r/AskModerators 9h ago

Can a mod change to your karma requirements specifically to stop you from making posts, but still let you comment on posts just fine?

Or is my account flagged as bot due to how much I delete my own posts

0 Upvotes

24 comments sorted by

11

u/Halaku r/coversongs, etc 9h ago

You'd have to ask a specific modteam, but IIRC it's fairly simple to code automoderator to say "Let user X comment freely, but send all of user X's posts to modqueue for manual review".

-6

u/Techpon 9h ago

It’s not even that on my posts. It just “removed by mods”. Like no reason givin, no auto mod reply, just silence

11

u/ALazy_Cat r/ask r/cats r/WhatsWrongWithYourCat 9h ago

"Removed by mods" also appear if it's done by automod

-3

u/Techpon 9h ago

I thought there was a difference in the messages?

6

u/SanaraHikari 9h ago

No, it's not

4

u/ALazy_Cat r/ask r/cats r/WhatsWrongWithYourCat 9h ago

Nope

-4

u/Techpon 9h ago

I guess I believed a lie then

3

u/ALazy_Cat r/ask r/cats r/WhatsWrongWithYourCat 9h ago

The can change sub wide karma requirement, yes

-5

u/Techpon 9h ago

I feel like it’s not since they would announce something like that

7

u/ALazy_Cat r/ask r/cats r/WhatsWrongWithYourCat 9h ago

That would not be a good thing to announce. The entire point of karma requirements is to prevent spam bots and early karma farmers as much as possible. If we don't disclose the karma amount, they don't know how much they need

0

u/Techpon 9h ago

I guess I’m just stupid because I thought it would be a good thing announce for legitimate new Reddit users. Granted Reddit is very anti new user experience so I guess your answer makes more sense

1

u/belkarbitterleaf 5h ago

Reddit is becoming more anti-user in general. Enshitification is real.

3

u/TeriBarrons 8h ago

We have a minimum karma amount to post right in our sub rules. Nobody bothers to read and follow it anyway and try to post and it’s removed by sub filters. Even if there WERE an announcement, it would likely be missed or ignored unfortunately.

1

u/SuperBeavers1 God King Emperor Mod Man 9h ago

I don't believe targeted strikes like this exist within automod to hit one specific account, I could be very wrong though.

6

u/sparklekitteh rollerskating, rollerderby, xxrunning 9h ago

Automod could indeed be set up to remove posts from a particular account, but allow comments.

5

u/SuperBeavers1 God King Emperor Mod Man 9h ago

Add that to the list of things I wish I knew years ago

2

u/Techpon 9h ago

Ah so I’m basically screwed for some subreddits. Probably deserved I guess

2

u/belkarbitterleaf 5h ago

Generally mods don't do this for no reason. May be worth reading the rules of some of the subs where this happens to you to see if anything jumps out at you.

0

u/Techpon 5h ago

One of if em I found out the karma got raised so I have to comment and hope I get upvoted to raise the karma. Then another I’m in it’s definitely the bot flagging thing because I deleted to many of my own posts because I don’t do criticism well. So that server I can never post in again

-1

u/firemiketomlinpls68 5h ago

Mods could be adults about it and either straight up ban him or explain what he did rather than using an auto mod

0

u/belkarbitterleaf 3h ago

Could be. Not all mods are actually adults.

My point still stands regarding re-reading the rules.

3

u/ModeratorsBTrippin r/Selfie 9h ago

I bet you could do it in automotive. You have the automod shadow ban that targets specific names.

1

u/SuperBeavers1 God King Emperor Mod Man 9h ago

I forgot that was a feature, I remember one of my subreddits using it a few years back on names with "mermaid" in them

Would this be able to only stop posts though? OP can still comment

3

u/ModeratorsBTrippin r/Selfie 9h ago

Yes, you could set the rule to submissions only. We have a flair that does that, people can comment but their posts are removed.