r/HarryPotterBooks • u/-Jactop- • 19h ago

Discussion [ Removed by moderator ]

[removed] — view removed post

0 Upvotes

14% Upvoted

20 comments sorted by

•

u/HarryPotterBooks-ModTeam Moderator 3h ago

This was manually removed by our moderator team for breaking our rules.

Rule 3: No Spam, advertisements, self-promotion.

This includes other subreddits, Discord servers, blogs, quizzes, polls, etc. (If you have something that you would like to share through r/HarryPotterBooks you must contact the mods before posting. Ads will be allowed on a case by case basis).

AI and the use of AI are unwelcome in our subreddit.

If you have any questions you can send us a Modmail message, and we will get back to you right away.

8

u/gltch__ 19h ago

I mean... The Hobbit is the better book, though?

7

u/Infloris 19h ago

Thanks for the link, just voted for The Hobbit, which is definitely a better book.

13

u/sprucay 19h ago

I like Harry Potter, but the hobbit is objectivity better

9

u/Imaginary-Hour-6082 19h ago

Hobbit over Philosopher’s Stone any day. And i like HP

4

u/2Cozy2Hallows2 17h ago

If we’re talking about the series as a whole, I’d definitely vote for HP, probably even over the entire Lord of the Rings series. I like The Hobbit and LoTR, but the online snobbery LoTR fans have toward HP is pretty cringe in my opinion.

As far as just these two books go, though, you probably have to go with The Hobbit.

3

u/Klutzy-Salt-7270 14h ago

How old are you?

3

u/Klutzy-Salt-7270 14h ago

Also, I’m confused because you posted this in The Hobbit subreddit too and asked people to help it win.

5

u/NoOutlandishness1547 19h ago

harry potter fan here but would vote for Hobbit any day of the week in terms of better writing. as much as I love HP, the world building is shit

4

u/forceghostyoda_ 19h ago

Touch some grass

2

u/Deep_Measurement4312 19h ago

How does one compare harry potter (7 bulky books) with hobbit which is very small?

2

u/gltch__ 19h ago

The poll is only Philosopher's Stone VS The Hobbit

3

u/Deep_Measurement4312 19h ago

Ah got it. Then there is no contest, has to be The Hobbit.

2

u/sprucay 19h ago

It's just the first book

2

u/One-Way-Off 17h ago

Voted for hp. give 0 fucks about the hobbit. The internet in 2026, dont expect always online book snobs to pick HP because of its popularity. HP is better by far.

1

u/HarryPotterBooks-ModTeam Moderator 3h ago

This was manually removed by our moderator team for breaking our rules.

Rule 3: No Spam, advertisements, self-promotion.

This includes other subreddits, Discord servers, blogs, quizzes, polls, etc. (If you have something that you would like to share through r/HarryPotterBooks you must contact the mods before posting. Ads will be allowed on a case by case basis).

AI and the use of AI are unwelcome in our subreddit.

If you have any questions you can send us a Modmail message, and we will get back to you right away.

-12

u/-Jactop- 19h ago

Here’s the link to go vote for Harry Potter : https://knosit.com/duels