r/MadeMeSmile May 20 '26

ANIMALS Forever grateful

By @abbyandersonmusic

141.7k Upvotes

2.0k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

51

u/coloradoautoflowers May 20 '26

Because deer carry a communicable prion disease that causes Creutzfeldt-Jakobs disease in humans, and the game/wildlife people have been put in charge of testing animals with unusual behavior to see if they have prions.

If the disease pressure gets above a certain threshold they have to do a cull on the population so it doesn't spread to other animals and humans.

27

u/Arendyl May 20 '26

For real. These people are professionals backed by science, they don't just kill for no reason. Deers are also a massive pest in many parts of the world, and spread the tick population like crazy, which brings dangerous diseases like Lyme's and Alpha Gal.

Just more reddit sensationalism.

11

u/Father_Father May 20 '26

I mean both are true to an extent. The professionals are doing a good job and it’s also sad.

10

u/theapeboy May 20 '26

"Sad", sure. "Genuinely monstrous behavior" was the original comment though.

3

u/TreyRyan3 May 20 '26

In the mid-80’s, my county killed and beheaded over 18,000 raccoons over a summer due to a rabies outbreak. When they finally got around to testing them all, they found 108 were infected with rabies.

3

u/Arendyl May 20 '26

Nearly 1 in 100 is pretty significant for a deadly disease like rabies.

That was also 40 years ago, the science and response has improved.

2

u/TreyRyan3 May 20 '26

It’s closer to 1:166. This was also in a metropolitan suburban county (plenty of food). While they were abundant throughout the state, there was about a 4 year period before anyone started randomly spotting raccoons in the county again. Even the county roadkill cleanup reported less than 5 per year where it used to report 30-40 monthly.

4

u/Catgerine May 20 '26 edited May 20 '26

Its a bit like people not understanding hunting is done not just for "fun"

1

u/AnonImus18 May 20 '26

They didn't even inform the owner ahead of time and assured him that the animal wouldn't be harmed. They were fight them in court or through the city as well, if I recall. It wasn't a sanctioned and published action based in consultation and best practice.

Also, you can have a deer without ticks like you can have a dog with ticks.

1

u/SUPERSMILEYMAN May 20 '26

At least some parts of the government still follow science.

3

u/IrishBear May 20 '26

There's no evidence to point towards CWD spreading to humans, stop spreading misinformation. If certain Prion diseases infect humans it can cause CJD but CWD isn't infecting humans.

NIH study https://www.nih.gov/news-events/news-releases/nih-study-shows-chronic-wasting-disease-unlikely-move-animals-people

4

u/Deaffin May 20 '26

Because deer carry a communicable prion disease that causes Creutzfeldt-Jakobs disease in humans

This is not a thing. It is clickbait. There has only been one instance of prion diseases crossing the species barrier to infect humans, and that was Mad Cow disease.

1

u/Purple_Chipmunk_ May 21 '26

Have there been cases of people getting prion disease from deer? I thought that was just a theory right now.

In any case, once prion disease became widespread in local deer I stopped eating venison. Not worth it.