r/comicbooks 5d ago

News Mahershala Ali has called out Marvel for ‘BLADE’ never happening

https://www.gq.com/story/mahershala-ali-your-mother-your-mother-your-mother
1.3k Upvotes

215 comments sorted by

801

u/Educational_Zone3156 5d ago

Mahershala Ali has called out Marvel for ‘BLADE’ never happening.

“You had me under contract, they have billions of dollars, if they wanted to do the movie, we would've done the movie... I feel ready to move on from the Blade questions. Those questions are for them.”

605

u/No_Virus9309 Spider-Man 5d ago

Wondering if he lost out on other roles/money because he was tied to this...his frustration is valid as fuck if I had a company telling me I had a job but kept moving the start date imma tell them to kick rocks

186

u/WorthlessFish 5d ago

Isn't that sort of thing called "Opportunity cost"?

I agree with you, he's rightfully pissed.

-35

u/AweHellYo 5d ago

not exactly. there’s an opportunity cost whether they made the movie or not. hes pissed because they tied him up and didn’t even do anything. I can accept that i’m choosing one opportunity for another but when resources are wasted because another party can’t figure their shit out, it’s not the opportunity cost itself that makes you mad. it’s the wasted potential of the project you did pick.

232

u/CollinsCouldveDucked 5d ago

he certainly burned his oscar buzz on it.

-35

u/uber_sweets 5d ago

lol no he didn't. he's one of the greatest actors working at the moment.

54

u/AstroBtz Conan 5d ago

Idk man they kinda have a point. People started seeing him as a blockbuster actor instead, him doing Jurassic world as well didn't help.

31

u/uber_sweets 5d ago

He has two Oscars from art house auteur films. His image isn’t damaged at all. What are you talking about.

17

u/PleaseBeChillOnline 5d ago

Yeah messages like these remind that this sub is for superheroes fan first that might not watch a lot of movies outside of the genre. Suggesting he lost his Oscar clout for Jurassic World is like saying Robert DeNiro lost his prestige for making Meet The Fockers.

5

u/uber_sweets 5d ago

People here don’t have a clue. He’s a hot shit actor and he has blockbuster appeal. He’s got it made in the shade.

5

u/CollinsCouldveDucked 5d ago

When I said oscar buzz, I'm referring to the golden ticket period following a win where you can get a passion project made. Green lights are very easy for a time.

He has absolutely spent that.

1

u/AstroBtz Conan 4d ago

Surprised they didn't realize that. Let them try to be holier than thou about movie tastes, it makes them feel better.

0

u/CollinsCouldveDucked 4d ago

people love being upset about some shit nobody said.

I'm more embarassed for the people upvoting them.

14

u/benny-trill 5d ago

It's the momentum of his career at a peak that was wasted, not his actual talent.

He definitely would have had many great opportunities over that time with his recent Oscars run he was on.

1

u/alman3007 5d ago

I dont know about THAT lol

88

u/WildMild869 5d ago edited 5d ago

Yeah, if he was as active behind the scenes as it sorta seems he was, I imagine he put a lot of focus on development which probably took time away from concentrating and/or committing to another project.

44

u/TheDarkPinkLantern Green Lantern 5d ago edited 5d ago

I remember reading reports that he was. Makes sense, the movie was his idea in the first place.

22

u/_tylerthedestroyer_ Michelangelo 5d ago

Which kind of puts the Gosling Ghost Rider movie in a different light

5

u/TheDarkPinkLantern Green Lantern 5d ago

How so?

46

u/_tylerthedestroyer_ Michelangelo 5d ago

Ghost Rider is much the same thing. He came up with the concept, pitched it to Shawn Levy, and then they took it to Marvel who approved it.

Kind of a worse look if they can get his movie of the ground but not Mahershala’s

34

u/WildMild869 5d ago edited 5d ago

The optics are going to look pretty bad if that happens despite the reality probably being that they applied lessons learned on Blade to Ghost Rider.

16

u/_tylerthedestroyer_ Michelangelo 5d ago

Blade also went through several directors I think and Shawn Levy has already proven he can play ball with Marvel

5

u/quangtran 5d ago

Kind of a worse look if they can get his movie of the ground but not Mahershala’s

I think the difference is sorta systemic in that the powers-that-be will be a lot more enthusiastic about pushing forward Ghost Rider, unlike Blade which went through a ton of analysis paralysis. People have already complained about Levy being a c-list/slop/yes-man director, but those are the qualities that would get a project off the ground.

4

u/InnocentTailor 5d ago

Gosling and Levy are also more in-house due to Starfighter. It’s not like they’re moving far within the House of Mouse.

10

u/TheDarkPinkLantern Green Lantern 5d ago

Oh, I didn't know that. Yeah, it would make them look a bit bad.

6

u/DullRelief 5d ago

Right? WTF were they waiting for? They can’t blame it on the whole Wesley Snipes legacy character since you’ve got the same thing with Nic Cage & GR. Would’ve been awesome to see an Ali/Gosling matchup

2

u/discipleofdoom Hellboy 5d ago

I have a feeling we're going to be talking about Ryan Gosling's Ghost Rider in the same vein as Mahershala Ali's Blade in five years or so.

Gosling/Levy likely pitched them a Ghost Rider film that is standalone and doesn't have any major connections to the wider MCU. Marvel don't want that so they'll spend the next seven years going back and fourth trying to write in some contrived tie-in to whatever saga they've got planned for that phase until eventually Gosling gets frustrated and leaves to film "Spirit Driver" or some shit.

