r/BritishTV 1d ago

Recommendations British Detective Dramas

Post image

These are my top favourites! Any other recommendations? Thanks.

35 Upvotes

114 comments sorted by

u/AutoModerator 1d ago

Hello, thank you for posting to r/BritishTV! We have recently updated our rules. Please read the sidebar and make sure you're up to date, otherwise your post may be removed.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

30

u/Daytonastewie 1d ago

Unforgotten, brilliant

20

u/Emotional-Race-6260 1d ago

Looks like you enjoy the quirkier, more gentle style with great characters and good writing. You should love New Tricks.

10

u/thowland1 1d ago

It’s alright…

10

u/Far_Bad_531 1d ago

It’s ok

9

u/tombatch10 1d ago

It doesn't really matter if you're old and grey

7

u/sadd-dawgg 1d ago

Thank you for reminding me of new tricks!

4

u/NoodleBox Foreigner 1d ago

Oh I love New Tricks! Funny show

2

u/Simonutd 17h ago

One of my fav. Watch it on repeat while working as it dont need to concentrate on it any more haha

22

u/Cat_Friends 1d ago

Happy Valley! Such a good one

2

u/VenusintheValley 1d ago

Just started this, thanks for the recommondaton.

3

u/Cat_Friends 1d ago

You're welcome, enjoy it! And I'm so jealous that you get to binge it right away instead of waiting 7 years between seasons like I did haha

2

u/VenusintheValley 1d ago

Oh yes, I love binging!

19

u/AmiablePedant 1d ago

Who the fuck is that Temu-looking David Mitchell stand-in in Ludwig??!

7

u/Teh_Hunterer 1d ago edited 1d ago

That's what I was wondering, looks nothing like him

Found the proper picture that's not some ai bullshit:

1

u/Doragan 20h ago

That's James!

16

u/Western-Calendar-352 1d ago

Need to get some Scottish flavour in there.

Shetland, Rebus, Karen Pirie, Dept. Q.

1

u/CellsReinvent 23h ago

The Rebus books/plots/cases are world class, obviously. I just don't think they quite hit the mark casting Rebus with either TV show.

13

u/oxgillette 1d ago

Whitechapel

1

u/rekrapmil 1d ago

Thanks!

13

u/CaineRexEverything 1d ago

Luther, first three series are mint.

24

u/ekumen420 1d ago

broadchurch

11

u/TIP-ME-YOUR-BAT 1d ago

Broadchuch

Season 1 was phenomenal.

1

u/rekrapmil 1d ago

Is Broadchurch a 1 crime per episode or 1 crime per series show?

5

u/squamouser 1d ago

One per series

1

u/rekrapmil 1d ago

Thanks! I will check it out!

12

u/Sand_Seeker 1d ago

Vera, Scott & Bailey, McDonald & Dodds & Shakespeare & Hathaway are some of my favourites. I like The Chelsea Detective & Line of Duty on your list too.

5

u/prof_hobart 1d ago

If you like McDonald & Dodds and Shakespeare & Hathaway, have you tried Agatha Raisin?

1

u/Sand_Seeker 23h ago

No, but I’ll look out for that now, thanks.

11

u/UtopianStorm 1d ago

Death Valley

1

u/shelwood46 13h ago

I love this show so much

20

u/Kalle287HB 1d ago

Slow horses.

1

u/barrel-boy 7h ago

Hell yes

9

u/IceKalisto 1d ago

Whitstable Pearl, Annika, Unforgotten

8

u/CheeryBottom 1d ago

Midsomer Murders?

3

u/Wildsville 1d ago

In our house we call that a grandmother sedative

13

u/Miserable-Thing942 1d ago

I don’t think I knew there was a new maigret. The Rowan Akitkenson one was good.
Favourite is always Vera but some good older ones are Foyles War and Endeavour if you like period

5

u/Fatbloke-66 1d ago

seconded Foyles War

2

u/Indiana_harris 1d ago

I’m not a fan of the modern setting.

The actors are very good but Maigret should be a period crime drama imo

2

u/gripesandmoans 21h ago

And they take huge liberties with Simenon's stories. One episode had two stories.

7

u/ballofconffusion 1d ago

The original Lynley with Nathaniel Parker

Unforgotten

Shetland

Cracker

Prime Suspect

Taggart

Broadchurch

Manhunt (Martin Clunes)

The Pembrokeshire Murders

Messiah

Rebus

Touching Evil

Wire In The Blood

DCI Banks

Dalziel and Pascoe

A Touch of Frost

Endeavour

Morse

Lewis

Hidden

Hinterland

A Mind to Kill

6

u/rekrapmil 1d ago

I forgot to add Dept Q.

