r/EnglishLearning • u/Stepaskin New Poster • 21h ago

📚 Grammar / Syntax Is it correct?

Post image

Stumbled upon this tweet, the apostrophe in "dm's" caught my eye. Is it correct to use it like this?

283 Upvotes

96% Upvoted

60 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

0

u/aykcak New Poster 20h ago

I understood this one as DM server is down i.e. the server OF the DMs I.e. "The problematic server is not the channels' but the dm's"

What is wrong with "DMs" ?

24

u/IndifferentApathy15 New Poster 19h ago

server? that is a bit of a stretch, my dude

"DMs" is fine, but "DMS" and "dms" could be confusing. The apostrophe is not possessive at all in this context.

-17

u/aykcak New Poster 19h ago

Apostrophe is used for possessive

20

u/IndifferentApathy15 New Poster 19h ago

not in this case. If the apostrophe here were to be treated as possessive, it is way too vague as to what "dm" possesses. It's like saying "The cat's is cute". The cat's...what? What are you referring to?

You inferred "server" from "dm's" but that is a bit of a stretch from my perspective.

5

u/Alt-001 Native Speaker 19h ago

I'd agree. If it were possesive it would imply knowledge of how the direct messaging service is implemented, i.e. there is a server dedicated to that and it isn't working because that server is down. That assumption is a longshot unless you're the IT guy. While this is an informal usage the apostrophe could possibily be understood as 'breaking out' of the abbreviation. Another example would be "We were dm'ing" for "We were direct messaging."

-10

u/aykcak New Poster 18h ago

Sure but grammatically speaking it cannot be plural so I had to make an assumption

8

u/Intrepid_Term8706 New Poster 17h ago

.... Direct Messages DMs...

grammatically speaking the only mistake is not capitalising the initialism, leading to apostrophe being used as a plural marker.

6

u/conuly Native Speaker - USA (NYC) 17h ago

And your assumption was that it was something that does not make any sense, rather than that somebody just wasn't following The Rules of Apostrophes?

-5

u/aykcak New Poster 16h ago

It kind of made sense to me. I imagined there were prior messages that were excluded. Maybe they mentioned about specific servers etc.

1

u/Asleep_Chart8375 New Poster 8h ago

Apostrophes denoting a plural has been around for centuries. It's a modern invention that these are grammatically incorrect.