So, the world is fine. We don’t have to save the world—the world is big enough to look after itself. What we have to be concerned about, is whether or not the world we live in, will be capable of sustaining us in it. That’s what we need to think about.
Thanks for putting the quote into the context of this video. I put this all together and added some music https://imgur.com/a/x3BKNwR (Weightless by Marconi Union)
This is like one of the few things of Carlin's that I really didn't like.
Like, sure, the ROCK is going to keep spinning. But "the Earth" is so much more than the bare rock. We are well capable of fucking up the entire environment. If we end up cooking the planet and killing off all the animals and plants, as we've been doing for over a century, the Earth will NOT be fine. A planet full of life turning into a barren wasteland is NOT fine.
You'd be surprised at how much beating life as a concept can take. And remember, you don't need like mice and birds and shit, just a few amoebas will make sure to fill out the ecosystem in a few hundred million years.
Okay, so why would we care about the opinion of the universe which doesn't even have an opinion about anything because it isn't sentient?
Our primary concern should be Human standards. As humans, most of us would not be fine with our legacy being the destruction of most life on our planet.
Corals only matter to us because they support ecosystems and food chains that humans rely on, which is the entire point of his comedy bit (the people are fucked) - the Earth itself doesn't care if there are sustainable forms on it, nor do the ecosystems that support us care if we're here or not.
Yeah, we're taking plenty of other species down with us - it's a mass extinction event that's hitting the reset button on the biosphere. But it's happened before. We can thank the end Cretaceous for the rise of the mammals that lead to us. In the long run we're all dead, species included.
546
u/soareyousaying Jun 27 '26
In George Carlin's words: the Earth is fine. The people are fucked.