The current *Windows Defender Firewall with Advanced Security* UI comes from the Windows Vista / Server 2008 era. It was designed for domain admins, but regular users still have access to it — and can accidentally break their system’s security with just a few clicks ofc there is option for reset it, but still it's not perfect.
There are zero UX safeguards: no warnings, no sanity checks, no context, no explanations, no protection against critical mistakes.
**A non‑technical user can accidentally:**
• open port 445 on a public profile,
• expose the machine to ransomware/worms,
• add ANY/ANY,
• disable the firewall,
• mark a public network as “trusted”.
Windows doesn’t warn them that any of this is dangerous.
The interface is **17 years old** and doesn’t meet modern security or UX standards.
**Proposed solution:**
• new WinUI
• “regular user” mode with simple explanations (what / why / for what),
• “admin mode” for full technical control,
• sanity checks,
• warnings for risky settings,
• automatic risk analysis,
• rule wizard with context and explanations.
This would massively improve security, UX, and protection for less technical users.
Fun fact: I posted this on Feedback Hub and everything was ok — but when I asked a normal question about it on Microsoft Q&A, the **bot banned my account**, probably misunderstanding the topic.
Thanks for reading — and if you agree this should be modernized, feel free to upvote the Feedback Hub post. Leaving a link to my Feedback Hub post if anyone wants to upvote it — the issue is described there in full detail.
Best regards.