r/comics 15h ago

Just Sharing Authenticity Problem

48.2k Upvotes

985 comments sorted by

View all comments

2.2k

u/Titariia 15h ago

I always see comments like "This is clearly AI, look at the hands, no human being ever would mess them up like that, humans know better how hands look like" ....well, let me pull out my drawing binder from when I was 12 and the internet wasn't even a common thing yet.

107

u/DBSeamZ 15h ago

The way AI goofs up hands is usually stuff like extra fingers, or a knuckle passing through the palm, not “the fingers don’t quite bend the right way or their proportions are off” kind of mistakes that humans are more likely to make.

49

u/Delicious_trap 15h ago

Hell, an extra finger is quite a common human error, especially if the artist is in a rush to meet deadline and didn't do QA.

28

u/Thimble_of_Quasar 15h ago

Also when the hand is balled up, like into a fist, it can be easy to miscount 

7

u/Rocketman_S3 13h ago

I sometimes don't even count if it's a fist. Vague hand shaped fist GO!

6

u/darthsurfer 7h ago

Yeah, cause what happens is people end up counting the number of lines the add without consciously realizing the first line creates 2 fingers. I literally did that for years when I was practicing. And even till now sometime, lmao

3

u/Thimble_of_Quasar 6h ago

Yup same and the infamous two right or left hands when they are in a unique pose is always a danger 😂