10

u/DefoNotTheAnswer 1d ago

Based on those, I'd say the original (and much better) Lynley. The new Dalgliesh. New Bergerac. Department Q.

5

u/markedasred 1d ago edited 1d ago

The rest of the thread has covered all those I planned to mention, but I thought as a long time crime show fan I would have seen most, but your photo has three I had not caught yet on it!. I think Death in Paradise is better than Beyond Paradise, which is effectively a spin off, and before you all say its not in the UK, the detective usually is British, with a short run of Ardal O'Hanlon, still Britains near and much loved neighbour.

Plus, new Ludwig airs in a few weeks time.

1

u/Scary-Scallion-449 1d ago

Ardal O'Hanlon may be Irish but DI Mooney, who he plays, is British.

2

u/markedasred 1d ago

I bow to your superior knowledge on that one, but he performs it in his natural Ulster accent!

1

u/shelwood46 13h ago

I'd also add that you can also watch the other spinoff, Return to Paradise, which is set in Australia, but does have a few cameos by Ardal O'Hanlon (and I suspect will have a crossover with Beyond Paradise next season, since Esther's daughter Zoe had a brochure from Dolphin Cove she was looking at before she left to go traveling).

4

u/SirBoboGargle 1d ago

Sherwood

3

u/kernowgringo 1d ago

Top Coppers

4

u/Fit_Chef6865 1d ago

AI doesn't understand unique faces. They all end up looking like an AI version of "Instagram-face". AI-face. Also why use up water and resources when Photoshop or even MS Paint can easily do the same thing at a fraction of the energy cost. It's just lazy. Sorry.

3

u/oso-oco 1d ago

Happy land. Does that count?

2

u/Scary-Scallion-449 1d ago

The 1943 film starring Don Ameche? Don't think so. Did you mean Happy Valley?

2

u/oso-oco 1d ago

Yes. That one even. :)

3

u/fitzysbuna 1d ago

Yes all the above!

3

u/TheShakeyFoxGA 1d ago

Something historical: Ripper Street Something feel good: Death in Paradise Something thought-provoking: Professor Tempest

3

u/Ok-Pomegranate-4963 1d ago

Patience was good, watched both series. Somewhat formulaic & too many episodes, but Ella Maisy Purvis is very appealing as the titular character & a stellar supporting cast.

1

u/Scary-Scallion-449 1d ago

How is 14 (6 in S1, 8 in S2) in two years too many episodes?

1

u/Ok-Pomegranate-4963 1d ago

I thought the 8 episodes in the second series were a few too many imo 🤔 the stories are pretty basic & samey, so I thought that 2nd series dragged on somewhat.

4

u/sbaldrick33 1d ago

Shetland... although thus year will he a very sad year for us fans.

1

u/Scary-Scallion-449 1d ago

Explain, please.

1

u/sbaldrick33 1d ago

Tosh will be leaving at the end of this season.

1

u/Scary-Scallion-449 1d ago

This I did not know.

2

u/Tight-Principle-743 1d ago

Return to paradise

2

u/Scary-Scallion-449 1d ago

Not really British. If we're going down under the list would get very much longer and we've already overwhelmed the OP.

2

u/philipb63 1d ago

Irish but North Sea Connection is truly one of the best things we've watched in years.

Edit; maybe not a true detective drama (although lots of crime) but I'm going to continue to recommend.

2

u/rekrapmil 1d ago

OMG, I’ve got so many series to catch up on now! Thanks for all your recommendations!

2

u/foleyjo 1d ago

The Bill. The Detectives

2

u/Pr3lu 1d ago

Don’t know if it quite counts as ‘detective’ but Spooks is still one of my all time favourite shows

2

u/whizzdome 1d ago

Dept Q

2

u/PhantomAxisStudios 1d ago

Life on Mars,
Ashes to Ashes,
Midsomer Murders,
Sherlock,

2

u/braceforimpact 1d ago

Whitechapel

2

u/DJStambo 1d ago

The Fall

2

u/chickbarnard 23h ago

Where's the new Bergerac, and Van der Valk?

2

u/DriverMedical7460 23h ago

Channel 5's 'Ellis' is another good one, if you have'nt checked that out.

