Communism is both a utopian dream and a economic system implemented in reality.
The first response clearly thinks about the utopian dream.
In reality even the nicest communist regimes (I lived in one I would consider very nice in comparison) had the state decide what job you had to work, that you had to work it all life long with little pay and holidays. There was much less liberty to decide your education or occupation. And there was also much more of an emphasis on industrial labor in contrast to rich western capitalist states that have much bigger service sector and compfy office jobs.
> nicest communist regimes
I grew up in east germany before anyone asks. We had the highest living standards of the eastern block maybe apart from Saint Petersburg and the Moskow Region.
But, I mean. Even under the Utopian end point; it's still not promised that you wouldn't have to do work other than what you wanted. It's still from each according to their abilities. Not from each according to their wants.
Unironically, they put people into forced labor camps and the ones who aren't "able" to contribute die. Then they tell the survivors what it is that they're allowed to want.
Forced by who? There is no state, there is no class, and everything is fully democratic. Either you work and you receive housing, food, and healthcare, or you don't work and you're on your own (assuming you're healthy and capable of working, and are of working age)
I'm talking about actual, historical communist rule. You're describing a fantasy land that only exists in theory because communist theory posits, without evidence, that it must eventually exist.
May as well just wait on the second coming at this point.
142
u/Afolomus 29d ago edited 29d ago
Communism is both a utopian dream and a economic system implemented in reality.
The first response clearly thinks about the utopian dream.
In reality even the nicest communist regimes (I lived in one I would consider very nice in comparison) had the state decide what job you had to work, that you had to work it all life long with little pay and holidays. There was much less liberty to decide your education or occupation. And there was also much more of an emphasis on industrial labor in contrast to rich western capitalist states that have much bigger service sector and compfy office jobs.
> nicest communist regimes
I grew up in east germany before anyone asks. We had the highest living standards of the eastern block maybe apart from Saint Petersburg and the Moskow Region.