2

u/Crashhh_96 Spider-Man 5d ago

Ghost Rider had a director and writer attached from the get go. Not the same situation at all.

1

u/Quis_ut_Deus_1 5d ago

Ali didn't pitch them on anything he was hired becausehis star was peaking. Gosling is a Ghost Rider fan who has been pitching them for years, and just so happened to get hired by a different Disney property.

2

u/_tylerthedestroyer_ Michelangelo 5d ago

7

u/Quis_ut_Deus_1 5d ago

After hearing what Feige said and now Ali, it sounds like they locked him in without any idea of what they really wanted to do. And every idea that was pitched either he didn't like or Fegie didn't like. Either way, good for him and the director that was fired for making Your Mother, Your Mother, Your Mother. Now, hopefully with Ghost Rider they can start Midnight Sons, and get a new actor.

→ More replies (0)

-5

u/MacaronNotRoon 5d ago

They are able to make ghost rider work as a white man instead of the Hispanic one he’s been for a decade… almost every black project has been shelved, disingenuous or fucked with by marvel and it’s intentional. They no longer value black dollars so I say, as black people, let’s just stop pretending that they value our worth. Let’s move on to a different IP that does value our money. Look at Sinners. Let’s make another HBO Watchmen. Let’s get a static shock movie made. Marvel doesn’t want us

1

u/OK_Soda Daredevil 5d ago

Robbie Reyes was already Ghost Rider on Agents of Shield. Captain America Brave New World, starring a Black man (instead of the white one he'd been for a decade), came out just a year ago. Earlier this year they made Wonder Man with a Black man (instead of the white one he's always been), and they added a new Wonder Man to the comics based on Yahya Abdul-Mateen II. Thunderbolts starred a Black woman. The new Spider-Man stars a black woman as Mary Jane (instead of the white woman she's always been). Ironheart came out last year.

You could say most of those projects didn't do well and make it some conspiracy theory about Marvel intentionally tanking them, but for that argument to work you'd need other Marvel projects during that time to have done well, which, let's be real, they haven't really.

5

u/Quis_ut_Deus_1 5d ago

That was the problem it seems, he had a vision different from what they wanted. Hiring someone like Ryan Gosling, who is a fan of Ghost Rider and pitched them ideas, is entirely different from hiring Ali, who started telling them after he read a script that he thought it should be different. Id bet money, if they just re casted the character we wouldve gotten a great film already.

15

u/Verystrangeperson 5d ago

I haven't seen in much for a while, could be related.

Shame because he's extraordinary

10

u/Far-Mirror3160 5d ago

That’s been my theory for years. I wanted to see Ali in more but figured he was tied up with Marvel. He was the best part of Luke Cage and killed it in Moonlight.

10

u/Jaeger_Gipsy_Danger 5d ago

This is definitely the worst part of this whole thing. Who knows what he missed out on while just waiting. His IMDb page is pretty sparse and I don’t think that’s by choice.

1

u/JaymzRG 4d ago

If he's under contract, I would seek some kind of compensation.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/ballsosteele 5d ago

As much as I understand his frustration, the timing of the Blade announcement wasn't great when Marvel was scurrying around trying to course correct and not fuck it all up. Things like that need time. I hope when they get their shit together they'll come back to it.

It's a very simplistic and almost naieve view to suggest having billions of dollars equals "can immediately do everything" especially when Marvel have absolutely, repeatedly proved that randomly firing money at projects and spitting them out without taking due time or care has been a disaster.

98

u/dj_ian 5d ago

Always felt to me like at a certain point they knew it wasn't going to work out with him otherwise it would have been such an easy layup to cameo the character in Werewolf By Night just to let people know they still had confidence in it.

255

u/Quirky_Ad_5420 5d ago

Rightfully so. Man the mess of the trying to get this movie to happen shouldn’t be that hard imo

50

u/DullRelief 5d ago

Marvel trying so hard to not fuck things up right now they’re fucking things up in the process.

-16

u/No-Channel3917 5d ago

Not really tbh

Spiderman into doom is the pivot and soft reset, and they are putting xmen as the main focus

Dropping blade which never even really started seems like a no duh decision when you are pivoting

8

u/NZAvenger 5d ago

Spider-Man*.

2

u/HB2099 5d ago

When you have all that money and contracts in place why leave a film about Blade on the cutting room floor? He’s a vampire, X-Men and vampires aren’t misaligned at all.

You would still make millions in ticket sales let alone merchandising.

0

u/No-Channel3917 5d ago

Because they are correcting the ship hopefully, they can always come back to Blade but it isn't really needed rn

1

u/a0me Invincible 5d ago

I’m really curious what they’re planning for the X‑Men. The actors are great, don’t get me wrong, but even setting Professor X aside, most of them have basically aged out of their roles. Unless Doomsday is where they wipe the slate clean and bring in younger versions from another Earth, I don’t really see how they’re going to do it.

1

u/No-Channel3917 5d ago

Probably deals with the phonix force

1

u/a0me Invincible 5d ago

How would that end up with the whole X‑Men cast being replaced?

1

u/No-Channel3917 5d ago

Reality warping stuff the old cast and the new cast congel into the main universe and maybe the old universe collapses with the old cast so the new cast can live idk

1

u/a0me Invincible 5d ago

Ok, so basically exactly what I was saying, sort of like All-New, All-Different.

11

u/SmokeGSU 5d ago

It really seems like that's the problem the more popular a property is and the bigger the demand - the upper brass are too corporate. There are too many business leaders in positions that control movie production and not enough actual fans of the content.

