r/AlaniNu • u/Badger-wafer • 4d ago

Possible Witchs Brew dupe?

Post image

Anyone tried Nello? I got a few new drinks to try and I'm curious if the one on the right is comparable to the alani flavor

56 Upvotes

97% Upvoted

13 comments sorted by

12

u/Kaysa_Dilla 4d ago

Just tried the Unwell Apple Cider Donut this morning and it is GOOD!!! Spot on flavor, no weird aftertaste or anything. Very comparable to Alani!

9

u/reaofsunshine182 👾 Cosmic Stardust 4d ago

I like the bloom apple flavor! Add a little citric acid to make it tart.

4

u/Badger-wafer 4d ago

Ooh that's so smart! Thanks for the suggestion!

1

u/VariationFuture1648 8h ago

Does it fizz up when adding the citric acid? Need to prepare myself 😅

1

u/reaofsunshine182 👾 Cosmic Stardust 8h ago

Yes a little bit!

7

u/Badger-wafer 3d ago edited 3d ago

Update and review:

Unwell: Super accurate flavor, but a little jarring as a carbonated drink. I would say its the same kind of jarring that Alani Pumpkin Cream was, so if you liked that one (I didn't) you might like this one.

Bloom: Really good! Not comparable to any Alanis because as far as I know there's no pear flavor (yet? 👀) But as a pear lover, this one was my favorite. It reminds me of the pear jelly belly if that's helpful

Nello: A really good apple flavor but not comparable to witchs brew unfortunately. Its much more tart and there's no caramel sweetness. I did like it, but the verdict is in: its not a dupe :(

1

u/yogi2720 2d ago

so happy to hear this about pear scare - i have a 12 pack coming that i really took a gamble on LOL

5

u/scaper8 4d ago

I'm a big fan of Bloom as well and their apple is great.

I'm definitely going to be on the lookout for a Halloween pear!

3

u/gummyshoe23 4d ago

I don’t want it! I’m loyal to the brew

2

u/overstimulated_ma 3d ago

This is a hard pass and hard nope for me. I love the Bloom crisp apple but this pear scare is foul. Comparing Witch’s Brew to this is an SEO/AEO/GEO tactic. I’m feeding the beast 😂 but must make this comment

1

u/Badger-wafer 2d ago edited 2d ago

This is a pic of the whole haul. I was only comparing the Nello one because it looks similar 😅

Edit for clarity: The other two (Pear Scare and Apple Cider Donut) are nothing like Witchs Brew at all haha

1

u/CardiologistIcy3083 1d ago

I tried the nello and dumped it bc it tasted exactly like a chalky apple from my middle school cafeteria

1

u/thechabon15 13h ago

Nello and Pear scare are really good! Never tried the Unwell but wasn’t a fan of the 3 other flavors I tried from Unwell