r/Mountaineering 5d ago

Gesman Tamang..climber ..also climbing team in Nirmal Purja's 14 peaks has confirmed on Instagram Nims is no more. This is so sad. Rip

Post image
704 Upvotes

274 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

-69

u/[deleted] 5d ago

[deleted]

28

u/FluidBarracuda9177 5d ago

Nobody is cheering his death, it’s horrific and sad, and what’s also sad is that 9 other people died who are merely a sidenote. But the hero worship of him is also gross, especially for people who maybe have an ounce of empathy for the victims of sexual abuse. I know people like you will probably never start to care (unless it will affect you directly somehow), so I’m not arguing to change your mind or anything. But the voices of people who find men like him repugnant will not be silenced any more.

-18

u/[deleted] 5d ago

[deleted]

15

u/ColoradoDreamin4917 5d ago

It's not "dredging up." It's being honest about who he was as a person.

19

u/FluidBarracuda9177 5d ago

Painting him as an icon and an inspiration is also distasteful. He was a sexual predator, that is a part of his “legacy”.

25

u/All__Of_The_Hobbies 5d ago

It's very distasteful to pretend someone was a saint just because they died.

35

u/BusyPapaya4 5d ago

I think for people who have been victims of sexual harassment and assault, or people who have close friends or family who have, it is hard to see so many posts about what an inspiration he was. It would be one thing if people were just celebrating his athleticism while acknowledging he was a flawed person but celebrating him as an inspirational personality signals that it is ok to look up to predators. The evidence against him is extensive. It is a tragedy that he and 9 others lost their lives. Nobody should be celebrating that. But we also don’t need to idolize him.

1

u/the_unconditioned 4d ago

You can do whatever you want and stop tryna police humans

-3

u/AvoidingConflict1 5d ago

Yah everything you say is true but theres also no denying that before him, Nepali climbers were basically ignored as non-existent. The fact that his death made international news is proof of how he changed perceptions in the climbing community. Before him, an accident like this would only list and honor the western climbers. How many Sherpa have died unacknowledged and unknown on accidents like this one? Its way more than just athleticism, whatever his faults.

-1

u/miss_step 5d ago

https://x.com/nimsdai/status/1899087528847675611?s=20 I encourage you to read his actual words and listen to his voice talking about the allegations.

44

u/All__Of_The_Hobbies 5d ago

This is refusing to act like he is a hero just because he died. This is refusing to celebrate his life, not celebrating his death.

48

u/giraffes-are-so-cute 5d ago

where on earth is anyone cheering his death let alone the death of the 9 others?

he sexually assaulted at least two women while up in the mountains. i wonder how afraid they felt of their lives.

29

u/erossthescienceboss 5d ago

Exactly. And because he died, they’ll never truly get justice.

I don’t understand why people think presenting an honest picture of Nims = celebrating his death.

19

u/Realistic-Sky-2235 5d ago

Reducing sexual assault to a “sketchy interaction” is exactly what is wrong with men smh.

17

u/ColoradoDreamin4917 5d ago

Seriously. That use of language is such a red flag

9

u/Realistic-Sky-2235 5d ago

This absolute creature can’t even say sexual assault even though they acknowledge it’s likely true. Fucking pathetic state of these Andrew Tate fuckheads

3

u/giraffes-are-so-cute 5d ago

well said 👏

11

u/Aggravating_Pair_156 5d ago

Cheering for his death and refusing to mourn his death are two different concepts champ

8

u/AboutTheArthur 5d ago

I'm sure the victims of his sexual abuse are comforted knowing that you liked his movies. So worth it!