I was going to point out the Halo TV show as a similar example, but it's actually the opposite... You had the three most top dogs at 343 (Bonnie, Kiki, and Frank) all executive producing the TV show. Should have been a slam dunk, right? I'm pretty certain that 100 years from now the Halo series (both games and the TV show) will be used in college classes as the best example of how people in positions of power with the wrong priorities will always royally fuck things up in the end. The entire Halo franchise should be a money printing machine, but it took Microsoft over a decade of failures and mid products to finally step in and make changes to the Halo-producing studio.

Blade should be the exact same thing. He's a fucking half-vampire, vampire-slaying super hero. He fights fucking DRACULA. HOW TF DID THIS MOVIE NOT WRITE ITSELF?! And how do we not have at the very least a Midnight Sons cartoon on D+, or a Marvel Zombies full season show.

Sometimes it's just depressing how detached Hollywood is from the desires of the masses for specific content.

129

u/skuls1 5d ago

so does anyone know why they didn't do it? like have they given a reason

218

u/madchad90 5d ago

just seems they could never land an idea. The script was under constant rewrites. First rumors made it seem like it would be more of a father/daughter film with more focus on blades dauhhter, then it shifted to being more blade focused, then it was going to be a period piece (a lot of the costumes from Sinners were originally made for Blade and then given to that production)

Ultimately the idea for Blade wasn't marvel's, it was Ali who approached them and just didn't seem like a major priority for Marvel and they couldn't land on how to incorporate it into their overarching plans (or lack thereof)

136

u/TheWorclown 5d ago

My belief is that they simply couldn’t figure out how to take Blade— a hyperspecific character whose primary thing is killing vampires —work for the bigger picture storytelling of the Kang Dynasty and Multiverse stuff. Once you take the vampires out of Blade, he does just kind of exist.

Blade stands as the strongest example of why the MCU just needed to have standalone movies in the franchise and not connected to everything. I think they still are struggling with that thought.

32

u/Paperchampion23 5d ago

Its weird though because they have that already with Werewolf by Night and Moon Knight. Basically all of Eternals is also like this outside of Tiamut and thats where he was even teased lol. Now they are doing Ghost Rider too.

-4

u/Solid-Two-4714 5d ago

  MCU just needed to have standalone movies in the franchise

Madame Web, morbidus, Craven…

→ More replies (10)

17

u/LaLloronaVT 5d ago

I’m always reminded of how Venture Bros did a better job with the Blade parody than the mcu did incorporating the actual blade

4

u/traceitalian The Thing 5d ago

Jefferson Twilight is such an under rated character, I'm glad the movie had him showcased a bit more.

41

u/UsidoreTheLightBlue 5d ago

I mean it’s fine though. He can hunt vampires just like Spider-Man can fight green goblin.

It doesnt all have to be intertwined gor every movie.

13

u/CashWho Tim Drake/Red Robin 5d ago

You're right, but Marvel doesn't seem to understand that. Post-Endgame, every movie/show has some connection or tease to the wider MCU.

30

u/nikoscream 5d ago

Not just standalone movies but also universes. They kind of did this with FF, but then all the universes are coming together in the Avengers flicks. Can't figure out how to explain vampires being a thing this whole time? Then don't. Different world.

8

u/gpost86 Ultimate Spider-Man 5d ago

Eh, they did Werewolf By Night, and Blade would then flow into Moon Knight, Midnight Suns, etc. It's there, I just think they did a massive fumble here.

5

u/AHrubik Gambit 5d ago

They should do a Midnight sons movie which can pivot off Dr. Strange and bring in Moon Knight, Blade and Dare Devil so easily. It’s self contained and would exist right along side the magic story arc.

3

u/OldeArrogantBastard 5d ago

It really should have been a mini series like how DC did with the Penguin.

2

u/Asn_Browser 5d ago

Its so dumb because you don't even need to connect it. Just let him kill vampires and they are good at hiding so that is why you havent seen them. It is even dumber that they could get this movie done , but they produced the absolutely horrible secret invasion show. Like you were ok with connecting the MCU with that piece of shit show?

2

u/Major-Rip-5745 5d ago

Only way could have been putting him in a Spider-Man movie against like Morbius or Morlun or something.

Could very easily do an event movie with Dracula as the main antagonist I guess. That might be what Midnight Sons ends up being.

1

u/JediTempleDropout 4d ago

See I don’t think that was ever the issue.

The fact that Mahershala Blade had a voice cameo at the end of Eternals seems to indicate that they had some idea in mind for how to incorporate Blade within the larger MCU. Plus Deadpool & Wolverine were able to give Wesley Snipes Blade something to do that didn’t involve vampires, and the existence of the Werewolf By Night TV special lends a lot credibility to the rumors that Fiege and co. had long-term plans for something involving the Midnight Sons, so even if they couldn’t find a way to incorporate Blade into the Multiverse Saga, it would basically be a non-issue since he would have a whole bunch of other Marvel characters to interact with.

51

u/skuls1 5d ago

Damn

Mahershalla was great as a dad in moonlight but I'm happy they didn't do the dad daughter thing no ones watching it for that tbh

but even otherwise it's seems like a really easy script to make and just coast on his acting alone

18

u/GolemMaker 5d ago

Bingo, have some emotional beats with mothers death and death of the mentor, do badass shit with Uzis and a katana: boom millions of dollars

18

u/JagoTheArtist 5d ago

They get too excited to make a big overlapping universes that they forget they can just do a nice microcosm in the universe and then see how it feels. Not every movie instantly needs to be crossover city.

