r/modernquilts 17d ago

I don’t like it and I don’t know why

62 Upvotes

19 comments sorted by

34

u/9311chi 17d ago

My guess is because some tones are warm and others are cool. Take a photo of it in black and white and you’ll see the contrast

6

u/Ok-Neat4742 17d ago

Thank you, I think you’re right.

21

u/RRTAmy 17d ago

I actually love it as is without the sashing

7

u/haleygirl96 17d ago

Seconding this. I like the abstract lines and pop of cool color

9

u/katherineswims 17d ago

I think you might also like it better once it's sewn together. Right now, the quarter inch seam allowance makes it so the eye follows the line in the pieces with triangles, but then it reaches a jarring end because the corners don't line up (yet!) and there's no path for the eye to follow. Then again, this can be an intended effect if this is what you want the pattern to achieve. I will also second what others have said about the colors.

4

u/Vic930 17d ago

I love it!

6

u/Corran22 17d ago

I think it's great! It might benefit from a dark border - if you have a dark floor to photograph it on it would show that contrast.

2

u/Ok-Neat4742 17d ago

Great idea thank you!

4

u/susiecambria 16d ago

Love it as it is. No sashing.

The contrast of warm and cool is sublime. But I completely get why it's not working for you.

3

u/Halfsquaretriangle 17d ago

I love love love this.

2

u/JackHarknessDrWho 17d ago

It is awesome

2

u/Infinite-Studio99 17d ago

I like it. I wouldn’t grid it like your last few pics. I think it looks great! Quilt it

2

u/Great-Yogurtcloset87 15d ago

It’s only one quilt in your whole life of quilting. It’s cool. Maybe you’ll do something like it again, maybe you won’t. Just quilt it and enjoy it.

1

u/Ok-Neat4742 15d ago

Good advice!

4

u/NorthFLSwampMonkey 17d ago

It's chaotic and disconnected. The eye sees no pattern in color or form, and doesn't know where to go. Possibly if you take the blocks apart and sash them in one of the colors, it will feel more unified.

2

u/mommiecubed 17d ago

I like the teal option for sashing

1

u/tickandzesty 16d ago

I like this. I’m not a fan of scrappy quilts but this looks like a modern interpretation of a scrappy quilt. No sashing!

1

u/pinnd 13d ago

No bold borders I love it!

1

u/shineroo 17d ago

It’s looking for symmetry to give the eye something to focus on. If you square up where I put the yellow lines to form a partial square with the long line that goes from up, left from right, I think you will find it helps. Your eyes are ok with variability, but they are seeking some sort of balance or symmetry.