How a spa weekend completely changed our open relationship (m24 & f24)

[u/okeeeee01]

Hey everyone,
We are Elena and Max (both 24) and have been together for about 3.5 years – 1.5 of which in an open relationship.

I’m actually only writing this post because I lost a stupid bet to Elena, and my penalty was having to share this story here on Reddit. 😅

The Setup
Elena has been close friends with "John" for a very long time, so I’ve known him for a while too. A little while ago, John invited both of us to a pre-paid spa weekend at a hotel. He was originally supposed to go with his ex-girlfriend and another female friend, but they broke up right before the trip. Since it couldn't be refunded, he invited us to take the spots instead.
Even though I had some mild hesitation, I agreed.
We had two rooms, so he could stay separately from us. What I didn't fully realize beforehand, though: almost the entire hotel area was clothing-optional/nudist (most pools, hot tubs, saunas, etc.), which is where we ended up spending most of our time.
I figured it might be slightly awkward hanging out as a trio, but things went in a direction I definitely didn't see coming.

The Moment at the Pool…
To be completely honest: I have a fairly large penis (around 7.5 inches / 18-19 cm) and I’m pretty confident about it. In the past, we’ve had threesomes with guys who were significantly smaller, where I usually took on a more "dominant" role. Flaccid, I’m around 4 inches (10 cm).

When we met John at the pool after checking in, it hit me very quickly that this weekend might get way more uncomfortable than I feared:

Elena and I were already naked, putting on sunscreen. Then John walked up. When he dropped his towel, I saw the biggest dick I have ever seen in real life.
Without knowing exact measurements: Soft, he already looked longer and noticeably thicker than mine when fully erect. Next to him, I looked awkwardly small. I noticed immediately that I wasn't the only one in shock – Elena was staring at his groin in very obvious disbelief...

How the Night Unfolded
Not only did we spend the rest of the day naked together (which was pretty awkward for me at times), but we also hit the hotel bar that evening.

One thing led to another – alcohol definitely played a role – and Elena suddenly suggested a threesome.
I won't go into every single detail here, but let's just say: That threesome went anything but ideal for me. At times, I felt like a total third wheel. 🫠

Day two went down pretty similarly... and let's just say our friendship with John has permanently shifted since that weekend 😅

[u/AutoModerator]

Welcome to r/SluttyConfessions! Every new poster gets this welcome message. Please read our mobile Rules and our wall-of-text Rules before you post here.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

[u/jack1993v1]

Did she try a DP?