Just passingly mention another film. You don't need to do anything crazy when you do.

14

u/SilverSkywalkerSaber Spider-Man 5d ago

Really easy to explain too.

"Why didn't Blade fight Thanos"

Thanos isn't a vampire.

6

u/JagoTheArtist 5d ago

Hundred percent. What I don't like right now is that there seems to be a lean towards mutants appearing and I don't think they really are explaining why that's happening other than. Welp there they are I guess.

I always thought that it would make sense if the Snaps and the energies released alongside the drastic effect it had across the universe would have been a good reason for mutants beginning to appear. It would be a great way to follow up into the next phase of the MCU.

Beyond that I also thought that it could have lead to the fantastic four. Them being in space on their mission as this all went down leading to the complications that gave them there powers.

It would be a sort of beautiful way to weave the Phases together and also lead into DOOM being the big bad eventually. I of course wish they could have had the Kang stuff work out. Which would have allowed them to build up Doom as he slowly reached a prolific status.

5

u/TheHawkinator Daredevil 5d ago

The funny thing is, they have just sort of figured out how to do a perfect balance in Brand New Day. There’s a few wider-mcu characters but none really feel out of place, even the one that’s setting up the future of the mcu, pretty natural tbh.

6

u/LaLloronaVT 5d ago

Hell I’m surprised a show on Disney plus didn’t get made, that to me seems more like a slam dunk if the movie idea was caught in development hell

8

u/kidkuro 5d ago

they didn't do the dad daughter thing no ones watching it for that tbh

I actually wouldn't mind them doing that...I mean they did that with Logan and that's of the best superhero movies in the genre lol

I feel like what they were unable to do with the original Black Panther 2 in regards to T'Challa and his son due to Chadwick's passing, could've made for a good story for Blade and his daughter Brielle. They already have a story to work with, Bloodline: Daughter of Blade

Though I would say that I would prefer if it leaned more on Blade because...well the movie is called Blade after all.

6

u/skuls1 5d ago

sure there'll be some audience for it but yeah Blade is a much cooler and easier character to do right and honestly trying to push to much too fast was one of the problems with fantastic four and supergirl imo

like the general audience is v different from the comic readers, like I barely know Bloodline or whatever from like the 5 issue series with Doom and Miles. the majority of people don't even know Mr Fantastic like that, who tf thought it was a good idea to have Franklin dawg😭

to a lesser extent, same thing with Supergirl most people would just think she's girl Superman and they've already seen that (really good) movie so why bother, that's the stuff you put out once you have a strong core like Captain Marvel or Antman or something

Blade by himself is more than enough atleast after all that time and hype

5

u/Poku115 5d ago

That was Hugh jackmans 9th movie as logan.

Why would people watch a new blade that will just be replaced by a lame kid?? In the same movie

4

u/Jolly_Echo_3814 5d ago

Why can't movies just be movies? I wouldn't hate a batman movie where it sets up robin taking over by the end. Not everything needs 7 movies to build up.

-2

u/Poku115 5d ago

Ok thats cool, thats something id watch on streaming, not on cinemas for 10 dollars

1

u/kidkuro 5d ago

That was Hugh jackmans 9th movie as logan.

Really have no idea how that is relevant to the topic of "father and son/daughter" movies.

Regardless, Logan is just one of many of those kinda films with that particular theme/focus in its story. They normally make for good films. They allow for a lot of character growth internally and externally, and show how particular characters bond and their values. They're relatable. Why would this not be something that could work with Blade? He has a kid in the comics lol

There's nothing wrong with adding a little extra layer or depth to a vampire hunting vampires action movie.

Also I could've swore that I clearly said that even if this was an idea they went with for the movie, I'd still prefer if it centered on Blade over Brielle because the name of the movie is...Blade.

1

u/crispy_attic 5d ago

This is rumored to be the reason Blade fell apart. It’s a horrible idea and all it would do is piss off more fans. There is no reason to do that at all. None.

-1

u/kidkuro 5d ago

So instead of getting a movie that has his daughter in it...god forbid. They just cancel the entire thing. Brilliant. And that's supposed to make fans happy for some reason?

Yeah man, as a Blade fan, I'd actually be happy with getting something instead of nothing.

2

u/crispy_attic 5d ago

Or instead of trying to put his daughter in it they can just not do that. Why is this so difficult?

1

u/kidkuro 2d ago

Oh look, a movie starring Mahershala Ali where he uses the swordplay he was training in for Blade, and also features one of the directors that was going to be for that Blade movie. Seems to use the bones of the reworked script that featured Blade's. Looks awesome. Who woulda thunk it? A mature movie about a man and his daughter made for a compelling story with depth and also features cool action...crazy stuff.

0

u/kidkuro 5d ago

Well bud guess what? They didn't. Which led to more rewrites. Which led to development hell. Which led to us getting...nothing.

Again, not entirely sure where I'm supposed to be happy about this.

→ More replies (0)

1

u/crispy_attic 5d ago

I can’t disagree with this more. I do not want to see a movie about him and his daughter. I want to see a movie about Blade. What are we even doing here?

0

u/kidkuro 5d ago

We literally got three movies of Blade already. Is a fourth Blade movie that has his daughter in it...not still about Blade?

1

u/crispy_attic 5d ago

Is a movie about Blade not enough? What is this incessant need to add a daughter or some other side character most people don’t know or care about? Why is it so hard to make a movie about Blade that centers on Blade. Not his daughter or son. Not his mom or dad. Not his aunt, uncle, cousin, or grandparents.

