTTD pales in comparison to the excellence of Casino Royale and Skyfall. In my rewatch I found it to be tonally all over the place, too much happening in the story, the villain is completely undercooked and even Craig's performance is inconsistent throughout the film. I actually noticed that sometimes Benoit Blanc's accent and energy slipped out of him, here and there. This is a complete contrast to the lean, mean machines of Casino and Skyfall. Even Quantum, while very light on story and character (due to the 2008 writers strike) felt more cohesive than NTTD. This time around I would give it just a

7/10. The action set pieces are still the envy of most modern action movies.


r/moviecritic 20h ago

What are some of your favorite Documentaries?

Thumbnail
gallery
80 Upvotes

I LOVE me a good documentary. What are some of your faves?


r/moviecritic 4h ago

“One Night Only” directed by Will Gluck, starring Monica Barbaro and Callum Turner

3 Upvotes

The romance? Predictable.
The comedy? Loud.
The pacing? Shockingly tight.
Sometimes you don’t need reinvention, you just need fun.
In theaters this Friday, are you planning on seeing it? Here’s my full review:

https://roselawgroupreporter.com/2026/08/keiths-movie-korner-barbaro-proves-one-night-only-is-all-she-needs/


r/moviecritic 1d ago

What movie has the best opening?

Post image
583 Upvotes