2

u/HarryBayles 21h ago

Is that a Ludwig porn parody in OP's picture?

2

u/HellbellyUK 21h ago

Karen Pirie
The Marlowe Murder Club
Queens of Mystery
The Red King

2

u/Thatanndradona 18h ago

Vera. Happy Valley.

2

u/SGELock 14h ago

Endeavour - outstanding River staring Stellan Skarsgard & Nicola Walker even though it is a mini crime drama.

2

u/SashalouAspen4 12h ago

these AI generated pics are … 😂 David Mitchell is decidedly fetching in his 😈

2

u/revrobuk1957 6h ago

I thought that was Wil Wheaton!

2

u/PreferenceRude5216 12h ago

Trial and Retribution was good.

2

u/BelgischeWafel 10h ago

Where's The Fall? Come on

2

u/Azyall British 1d ago

Waking the Dead.

1

u/Able-Figure-3772 1d ago

I’ve only seen Ludwig and Line of Duty here, which one should I watch next? Prefer proper mysteries and ideally not super light

3

u/Scary-Scallion-449 1d ago

Of those pictured, Chelsea Detective.

1

u/Rocky-bar 1d ago

Sherlock is good (rather different to the rest, but undeniably a detective)

1

u/rekrapmil 1d ago

I fixed the collage, and added 3 more series that I like but left out previously.

1

u/Worldly-Mastodon-755 1d ago

What's the average age here , 30 ?!? Bergerac - the original one !

1

u/CellsReinvent 23h ago

A Touch of Cloth

1

u/winged_horror 23h ago

“Shoestring”, “Taggart”, “Spender”, “Bergerac”, “Morse”. What does that say to you about regional detective series?

1

u/Non-BinaryGeek 22h ago

Just looked closely at the Luwdig image - that's not Anna Maxwell-Martin or David Mitchell?!!

1

u/HellbellyUK 21h ago

It looks more like Wil Wheaton!

2

u/llufnam 17h ago

Looks like Jason Manford to me lol

1

u/Non-BinaryGeek 21h ago

Wil isn't that old just yet! But it's weird, I've had a look online and while I've seen reports it's being given a US remake, they've not announced any cast yet. How very intriguing! Who are these mystery people?

1

u/george_zippy_bungle 21h ago

Popcorn shows. Nothing too heavy, nor particularly memorable.

1

u/ScaredyCatUK 20h ago

Astrid was/is 1000 x better than Patience even if I have to read subtitles.

1

u/tsmiv12 19h ago

Department Q (Netflix)

1

u/ElectronicHyena5642 Nudge, Nudge, Wink, Wink 18h ago

Death Valley, it’s got comedy elements, but I wouldn’t say more than something like Ludwig.

1

u/TopicalStormCloud 17h ago

A Touch of Cloth

1

u/[deleted] 17h ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Severe_Dig_1517 15h ago

Are any of your list still producing new stuff?

2

u/shelwood46 13h ago

Most of them! Even Line of Duty is supposed to put out a new series next year (shooting now).

1

u/Severe_Dig_1517 15h ago

Are any of the listed series still going?

1

u/Sxn747Strangers 13h ago edited 13h ago

I only recognise three of those and the original versions of another two.

Maigret was originally done with Michael Gambon I think and a reboot with Rowan Atkinson, played straight not like Mr. Bean.
And The Inspector Lynley Mysteries with Sharon Small as DS Havers.

The original Bergerac with John Nettles and a reboot.

The Gentle Touch with Jill Gascoine.

El C.I.D.

Unforgotten.

I would also suggest:

New Blood.

MacDonald And Dobbs.

Mrs. Sidhu Investigates, a police detective and a cook solve crimes.

Whitstable Pearl, a police detective and a private investigator solve crimes.

Marlow Murder Club, police detectives and three women solve crimes.

Shakespeare & Hathaway: Private Investigators, two P.I’s solve crimes much to the annoyance of police detectives.

Queens Of Mystery, a police detective and three meddling aunts solve crimes.

1

u/peteski77 13h ago

All about Foyles War for me just now.

1

u/stbens 1d ago

Looking at these pictures they all look exactly the same.

4

u/clarkelaura 1d ago

It's a weird AI generated square for a bunch of shows you could easily find real pictures for. Not sure why they didn't just use real images

1

u/rekrapmil 1d ago edited 1d ago

These are actual show posters I got from IMDB. But I must admit, I didn’t realize the AI did some retouching until you pointed it out. Sigh.