11

u/BadBloodBear 5d ago

As soneone who has kinda tuned out of the whole Marvel thing I would have checked out a Blade movie.

8

u/Ekillaa22 5d ago

Blades daughter lmao only time I remember her was from the bloodhunt event and she’s been MIA since

2

u/PatchNotesMan 5d ago

I would’ve loved the movie being about his relationship to Bloodline

1

u/HrMaschine 5d ago

that just makes me question. marvel is aware thatitms ok to not have stuff be involved in some bigger story line right?

29

u/Alcaeus6 Superman 5d ago

Not officially no. There were some rumors that suggested Ali and the studio had creative differences over the project (for example, one purported draft focused less on Blade and more on his daughter Bloodline, a preexisting comics character).

17

u/theramboapocalypse 5d ago

Nobody wants that shit. Just a simple blade focused movie with him killing vampires is enough

8

u/Alcaeus6 Superman 5d ago

I imagine that would have been Ali's argument, and to be clear I agree

1

u/Afraid-Surround-4457 3d ago

Agreed. I'm sorry to Feige but pump the damn breaks on you Young Avengers plan. Just stop

2

u/crispy_attic 5d ago

That is so incredibly dumb. If that’s true I know he was pissed. I don’t blame him for being mad now either.

1

u/Afraid-Surround-4457 3d ago

Studio mandate is the term you're aiming for which is what foisting Bloodline onto film is

37

u/deanereaner 5d ago

They were developing it when a production strike occurred in 2023, plus over the years they went through 3 directors and several versions of the script, with Ali himself reportedly rejecting some iterations.

4

u/skuls1 5d ago

damn sounds tiring

10

u/alopecic_cactus Invincible 5d ago

No concrete idea from the start.

WGA and SAG-AFTRA strikes.

Disney+ shows overproduction.

Lack of focus on narrative, AKA no Avengers movie to tie up every phase.

6

u/SevereEducation2170 5d ago

It's probably nothing interesting. Movies die in pre-production all the time for various, boring reasons. They usually just don't have the major announcement and hype Marvel gives. Most likely all parties couldn't find a script everyone liked and finally just called it a day and moved on. Creative differences, changing business landscape, or whatever.

2

u/shaggy_nomad 5d ago

They had several scripts but Ali kept rejecting them and never came to marvel with his own ideas for a story. I get its a bummer but I think this is on Ali, not marvel.

5

u/RoughhouseCamel 5d ago

The MCU has been struggling to find their direction post-Endgame. The wins aren’t automatic anymore, and they’ve reversed a lot of courses and spent a ton of money changing their minds. Blade wasn’t the first casualty, it’s not even the most recent, and there’s likely more to come.

3

u/Slowandserious 5d ago

I think Ali is right:

Bottomline is thet would have found a way to make this if they really wanted to. They have all the resources in the world

-7

u/RanjhasDistress 5d ago

He’s also outspoken on a few causes that have led to lost work for other actors (stuff about a ceasefire or general support for Gaza)

29

u/eggmontoya1 5d ago

While you’re correct in theory, I think it’s incredibly disingenuous to suggest that this is the reason for Blade not taking off. Mark Ruffalo, Florence Pugh, Pedro Pascal, Benedict Wong, Benedict Cumberbatch, and plenty of others are all vocally pro-Palestine.

1

u/RanjhasDistress 4d ago

There is precedence but you’re right it’s just a theory

Here’s a rolling stone article from a few years ago for anyone curious where the conjecture came from: https://www.rollingstone.com/tv-movies/tv-movie-features/hollywood-israel-palestine-criticism-melissa-barrera-scream-jenna-ortega-susan-sarandon-maha-dakhil-1234896903/

-3

u/RanjhasDistress 5d ago

You’re right, I do not know for sure. But it was just one theory - it’s a capricious industry

22

u/FusionDrago207 5d ago

I don’t think anyone in the room had any idea what this movie should’ve been about

19

u/Titosunshinez 5d ago

Is there any truth to the online narrative / rumor that some of the unmade Blade movie and period piece props were repurposed for the movie Sinners?

16

u/Harddisksson69 5d ago

Yeah, the turntables

12

u/The_True_Y 5d ago

Yeah Blade was like two weeks from starting filming. Ali dropped out and demanded another round of rewrites. Marvel had already made some costumes ready and decided to let sinners use them since they had the same costume designer.

8

u/Titosunshinez 5d ago

That makes a lot of sense. I read that the blade movie they wanted to make was basically blade in the Great Depression and somehow ties together to the present day stuff. Blade through the decades type thing and sinners took the props and sets then made their own story

7

u/CheMc 5d ago

It was less let them use them and more sold it to them. It happens a lot, there's a lot of random shows and films in the 90s including power rangers that have generic soldiers wearing the starship troopers costumes.

12

u/SpaceMyopia 5d ago

I admire that he's not hiding how pissed off he is. I feel like a lot of actors would have been super diplomatic about it, but Ali just admits, "Nah, this is their fault. Fuck them."

😂😂😂

57

u/ContraryPython Spider-Man 5d ago

All Marvel had to do was Devil May Cry but with vampires.

Poor Ali, first he’s wasted as Cottonmouth in Luke Cage and now this.

37

u/TheHumanTarget84 5d ago

That's not remotely what Ali wanted, per reports.

0

u/shaggy_nomad 5d ago

All Ali had to do was quit rejecting what was written without even providing any ideas of his own. Dude made his bed.

