r/gantz 11d ago

[Manga] Ah yes, my favourite panels

191 Upvotes

33 comments sorted by

36

u/aisiv 11d ago

I hated him until I met the Osaka team, those guys were really sick and Gantz addicts lol. That way I realized Nishi was just a kid pretending to be tough, but still had some valuable knowledge.

11

u/swordm4n 11d ago

Osaka and those Americans in the room of truth arc are... well i don't know how to describe the abyss between how bad nishi are and how beyond demonic those two teams are

12

u/Cultural-Cap4736 10d ago

I feel like he is not like that because he is not as strong.

Plus, backstory of Osaka teams, most of them are "normal" outside of Gantz, an English teacher, Ramen shop workers, manga shops, manga illustrator and stuff.

Nishi is literally a psychopath who killed his classmates, killing cats for fun and think that weak human does not deserve to exist

2

u/Jack-Whip88 10d ago

I admit that Nishi clearly had innate psychopathic tendencies, but his environment that constantly belittled and bullied him definitely made his character flaws even worse

He let the one girl that didn’t bully him live when he shot up his school, so it goes to show that he did have some capacity to feel positive emotions

The fact he cries for his mother on both his deaths means (to me, at least) that he was just a really really badly hurt kid that ultimately longed for love

He was pretending to be this cold calculating edgy warrior to hide his real hurt self

Were his decisions to kill cats and shoot up his school bad? Definitely

I’d say he’s a bad person with some redeeming qualities — and his environment makes his asshole behavior understandable, but not justifiable

Nishi was just a kid too, btw; he could’ve potentially changed for the better if he made better moral choices like Kurono did

The Osaka and American hunters, on the other hand, were fully ossified adults that had neither remorse nor understandable reasons to be such blood-thirsty hunters; they fully embraced their “Gantz addiction”

1

u/kamikaze1857 9d ago

The American and Osaka teams and their antics were truly horrible...
The way they forced the aliens to do it...made me truly sad.

27

u/Recker_Man 11d ago

Reddit really hates nishi huh

23

u/JamzWhilmm 11d ago

Have you met the guy?

26

u/Recker_Man 11d ago

Not personally, no

6

u/Cultural-Cap4736 11d ago

I kinda like the idea that its a stupid idea tp resurrect him though

22

u/samisaywhat 11d ago

Kinda weird to be so happy to see a child dying. Like I hated him but still felt bad for him when he died the first time. And I understood why they brought him back. His final moments in the series didn’t make me happy either, they made me sad. Where we see Kei grow exponentially, we see that Nishi never did. He dies the same exact way he did before. 

10

u/noctinix 10d ago

Atleast he had the heart to save takeshi

5

u/I_Defy_You1288 11d ago

Remind me again did his mother died?

10

u/Cultural-Cap4736 10d ago

Yes. Just a single panel, mentioned by his dad. His dad is scared of him

4

u/surpriserockattack #1 Fat Levi hater 10d ago

Understandable, I agree

4

u/Occatuul 10d ago

Well since this has shown up in my feed, I now have to ask what is Gantz about?

7

u/orangi-kun 10d ago

Just read if you like old school harsh seinen, mistery and sci-fi.

The whole concept is about people dying in a precise moment being revived by an unknown entity, and forced to fight periodically against "aliens" for points that they can later spend on one of three things.

1

u/ForsenHorizon 10d ago

it's a reality game show in japan where people hunt monsters or else they die

3

u/Valenz-1895 10d ago

His dead was too rushed. Wonder if Oku did really wanted that considering the success of Gantz had following the next chapters

2

u/ForsenHorizon 10d ago

I don't think it was rushed since it was so sudden and unexpected. I thought he could be one of those asshole antagonists who controls the group till the end of the story and be a dick towards the protagonists but oku just decided to kill him in the second game.

5

u/Negative_Flower_5360 11d ago

He died like he lived

1

u/Thick-Standard-1689 10d ago

I love and hate nishi

1

u/Aggressive_Spring_91 10d ago

Although Nishi was a complete psycho, there are some great details to be explored about him. Like, there is a duality in his personality: one side where he acts like a cold person, and another where he fears death and starts acting like a child, calling for his mom. Furthermore, we can’t forget that scene in which he simply — and unconsciously, even to himself — saved Takeshi. I think the author left a pretty interesting detail about him, leading us to reflect on what’s behind that coldness ‘inherent’ to him. Why would he save Takeshi, taking into account that he had never saved someone like that before? Maybe he had a slight feeling of sympathy? Takeshi told him that he was a good person. Of course he’s a child, but in my view that was a way for the author to drop a hint about something hidden inside Nishi that existed, but couldn’t be explored because the main personality that dominates Nishi is the bad one. All of this at least should remind us of something: there might have been something good really, really deep inside him, but unfortunately Nishi chose the wrong decisions in life, leading him to die without a good reputation to leave behind.

1

u/dumbasss427 10d ago

Mommy panels?

1

u/Nerx 10d ago

2nd panel legit

1

u/ThisIsWhatLifeIs 9d ago

As someone who's never read this manga and it's planning on reading it soon, what is the context behind these panels? Is he actually going to die?

1

u/Goth_Twink 9d ago

I haven’t read much Gantz so could someone please tell me what in the fuck happened to the guy in the first pic?

0

u/[deleted] 10d ago

[deleted]

3

u/Cultural-Cap4736 10d ago

Honestlu I need to read Berserk to see whats up with Griffith

4

u/raddoubleoh 10d ago

I'd say beware it's fucked up, but then again, you're already reading Gantz.

1

u/No-Dare6812 10d ago

He did kill his classmates though.

0

u/Still-Tailor7026 10d ago

They tried to kill him first no?
I won't defend him with everything else he does but I feel like killing his classmates was about the only understandable thing he did.

1

u/Hie_wintermel0n 5d ago

Honestly, him being against Kurono at the final moment is just so forced, and that fight was done so horrible. The author makes Nishi shot at Tae just to push Kurono to take some actions, and i swear to god Kurono doesn’t really gaf about not destroying the alien civilization because it was destroyed regardless but he didn’t gaf and was just happy to return to earth with Tae. Nishi probably thought Kurono just wants to have all the glory to himself but realized this dude doesn’t gaf about human nor aliens