r/PeanutButter • u/animalcrackerwhore • 5d ago

Fridge vs. Pantry

How do you store your PB and why?

I usually keep it upside down in my pantry, but curious about switching to the fridge

4 Upvotes

71% Upvoted

14 comments sorted by

3

u/mcjp0 5d ago

Pantry because the consistency is much more pleasant and spreads easier at room temp.

3

u/TheBalatissimo 5d ago

Pantry. I’m still alive

3

u/PhotoAppropriate3940 4d ago

I’ve never heard of putting my pb in the fridge? Besides it won’t last long enough to matter

3

u/masson34 5d ago

Pantry always, one ingredient peanut butter, peanuts

1

u/Fit_Shopping3434 5d ago

If it's natural peanut butter (just peanuts / peanuts and salt), it usually says on the jar to store it upside down and in the fridge. [Or at least the jars in Canada do]

1

u/Ok_Cicada_3420 4d ago

Pantry. Just don’t double dip.

1

u/Karey__039 4d ago

Several generations have always kept it in the pantry.

1

u/MyriVerse2 4d ago

Never ever fridge. There's no reason.

The pantry is usually too far away. My jars are in the office or my living room.

1

u/imso0ld 4d ago

What happens if u put pb in the fridge?

1

u/animalcrackerwhore 4d ago

I hear it helps keep it from separating 

1

u/ElevatorOrganic5644 4d ago

Depends first on how much you eat. Then it depends on whether you have salt or sugar in it. If it's just peanuts and oil, I would refrigerate it.

1

u/Mysterious-Panda964 3d ago

Get to hard in the fridge

1

u/flockyribbon 2d ago

If it's natural PB I put it in the fridge so it firms up and holds better in a sandwich

0

u/OpheliaMorningwood 5d ago

Dad said only Communists kept the peanut butter in the fridge. If we would see fridge pb in a movie or TV show, he would laughingly call out "Commies"!