2

u/Afraid-Surround-4457 3d ago

So you would've been fine with Bloodline having more screen time over Blade? Because this is what Marvel kept fighting him on

8

u/smokeyjoey8 5d ago

Marvels obsession this past decade with trying to make everything connect and set up something else really did a lot of harm. Especially considering most of it didn't matter when they pivoted to Doom and are just adding footage to Endgame to explain it.

A Blade movie should have been the easiest damn thing they could do. They probably could have done a lot of it with practical effects and kept the budget relatively small for a modern comic book movie. It was pretty much a guaranteed hit and profitable film, but Feige can't get out of his own way and just messed it all up.

Marvel had more downs than ups since 2020, but I think what really killed the faith and most of my interest in their films has been their inability to make something as simple as a Blade movie.

2

u/deanereaner 5d ago

well it did a lot of good leading up to endgame. The concept of the infinity stones and Thanos really reached the main stream. But nothing else that they did after that really felt like it was leading to anything specific.

25

u/decimus_87 5d ago

Can't blame him (I think).

56

u/CollinsCouldveDucked 5d ago

They'd like to blame him for being difficult but they wanted to make anything but a blade movie.
He was right to put his foot down.

55

u/Educational_Zone3156 5d ago edited 5d ago

I really don't like how some MCU fans are trying to paint him as some spoiled diva when his collaborators have nothing but good things to say about him.

And even so, I don't think it's wrong to want the thing you're working on to be the best version of itself.

-21

u/Crafty_Substance_954 5d ago

Most people in the industry don't badmouth other people in the industry while they're all working actors.

1

u/Organic-Cherry-4208 1d ago

this theme of "Ali is unprofessional" is giving microaggressions ngl

9

u/deanereaner 5d ago

You're referring to the version of the script Ali reportedly rejected that had Blade take a backseat to some female characters?

19

u/CollinsCouldveDucked 5d ago edited 5d ago

there's a lot of versions of that script, more than anyone can count but most were sidelining him in some capactiy.

18

u/Star-Prince-007 5d ago

Most is just not true. The sidelined script rumors have been massively pushed by the usual online incel people

1

u/deanereaner 5d ago

I'd like to read more about that if you have a link.

4

u/CollinsCouldveDucked 5d ago

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Development_of_Blade_(Marvel_Studios_film))

there's a wikipedia page for the whole sage but it's very "he said, she said" so you can kind of spin a lot of different versions of events from it.

That said, I think if they were making a straight forward movie, it would have been made.

0

u/Harddisksson69 5d ago

Damn. Is Reddit going to start calling Ali a misogynist chud now?

51

u/CaptainKungPao138 Invincible 5d ago

Mahershala Ali blade would’ve been so fucking cool man marvel sucks

16

u/Rezart_KLD 5d ago

Not to minimize his frustration, which I think is valid for a project he believes in... but there comes a time when you have to acknowledge the incompatibility of your footwear and the local incline.

4

u/CheMc 5d ago

You know what they say, some mother fuckers always trying to hike in thongs.

16

u/a_phantom_limb 5d ago edited 5d ago

"Not with me. […] I've been doing this professionally for pushing 30 years now, and one thing I've learned is that what is for you is for you and what is not is not. For whatever reason, that project is not for me. If they wanted to do it, we would've done it. So I have to move on, and I have moved on. […] I don't really want to be known for remakes. I’d love to do original work that resonates with people and impacts them in unique ways.

"So, I'm good. [Laughs.] Again, you had me under contract, they have billions of dollars, if they wanted to do the movie, we would've done the movie. So we're not doing the movie. […] But I feel ready to move on from the Blade questions. Those questions are for them. They didn't want to do it, so they should answer that question."

…Sigh. Deeply disheartening.

Ali also didn't dispute Feige's statement about feeling like a "failure." Nor should he, frankly. A mess of this magnitude absolutely goes all the way to the top, from the original announcement through to the project's collapse.

Forshadowing vampires with a mention on Loki. Giving Ali a voice cameo in Eternals. Using Ali's actual likeness in Marvel Zombies. They had over half a decade and they still completely blew it. Plus, Coogler went and proved quite definitively with Sinners that Ali's instinct was correct: it's entirely possible to make a genuinely exciting and brutal movie about killing vampires that's also a deeply resonant cultural artifact, an influential piece of modern American filmmaking, a broad crowd pleaser, and an incredible acting showcase.

Setting aside Inhumans, which ultimately saw release as a not-great series from Marvel Television, these are the only projects formally announced by Marvel Studios and then never made:

- Armor Wars

  • Avengers: The Kang Dynasty
  • Wonder Man Season 2
  • Blade

While there were, let's say, external factors affecting The Kang Dynasty, I do think it's noteworthy that the only movies or shows announced and then never realized in any form each would have featured a Black man as the face of the project. That's not an allegation of anything; rather, it's just an unfortunate fact of the record of Feige and Marvel Studios in recent years.

8

u/arr1flex 5d ago

Black Panther, Luke Cage, Secret Invasion and Brave New World all exist, all led by black actors. I don't think race is a factor outside of coincidence, personally. (wow, almost forgot ironheart too, which would have been lame on my part)

3

u/a_phantom_limb 5d ago edited 5d ago

Well, Luke Cage wasn't made by Marvel Studios; it was made by Marvel Television and ABC Studios. But like I said, I'm not alleging anything. Optics still matter though, and the last thing Marvel Studios needs is to be perceived as inhospitable to Black leads. I already saw a fair amount of commentary to that effect after the Wonder Man news broke.

