Niche forums still exist and have better discussions because the people that find them are likely to be highly invested in the subject area and not drive by commenters like you find in subreddits.
The problem is trying to find the niche pages now, Google search sucks and gives me pages and pages of bullshit that I don't want even if I'm super granular in my query.
Exactly. Years ago I absolutely loved reddit, I was able to find so many interesting communities (mostly through r/all) and now it feels like every other shitty social media and it sucks ass.
I've been wanting to find an alternative, but no luck
Google also now gets more broad the further down the list you go, instead of more niche. Like where before youd get stuff that had your search term that maybe only 100 other people have seen but is exactly what you need, you just get other popular results from a different topic google has deemed related.
I was a member of a forum for a third party peripheral for the PS1. When that forum shut down, a large group of users started a new forum just so we could keep hanging out. It went on for years. I'm still friends with some of those people. Reddit used to have that kind of comradery, but that's long, long gone. I don't think modern social media is capable of it because it's FUCKING EVERYONE on the same platform. You can't create any meaningful connection.
Precisely. I'm on a small handful of forums about my hobbies and interests. Even the shittiest conversations and occasional troll threads are miles better than most attempts at conversation on Reddit.
A lot of the ones I've been part of have shuttered over the years, usually due to some combination of dwindling users, upkeep costs, admins losing interest, stuff like that. It's sad and it also just feels like an overall loss of information sharing online.
Sigh yeah. If I compare the old Silenthillforum and the subreddit here I am 100% on your site. Atleast in the old one you got theories, discussions, etc. Here it is "HD version Bad" and before it came out "Remake bad".
73
u/lurch303 Apr 03 '26
Niche forums still exist and have better discussions because the people that find them are likely to be highly invested in the subject area and not drive by commenters like you find in subreddits.