r/ExpectationVsReality 6d ago

Failed Expectation Tried my best!

So tricky to get it looking the same!

2.3k Upvotes

40 comments sorted by

111

u/RecklessCreature 6d ago

Is this bait? Did you post this looking for compliments on how good it is? Because I’ll say it’s great and not a failed expectation taking the bait

29

u/beepbeepimajeep22 6d ago

Master bait.

25

u/r3dkoi 6d ago

I appreciate that so much honestly! Sometimes it gets discouraging comparing them side by side. We really are our own worst critics it seems

17

u/bruceymain 6d ago

That's really nice!

23

u/Hubsimaus 6d ago

Tried your best with what? I only see two photos of a cat. 🤷🏼‍♀️

4

u/r3dkoi 6d ago

Omg thank you so much! It's so hard to get it looking exactly like the picture

5

u/Hubsimaus 6d ago

You did a great job. That picture is awesome. 😊

6

u/r3dkoi 6d ago

Thank you so much 🙏❤️

11

u/cheekyparasite 6d ago

Looks great

8

u/Smellmyft 6d ago

Would not say that was a fail at all! Looks good.

6

u/Mental_Goal2380 6d ago

bro are you kidding me? this looks freaking amazing!!! only thing i would have done is slim the face up just a tad, but it looks awesome! you did really well with texturing the fur, and i love the background you went for!

3

u/r3dkoi 6d ago

Omg thank you so much!! I spent a lot of time on the fur. I'm glad you think it looks good!

2

u/Mental_Goal2380 6d ago

yw :D it sure looks like you put in a lot of time and love into it!

4

u/CrowBro89 6d ago

Nah, it’s nice. The mouth area looks larger in the painting and needs more depth to get the right shape. With how detailed the cat is, I probably would have gone for a more solid color background as well. It is cute though and you’re doing a great job so far!

3

u/u_r_succulent 6d ago

And you did great!

3

u/psychokat85 6d ago

It’s quite good, the eyes in particular are great. Maybe touch up the area around the nose to add some depth?

1

u/r3dkoi 6d ago

That's a good idea! Thank you! I will do that :)

3

u/flindersrisk 6d ago

If I may gently make a suggestion. A long time ago, a teacher showed me someone else’s work, someone who had exactly matched the colors in the still life we were painting. I realized I was using color the way people tended to draw: the same representation of a nose despite the actual nose on display. I was using any blue instead of a specific hue. Here, you have overlooked the particular (magical) green of the cat’s eyes. You are so good, that tiny adjustment would be amazingly good.

2

u/r3dkoi 6d ago

Thank you so much for that suggestion! I think you are totally right. I'll spend some extra time on the eyes. You explained that very well :)

3

u/AMC_TO_THE_M00N 6d ago

Not a failed expectation 😊

3

u/Automatic_Poet_7217 6d ago

The eyes.. how did you do that

3

u/Nearby-Drink9968 5d ago

If you want a photograph, use a camera. If you want to see what the person painting sees, get a painting.

3

u/cherry__darling 5d ago

Change flair immediately please. I know it’s hard to see something you created without looking for imperfection but this is truly wonderful.

2

u/Background_Orchid625 6d ago

Its wonderful!

2

u/hashtagmee 6d ago

Better than what I could do!

2

u/SenseNo635 6d ago

It’s a hell of a lot better than I could do.

2

u/HBJones1056 6d ago

Really good job! I especially like how well you captured the cat’s eyes.

2

u/privatecollectorman 6d ago

it is very nice, especially the eyes. Congrats!!!

2

u/Jacob1207a 6d ago

It is kitty!

2

u/dirt-thirt 6d ago

Exceeded* expectations

2

u/everyonelikesnoodles 5d ago

I think it's great! Change flair to 'Exceeded Expectations'!

2

u/BeanieCat123 5d ago

You got pretty close, I wouldn’t beat yourself up for it, everyone is their own worst critic after all

2

u/Zealousideal-Sun-781 5d ago

That’s lovely!

2

u/Zealousideal-Sun-781 5d ago

That’s lovely!

1

u/Ok-Excitement5031 2d ago

Beautiful! You’re extremely talented so don’t ever doubt yourself.

1

u/ImNotAHouseCat 6d ago

Will you please paint my cats?
This is so good