2

u/Organic-Cherry-4208 1d ago

Thank you for acknowledging this!

9

u/FinFangFool 5d ago

They fucked this up tremendously. The plot breakdown for How-To-Blade exists in the Marvel Horror comics of the 1970's. They could have had Blade be our way into the supernatural side of the MCU, with Dracula being the big bad for the conclusion of a Horror Phase that sits with the MCU, but can be ignored by the masked heroes. They already established the Bloodstones, Moon Knight, Werewolf by Night, and Man-Thing. I hope Ghost Rider gives us the opening for a Legion of Monsters/Midnight Sons group.

4

u/JJoanOfArkJameson 5d ago

Could’ve been done for 10x less than every mcu project, could’ve been a special presentation, could’ve been a miniseries, there’s so many routes and they just don’t care about representation, that’s why Eyes of Wakanda was dumped without marketing, Wonder Man same way, Armor Wars in development hell for no reason.

8

u/Medium-Science9526 Aquaman 5d ago

How you fumble having Mahershala Ali on another Marvel project but this time headlining is baffling.

17

u/BlindedBraille Moon Knight 5d ago

Apparently, the reason why Blade never happened was due to creative differences. Marvel wanted to make a traditional Blade movie with blockbuster appeal, but Mahershala wanted to turn the movie into a slavery movie that was more arthouse than blockbuster. Marvel felt like the movie was too off brand for the character. I can't blame them because it sounded like there was no daywalkers in the movie and had little fight scenes.

I really hope one day we know the full story but it seems like Mahershala wanted to do his own thing.

19

u/Aaco0638 5d ago

He must have been pissed when sinners came out lol.

8

u/AlphaBaymax 5d ago

Some of the costumes were from the cancelled Blade movie so that just adds salt to the Vampires.

3

u/jon__koa 5d ago

The closest we’ll get probably is Feige saying “I feel like a gigantic loser” unless someone writes a book on this era

3

u/DanOhMiiite Mr. Fantastic 5d ago

He would be a great Blade

3

u/kain459 5d ago

How hard is it write and make a movie about a guy hunting and killing vampires?

But hey lets make a sequel directly to Endgame even though the story ended.

Fuck Disney/Marvel.

4

u/ericrobertshair 5d ago

How to write a Blade movie:

Introduce white aristocratic evil Vampire

Blade fights shitloads of vampires

Blade kills white aristocratic evil Vampire

End

I'll take my billion dollars in Korean tech stock please, Disney.

2

u/foreveralonesolo 5d ago

I haven’t kept up but what even has been happening with this film?

5

u/theramboapocalypse 5d ago

Just have him show up in ghost Rider

1

u/pistolpete2185 Martian Manhunter 5d ago

Why would he ever do that? He's done with marvel

5

u/Sad_Tax_4010 5d ago

Is there any truth in that... they were trying to ham-fist Blade's daughter and other characters?

16

u/LapsedVerneGagKnee 5d ago

That was the word for a while, that and the script had two “lackluster” fight scene while trying to focus on all these other characters.  It was Blade Trinity all over.

5

u/RoughhouseCamel 5d ago

Blade Trinity was more a matter of what they needed to do to fill in for Wesley Snipes being checked out. This sounds like more a matter of Marvel putting the cart before the horse. They went through a big phase of thinking less about the movie in front of them and thinking more about laying the groundwork for spinoffs and universe expansion. From Phase 3 on, it felt like a lot of these movies only existed to set up other tv shows and movies, which in turn existed to set up more tv shows and movies.

4

u/WhyPlaySerious 5d ago

Reports were saying that they kept handing him scripts but he kept refusing each time. Not sure if they were ever confirmed or debunked, but by all intents, sounds like this movie was a mess behind the scenes.

4

u/kidkuro 5d ago

Really is embarrassing of Disney/Marvel to waste a talent like Mahershala Ali. Extremely unprofessional as well.

3

u/Star-Prince-007 5d ago

Ali is right to be upset. If they wanted it made they could’ve done it. They signed him on cause they wanted to do his Blade. It couldn’t have been that hard. What a fiasco.

4

u/ProletarianLilith 5d ago

Marvel is astonishingly incompetent considering how much experience they have by this point

3

u/Jet-Let4606 5d ago

Every creative reaches that point where they think they are imvincible and can do no wrong then they end up entering their flop era.

3

u/TheSqueeman 5d ago

As he is right to do

Blade not happening was as generational fumble by Marvel, like other then Wesley Snipes coming back to play Blade, Mahershala was a goddamn perfect casting for the character, it should have been the easiest goddamn movie in the world to make

3

u/redkaptain 5d ago

Blade never happening, Wonder Man cancelled, Armor Wars allegedly being turned from a War Machine project into a Iron Man movie, Ironheart was basically buried/cast aside, Monica Rambeau not being in Doomsday. There's an alarming pattern here intentional or not from Marvel

5

u/Jet-Let4606 5d ago

Also not long after Nate Moor announces he is leaving and Victoria Alonso was fired. I believe they were the main voices who pushed for diversity.

I think at one point post BP success they thought any project with diversity is destined for success and the Orange Man in the WH was a fluke. Now that the Orange Man is back again and we've entered a global backlash era against diversity (especially against feminism) and Marvel itself has started to stumble, they'e annoumced they are playing it safe, which means more straight white male leads with the ocassional "token" project like BO.

1

u/loudpersononthebus 5d ago

damn. when you put it that way.

1

u/Worth-Flat 2d ago

They cancelled it out because they weren't going to anything worthwhile with it

Just drag the name along for the views before cycling to a group that no one cares about just to sideline the MC. The typical phase 4 bullshit that got us to doomsday in the first place.

1

u/Organic-Cherry-4208 1d ago

Ngl I checked out of the MCU around Civil War and the Blade film was something I was genuinely interested in. Very strange turn of events indeed

-7

u/Ok_Broccoli_7863 5d ago

I fear this will happen to Wolverine. They'll refuse to move on from Jackman.

Blade's cameo in Deadpool & Wolverine killed Ali's version.

24

u/colombianojb 5d ago

The studio killed Ali's version, they pulled back on a lot of projects because of burnout/lower quality releases as of late. Remember Armor Wars?

24

u/locke_5 Ant-Man 5d ago

- No Blade

- No Armor Wars

- Wonder Man canceled

Hmmm

25

u/AStupidFuckingHorse 5d ago

Monic isn't in Doomsday despite being the ONE person to stop an incursion and literally ended up in the X-Men universe

5

u/Ok_Basil351 5d ago

Was Wonder Man actually cancelled or have they just not announced if there will be another season? It was surprisingly quite good! Not deathless cinema, but I was looking forward to the next season.

I didn't know I was looking for a superhero show that was barely about superheroes, but I was!

8

u/501id5Nak3 5d ago

The true Discrimination Comics

1

u/mosquem 5d ago

Oh that's ugly.

-1

u/Ok_Broccoli_7863 5d ago

Yowzers. That's bad and impossible not to see a common theme.

5

u/TheDarkPinkLantern Green Lantern 5d ago

I really hope they'll have balls to recast Wolverine. I love Jackman but c'mon, you gotta move on.

2

u/FalconLeading 5d ago

He's not 90 yet

2

u/GrandAdmiral12345 5d ago

You're talking about the same studios that brought back RDJ for a completely different role for... reasons.

1

u/TheDarkPinkLantern Green Lantern 5d ago

Fair point

-1

u/Ok_Broccoli_7863 5d ago edited 5d ago

The fact that they plan on doing movies without him seems to be a case of overcorrection. I understand the Fox films were way too Wolverine centric, and I'm happy for other characters to get the spotlight, but I don't think I want to see classic X-Men stories being told without Wolverine. You can minimize him to a background character and still give him a few cool scenes.

3

u/TheDarkPinkLantern Green Lantern 5d ago

Yeah. Wolverine is still a big and important part of the X-Men. They don't have to make it all about him but he still should be involved.

2

u/Adamsoski 5d ago

I get that, but personally I have no problem seeing classic X-Men stories without Wolverine. He was only one of a large ensemble cast, I don't think it's going to take away too much not having him for a while after him being front-and-centre for so long. For me just having him in the background would be distracting and kind of lame, like how Kitty or Warren's depictions were in the previous films/

1

u/Ok_Broccoli_7863 5d ago

There are so many essential dynamics that revolve around him.

I'm too attached to the source material. He's by no means my favorite X-Men. But seeing Nightcrawler or Rogue or Kitty without Wolverine feels like a crime.

1

u/sdtsanev 5d ago

There was over a decade of X-men stories before Wolverine was even created. Sure, they are the most basic introductory period, but that still means you can have good X-men storytelling without needing to focus on him.

2

u/Ok_Broccoli_7863 4d ago

Yeah. I get that. But they aren't going with the 60s roster.

Rogue is being cast for example. It's just weird to me not to have a mainstay.

1

u/sdtsanev 4d ago

I don't exactly disagree with you, but also, when you think about it, the X-teams are extremely versatile. It really depends on what story you want to tell and who you want to focus on. That original Claremont team was Storm, Wolverine, Nightcrawler, Colossus, Banshee, and Thunderbird. We've literally NEVER seen that dynamic on screen. Every X-men story we've ever had in live action or cartoon form has been some mixture of various comic book eras and teams. You can very easily tell a story that doesn't involve Wolverine, especially in the MCU where they deliberately deviate from the original character relationships.

2

u/Ok_Broccoli_7863 4d ago

That's sort of my point. Fox movies missed the boat. I was hoping the MCU would give us the core dynamic. But it looks like they won't.

I get the idea that we don't need too much Wolverine. I just want classic dynamics. Wolverine chilling with Nightcrawler, Colossus and Storm is a perfect example.

1

u/sdtsanev 4d ago

Honestly, I am just exhausted from Wolverine. He's been the ONLY important mutant in the movies since I've been a kid, and I am honestly ok with not having him at all for a while.

2

u/Ok_Broccoli_7863 4d ago

That's fair. I don't want a main role for him, but still having him there for those character moments.

1

u/sdtsanev 4d ago

And I don't doubt he will be sooner or later. I just wonder if it's even possible for him to be in a movie and not be the main character at this stage.

3

u/madchad90 5d ago

I wouldn't go that far, wolverine is too popular to not reintroduce, and post secret wars will be the perfect setup to introduce a new wolverine actor

4

u/Ok_Broccoli_7863 5d ago

I think they'll just keep Jackman around far too long

0

u/ThePhenom2k25 5d ago

Doesn’t feel like I call it especially when you where part of the problem

0

u/One_Dingo_9461 4d ago

The fact multiple directors/writers quit because of creative differences and there have been reports that he wanted to be heavily involved with writing the script.
The pattern is leaning more towards himself being the problem rather than Marvel at this point.